How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-02 · 5 min read · Independent comparison
• GEEKRIA's biggest strength: It's a proven, no-drama repair part for the classic Bose QuietComfort QC1, made with memory foam and protein leather and backed by a one-year manufacturer warranty.
• GEEKRIA's biggest trade-off: It's built for QC1 specifically, so if you own anything else, you're gambling on dimensions — the listing even tells you to check them.
• Miruchertter's biggest strength: High-density memory foam wrapped in soft leather that's designed to seal out outside noise and preserve the sound of your W820NB.
• Miruchertter's biggest trade-off: It only lists one compatible model (Edifier W820NB), so it's useless for anything else, and it's a single-purpose pick.
• Buy GEEKRIA if you're reviving a Bose QuietComfort QC1 and want a simple two-pad replacement kit.
• Buy Miruchertter if you own an Edifier W820NB and your current pads are flat, torn, or uncomfortable.
GEEKRIA's pitch here is simple: your Bose QuietComfort QC1 pads wore out, and you want to fix that without buying a whole new headset. The pads are made from memory foam and protein leather, the same basic recipe most factory cushions use, and the kit ships as two ear pads. That's it. No tools, no adapters, no surprises — you pull the old cushions and press the new ones on.
The headphones themselves aren't included, which is worth stating plainly because it trips people up. What you're buying is the repair part, nothing more. In my opinion, that's exactly what a QC1 owner wants: a cheap, boring fix for a headphone that's still perfectly good otherwise. The dimensions are listed at 3.54 x 2.87 x 0.39 inches, and there's a one-year manufacturer warranty behind them, so if the fit is wrong, you have somewhere to go.
Who should buy it? Someone with a Bose QuietComfort QC1 whose pads have gone shiny, cracked, or flattened. Someone who liked the original feel and wants it back. Who should skip it? Anyone who doesn't own a QC1 — or who owns a newer Bose model and is hoping these will stretch to fit. GEEKRIA notes the pads may suit other brands and models, but only if the dimensions match, and that's a check you have to do yourself. If you're not sure, measure before you order.
Miruchertter takes a slightly different angle. The W820NB pads are pitched as an upgrade, not just a repair. The material list is the selling point: high-density memory foam under a softer leather cover, described as durable, flexible, and hard to tear. The claim that stands out is the noise-blocking one — the foam is meant to seal the ear cup so outside sound stays out and the W820NB's original tuning stays intact. That matters, because a worn pad with a bad seal is the single most common reason a headphone suddenly sounds thin.
Compatibility is narrow and clearly stated: Edifier W820NB, and that's the only model listed. The package is one pair of pads, headphone not included. Miruchertter also puts a two-year manufacturer warranty on the product, which is generous for a consumable part like this.
Who should buy it? An Edifier W820NB owner whose pads have gone stiff or started flaking. Someone who finds the stock cushions too firm and wants something softer against the ear. Who should skip it? Anyone without a W820NB. There's no cross-compatibility claim here, no "check your dimensions" hedge — it's a one-model part, and that's fine as long as you're that one model.
• Best for Bose QuietComfort QC1 owners → GEEKRIA Replacement Ear Pads, since that's the exact model it's built for.
• Best for Edifier W820NB owners → Miruchertter W820NB, which lists that headphone and nothing else.
• Best if you want a cushion that seals and preserves sound → Miruchertter, which explicitly targets outside-noise blocking.
• Best if you want the simplest, most predictable repair → GEEKRIA, a two-pad kit with a one-year warranty and no upgrade talk.
• Best warranty coverage → Miruchertter, at two years versus GEEKRIA's one, if that length of coverage matters to you.
• Best if you're unsure about fit → GEEKRIA, which at least acknowledges that other models exist and tells you to check dimensions first.
• Best if you just want to stop thinking about it → whichever one matches the headphone you actually own. That's the whole decision.
My Verdict
If I had to pick one, I'd go with Miruchertter W820NB — but only because the choice is really about which headphone you own, not which pad is objectively better. Assuming you have an Edifier W820NB, the softer leather, high-density foam, explicit noise-sealing claim, and two-year warranty make it the more complete package in my opinion. If you own a Bose QuietComfort QC1, GEEKRIA is the correct answer and Miruchertter won't fit at all. Buy the one that matches your model. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since that's the one variable that can shift your call.
GEEKRIA Replacement Ear Pads. They're explicitly compatible with the Bose QuietComfort QC1. Miruchertter's pads list only the Edifier W820NB, so they aren't the right part for a Bose headset.
That's their stated design goal. The memory foam is meant to seal the ear cup, which both keeps outside sound out and preserves the W820NB's original sound. A proper seal is the main thing a fresh pad restores.
Yes to a pair, no to the headphone. Both products ship as two ear pads only. GEEKRIA lists 2 x Ear Pad and Miruchertter lists 1 pair, and both state clearly that the headphones are not part of the package.
GEEKRIA lists a one-year manufacturer warranty. Miruchertter lists a two-year manufacturer warranty. If you'd rather have the longer coverage window, that points to Miruchertter.
Only if the fit works out. GEEKRIA says the pads may suit other brands and models but tells you to check the dimensions against your headphones first. Miruchertter makes no cross-compatibility claim, so I'd treat it as W820NB-only.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Jacuate Open Ear Earbuds vs RAOPINGX TWS Earbuds, YuShaTra Headphone vs L LTGEM Headphone Headset Case, FANVERIM 3'2 vs QMHL Swimming Headphones-Bone Conduction, RORSOU B10 vs ONIKUMA GAMING T27