Newspaper Article: Pak Man jelas cara buat minyak gamat, June 14, 1992
This article features Pak Man, a Malay merchant that specializes in the production of the minyak gamat commodity, who is located in Pulau Pangkor.
It tells us one method of the extraction of sea cucumber oil from sea cucumbers by the locals.
Newspaper Article: Teori Dr. John N. Miksic, Pakar Kajipurba, 2 May 1992
This article presents Miksic's theory on the reasons for trade between the Orang Laut and China - highlighting the exchange of sea cucumber as it was believed to have medicinal benefits.
Newspaper Advertisement: Weekend East, 5 September 1986
This advertisement shows sea cucumbers sold in a popular Japanese department store, Yaohan, in 1986. Due to the increased interest of sea cucumbers as a Chinese delicacy, Yaohan offered both salted sea cucumbers and fresh sea cucumbers for sale. It is worth noting that the fresh sea cucumbers were most likely obtained locally due to the absence of a country of origin.
Newspaper Article: Trepang Seekers, 9 August 1922
This article is taken from the Singapore Free Press and Mercantile Advertiser that was catered to the commercial and shipping uses of colonial Singapore. It talks about trepang trade in the Great Barrier Reef and the usage of Japanese/Malay natives to go trepang fishing. It is highlighted that the natives were not scared of marine threats such as sharks and shows the supposed resilience of the native people when it came to the arduous task of sea cucumber fishing in the seas.
Newspaper Article: Warlike Natives, 18 August 1909
This article documents the experience of an Australian pearl fisher who tried out sea cucumber fishing along the Liverpool River in Australia. It documents his experience supposedly getting attacked by the natives of the Liverpool River. Surprisingly, Mcpherson (the pearl fisher guy) suspects that the locals attacked him to steal his cigarette commodity while our group theorizes that they attacked him due to unwarranted fishing in the aborigines' territory.
Newspaper Article: Marine Discovery at Hong Kong, 27 July 1907
This article shares about the discovery of sea cucumber, specifically the holothuria edulis species in Hong Kong waters. At the time, it is to note that the British had colonized Hong Kong. The presence of trepang in waters other than Japan and the publishing of the article can show the British's interest in tapping in on the booming sea cucumber trade like in Japan.
Newspaper Article: A Dutch Restriction, 28 October 1898
This article shows the implementation of a decree issued by the Netherlands-Indie that states that a permit or license is required to fish trepang in Dutch territorial waters. The decree however, only applies to foreign ships and is not enforced on the local populations.
Newspaper Article: Some of Ceylon's exports, 5 September 1895
This article shows the export values of sea cucumber from Ceylon and brought in revenues of Rs. 21,275 (roughly SGD 346.77) and how the Chinese market is the largest consumer of sea cucumber.
Straits Settlements: Penang Consultations, 21 August 1826
This is an excerpt from the Straits Settlements record found in the National Archives of Singapore. It discusses the price of and tax that is imposed on sea cucumber (also known as beche de mer during colonial times) exports from Singapore.
"甘咸温.补肾益精.壮阳疗痿.辽海产者良.(周栎园闽小记云∶闽中海参、色独白、类撑以竹签、大如掌、与胶州辽海所出异、味亦淡劣、海上人复有以生革伪为之以愚人、不足尚也、胶州所出、生北海咸水中、色又黑、以滋肾水、从其类也.)有刺者名刺参.无刺者名光参.以上无鳞类."
Book Excerpt: 海参 (海蔘) from Ben Cao Cong Xin 本草从新, 1757
This excerpt from the Ben Cao Gong Xin, a medical text from China during the Qing dynasty, shows the various uses of sea cucumber and its medicinal properties in traditional Chinese medicine.
Online News Article: Historic cultural link and a rare delicacy, February 9, 2012
This article helps us in the understanding of relationships between people from different regions - in this case the Macassans and the Aboriginal Australians and the synergy between them in maritime history and threads brought together the selling of sea cucumbers to different parts of the world, China, which deemed sea cucumbers as exotic.
The taxonomy and exploitation of sea cucumbers in Malaysia
This article on the taxonomy and exploitation of sea cucumbers in Malaysia is an informative article showcasing the statistics of sea cucumbers in Malaysia from 1982 to 1995, be it the exportation and importation of sea cucumbers. The article surveyed different regions in Malaysia, especially the ones that are geographically-distinct areas such as Langkawi island, Pangkor island and Tioman island.
