How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-02 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• GEVO's biggest strength: a stronger magnetic mounting system that snaps into place automatically and stays put, plus breathable mesh fabric and slow-rebound memory foam for long listening sessions.
• GEVO's biggest trade-off: it only fits Apple AirPods Max 1 & 2 — it is useless on any other headphone brand.
• SOLYUJ's biggest strength: an original-size design with mounting clips that seat precisely, wrapped in protein leather and memory foam for a classic over-ear feel.
• SOLYUJ's biggest trade-off: it only fits Microsoft Surface Headphones Gen 1 and Surface Headphones 2 — a much narrower slice of the headphone world.
• Who GEVO is for: AirPods Max owners whose original cushions are worn, sweaty or losing their seal.
• Who SOLYUJ is for: Surface Headphones owners who want to revive a pair whose pads have flattened or flaked.
GEVO built this replacement around the way AirPods Max actually attach. The magnetic ring here is described as more powerful than a standard version, with automatic adsorption and a "tight attachment" that resists coming loose. That matters because the AirPods Max cushion system lives or dies on how well it holds. If the pads shift, the seal breaks, and the sound thins out. GEVO's answer is a stronger magnet combined with a sealing ring shaped to match the original headphone, which the brand says improves noise isolation and keeps you immersed.
The materials are where this pad separates itself from typical replacements. You get slow-rebound memory foam wrapped in mesh fabric — a combination aimed squarely at heat and moisture. Mesh breathes. It lets air move so your ears don't turn into a sauna during a long flight, a commute or a marathon work session. The enclosure also lists silicone among its materials, and the listing flags the pad as sweat resistant. In my opinion, that's the smartest part of the design: AirPods Max users tend to wear these for hours, and breathability is the difference between comfortable and clammy.
Who should skip it? Anyone who doesn't own AirPods Max. This is a single-purpose product, and the brand states plainly that it is compatible only with AirPods Max 1 & 2. If you're on Sony, Bose, Sennheiser or Surface, look elsewhere. Also skip it if you want a leather-look finish — this is a mesh-and-foam pad, and that textured fabric look is the point, not a compromise to work around.
SOLYUJ Ear Pads Replacement: Who It's For
SOLYUJ takes the opposite approach: it targets Microsoft's Surface headphones rather than Apple's. The pad is built to fit Microsoft Surface Headphones Gen 1 and Surface Headphones 2, and the design brief is clearly "match the original." The brand keeps the original size so the fit stays familiar and, in its words, the sound passes through without loss. That's the right instinct for a replacement part — you don't want a pad that changes the tuning of a headphone you already like.
Installation uses mounting clips rather than magnets. The clips are there to make sure the pad seats accurately and stays stable once it's on. It's a firmer, more mechanical approach than a magnetic snap, and for a clip-based headphone it's the correct one. The cushion itself is slow-rebound sponge, chosen so that long wear doesn't press on your ears. Anyone who has worn tight pads for a three-hour stretch knows that pressure ache, and slow-rebound foam is the standard fix.
The middle of the pad uses a dustproof mesh. That's a two-part job: it keeps debris out of the driver area while letting air reach your ear, which is how SOLYUJ frames the "your ears need to breathe" idea. The outer material is protein leather, so you get the smooth, wipe-clean surface many people expect from over-ear pads, with the memory foam underneath. Two colors are in play here — the listing shows black and grey options — and each pad measures roughly 3.54 by 1.57 by 1.18 inches, so the footprint stays close to stock.
Buy it if you own Surface Headphones Gen 1 or Surface Headphones 2 and your current pads are cracked, peeling or flattened. Buy it if you want a leather-feel surface rather than mesh. The warranty is 30 days, which is shorter than GEVO's year, so factor that into your expectations.
Skip it if you own AirPods Max or any non-Surface headphone. Skip it if you prefer a mesh, fabric-forward feel over protein leather.
• Best for AirPods Max owners → GEVO Ear Cushions Replacement. It's the only one of the two built for Apple's over-ears.
• Best for Surface Headphones owners → SOLYUJ Ear Pads Replacement. Gen 1 and Surface Headphones 2 are covered; nothing else is.
• Best for a secure, tool-free install → GEVO. The upgraded magnetic ring adsorbs automatically and resists detaching.
• Best for a precise, clip-seated fit → SOLYUJ. Mounting clips are designed to lock the pad into the correct position.
• Best for hot ears and long sessions → GEVO. Mesh fabric plus slow-rebound memory foam is the breathability play.
• Best for a smooth, leather-look surface → SOLYUJ. Protein leather over memory foam, easy to wipe down.
• Best for noise isolation → GEVO. Its sealing ring is explicitly designed to match the original and improve isolation.
• Best for a longer coverage window → GEVO. One year of manufacturer warranty versus 30 days on the SOLYUJ pads.
If I owned AirPods Max, I'd buy the GEVO Ear Cushions Replacement. The magnetic mounting, breathable mesh and slow-rebound foam are the three things that actually matter when you replace a wear item on that headphone, and the year-long warranty backs it up. If I owned Surface Headphones instead, I'd buy the SOLYUJ pads without hesitation — the original-size design and clip mounting are exactly what that headphone needs. Match the pad to your headphone first; everything else is a distant second. In my opinion, that's the whole decision.
Yes. GEVO states the cushions fit both AirPods Max 1 and AirPods Max 2. They are not compatible with any other headphone brand.
Yes. SOLYUJ lists compatibility with Microsoft Surface Headphones Gen 1 and Surface Headphones 2, and uses mounting clips to seat the pads accurately.
GEVO uses a magnetic design with automatic adsorption, so the pads snap on with no tools. SOLYUJ uses mounting clips that press into place for a stable, precisely seated fit.
Prices change often on Amazon, so use the "Check latest price on Amazon" button on this page for the live figure on either product.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Iwinna Kids Noise Cancelling vs TSYUCXH Over Ear Headphones, Generic Hybrid Noise Cancelling vs sajawass Earbuds Headphones, JVC Gumy Gamer vs AIAUXAI USB Earbuds, Turnstile Audio TAPH700 vs Mackie EM-91C: Closed Back Studio