How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-17 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Gionfe 120Pcs — biggest strength: 120 perforated squares measuring 8.5 x 8.5 inches, made from unbleached food-grade wood pulp and rated heat-safe up to 446°F, with an 18-month warranty behind it.
• Gionfe 120Pcs — biggest trade-off: At 8.5 inches square it can be a loose fit in a small basket, and the manufacturer's own warning is blunt — you must weigh the paper down with food covering at least two-thirds of it, or it can lift into the heating element.
• AstraGve Air Fryer Paper — biggest strength: A tight, tidy 8 x 8-inch white square that's water- and oil-resistant, sold in a 100-count pack aimed squarely at standard air fryer baskets and microwaves.
• AstraGve Air Fryer Paper — biggest trade-off: A smaller sheet with fewer stated specs — no heat rating published, no warranty mentioned, and a plain paper color that shows staining more readily than brown.
• Buy Gionfe 120Pcs if you cook larger portions, want more sheets per pack, and care about a stated temperature ceiling.
• Buy AstraGve Air Fryer Paper if your basket is on the compact side and you want a clean-looking white liner that fits it without overhang.
Gionfe's pack is built around one number: 120. That's 120 square perforated sheets at 8.5 x 8.5 inches, cut from unbleached food-grade wood pulp. The brand states they're greaseproof, waterproof and non-toxic, with no fluoresce treatment, and rated heat-safe up to 446°F (230°C) — a figure worth paying attention to, because it tells you the paper is meant to hold its shape through a normal air-frying session rather than curling up the moment hot air hits it.
Who should buy it? If you cook in batches, use a larger square or round basket, or want one paper that also handles oven baking and steaming, this is the more flexible of the two. The 120-count also means fewer reorders. Who should skip it? Anyone with a genuinely small basket — an 8.5-inch square will overhang and bunch at the corners, which is exactly the condition that makes lightweight paper lift. And heed the warning printed on the listing: always put food on top covering at least two-thirds of the sheet. That's not fine print, it's the difference between a clean basket and a scorched one.
AstraGve Air Fryer Paper: Who It's For
AstraGve goes the opposite direction: smaller, simpler, and aimed at the everyday basket. You get 100 pre-cut squares at 8 x 8 inches each. That half-inch difference sounds trivial on paper, but in a compact air fryer it's the difference between a liner that sits flat and one that curls up the sides.
The feature list is short and practical. There's a non-stick surface to stop food from clinging and to make cleanup quick. The paper is described as water- and oil-resistant, so juices and grease stay on the sheet rather than seeping through to the basket. And the stated uses are broad — air frying, baking, steaming and microwave cooking — so it covers the same ground as the Gionfe sheets, just in a smaller footprint. The color is white, which is a real preference thing: white paper reads cleaner in the basket and in photos, but it also shows browning and grease spots faster than unbleached brown.
Who should buy it? If your air fryer basket is a standard compact size and you've been trimming or fighting with oversized liners, the 8-inch cut is the whole point here. It's also a sensible pick for microwave use, where a small square is all you need and a big one just wastes paper. Who should skip it? If you want a stated heat limit, a warranty, or a count that stretches further between reorders, this pack gives you none of those on the spec sheet. And if you regularly cook for a family in a wide basket, 8 inches will leave bare metal around the edges — which is fine, but it means the liner isn't doing the full job you bought it for.
• Best for larger baskets and bigger batches → Gionfe 120Pcs. The 8.5-inch square covers more of a wide basket than an 8-inch sheet.
• Best for compact air fryers → AstraGve Air Fryer Paper. The 8-inch cut is the safer fit where overhang is a problem.
• Most sheets per pack → Gionfe 120Pcs. 120 versus 100.
• Clearest heat specification → Gionfe 120Pcs. A stated 446°F (230°C) ceiling versus no published rating for AstraGve.
• Longest stated support window → Gionfe 120Pcs. An 18-month warranty versus none mentioned for AstraGve.
• Best for oven and steamer crossover → Gionfe 120Pcs. The compatibility list explicitly includes ovens, cake pans, bamboo steamers and metal steamer pots.
• Simplest everyday air fryer and microwave liner → AstraGve Air Fryer Paper. Fewer specs, but the essentials — non-stick, water- and oil-resistant, pre-cut — are all there.
• Cleanest look in the basket → AstraGve Air Fryer Paper. White paper versus Gionfe's unbleached brown.
In my opinion, Gionfe 120Pcs is the better buy for most people. You get more sheets, a stated 446°F heat rating, an 18-month warranty, and a compatibility list that reaches past the air fryer into ovens, cake pans and steamers. The one real catch is the sizing and the flying-paper warning — both manageable if you cook with a normal portion covering the sheet.
I'd point you to AstraGve Air Fryer Paper only if your basket is small and 8.5-inch sheets have been bunching up on you, or if you specifically want white paper and don't need a published temperature rating. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before you commit — and measure your basket first, because fit matters more than anything else on this page.
Gionfe gives you 120 sheets versus AstraGve's 100, plus a stated heat rating and an 18-month warranty. On paper the Gionfe pack carries more per sheet, but value depends on the current price — check it on Amazon and compare per-sheet cost.
Gionfe states its 8.5-inch squares suit 8.5 to 9.5-inch square air fryers, 11-inch round baskets, and 10.3 to 11.2-inch oval baskets measured diagonally. If your basket is smaller than that, the 8-inch AstraGve sheets are the safer fit.
Gionfe explicitly lists ovens, cake pans, microwave ovens and bamboo or metal steamer pots as compatible. AstraGve lists air frying, baking, steaming and microwave cooking. Both are positioned as multi-use, not air-fryer-only.
Hot air circulates fast inside the basket. Gionfe's own warning says you must place food on top covering at least two-thirds of the liner, or it can lift and touch the heating element. That rule applies to any lightweight paper liner, regardless of brand.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.