From digesting the article, it helps in the understanding of the demand for sea cucumber in Malaysia, especially when Langkawi island prides itselves with the dominant sea cucumber oil industry. To sustain the high demand for the sea cucumber oil, it was reported in the article that “The product eventually became so popular that around the mid-1940, Langkawi traders began to import sea cucumbers from Thai fishermen”. This emphasises the importance of maritime trade on sea animals between neighbouring countries, which in this case would be between Thailand and Malaysia. However, this could also mean that there were practices of over intensive fishing practices in Langkawi which had a negative impact on the local sea cucumber populations.
Overview of sea cucumber and sea ranching practices in China
This secondary source helps in the understanding of the sea cucumber in a wider perspective - going away from the Malay perspective on the benefits of sea cucumber. The history of sea cucumber consumption could be traced back all the way to the Ming Dynasty (1368-1644) where sea cucumber was recorded in the Bencao Gangmu, a famous materia medica written by Li Shizhen. Sea cucumber was denoted as a tonic and a traditional medicine in many ancient writings such as Shiwu Bencao, Bencao Gangmu Shiyi, Wuzazu and Bencao Congxin - in which it was dated in Ming and Qing Dynasty.
Going back to the main idea of the topic presentation, we could then understand the “linearage” of sea cucumber and the uses of sea cucumber in different countries, which in this case is between Malaysia and China. Despite the vast differences in uses of the sea cucumber, there is a commonality that the sea cucumber has various health benefits.
Fisheries, trade and utilization of sea cucumbers in Malaysia
The exploitation of sea cucumbers in Malaysia has implications for the maritime world, particularly for the sustainability of sea cucumber populations and the livelihoods of those who depend on them. Overfishing of sea cucumbers can lead to the depletion of populations, which can have cascading effects on the ecosystem. Additionally, the trade and utilisation of sea cucumbers can have economic impacts on the fishing industry and the communities that rely on it. The report notes that the trade of sea cucumbers is an important source of income for many coastal communities in Malaysia, and that the demand for sea cucumbers in international markets has led to increased exploitation of this resource. Therefore, it is important to manage sea cucumber fisheries sustainably to ensure their long-term viability and to support the livelihoods of those who depend on them.
Serial Exploitation of Global Sea Cucumber Fisheries
The overfishing of sea cucumbers is a significant issue in many maritime countries, as they are a valuable commodity that is in high demand. The journal highlights the need for a more sustainable approach to managing these fisheries, which considers the broader ecosystem and the long-term survival of the species. The authors suggest that this approach could help to address the current overfishing crisis and ensure that sea cucumbers continue to play an important role in the maritime economy.
Jewel of the seabed: sea cucumbers as nutritional and drug candidates
In the journal, Kiew Peck Loo, and Mashitah Mat Don explored the potential of sea cucumbers as a source of nutrition and medicinal compounds. The authors note that sea cucumbers have long been used in traditional medicine in many cultures such as the Chinese and Malay, and recent research has shown that they contain a variety of bioactive compounds with potential health benefits. These compounds include polysaccharides, glycosides, and peptides, which have been shown to have anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and anticancer properties.
Sea cucumber extract has been found to have wound healing properties, and this study highlights the importance of the oil phase in enhancing its activity. Sea cucumbers are marine animals that are commonly found in the ocean, and they have been used in traditional medicine for their various health benefits. This study's findings could have implications for the development of new wound healing creams that utilise sea cucumber extract and different types of oil phase to enhance their activity. Overall, this study provides insight into the potential of sea cucumber extract as a wound healing agent and the importance of the oil phase in its formulation.
Aktivitas Gel Kombinasi Ekstrak Rimpang Kunyit Dan Gel Gamat Terhadap Penyembuhan Luka
This reading supports the earlier secondary source, “Influence of oil phase on the wound healing activity of sea cucumber extract based cream foundations” whereby the reading helps in the understanding of the benefits of using sea cucumber in a more scientific manner than just understanding it from word of mouth. This accentuates the reliability of minyak gamat benefits and goodness which helps to answer doubts and queries from people who find the idea of sea cucumber being beneficial absurd. Additional information which has no relations to the main idea of the topic proposal would be that the study showed that the combination mixture of turmeric extract and gamat get has a significant effect on wound healing.
Pepper to sea cucumbers: Chinese gustatory revolution in global history, 900-1840
This dissertation aimed to investigate how pepper and sea cucumbers respectively became significant exports from Southeast Asia to China in the early modern period. Xu (2021) argued that they form two different eras in Chinese food history, where sea cucumbers formed the second era of food prominence from the late sixteenth to eighteenth century stages. He argues that the change from pepper to sea cucumber was fueled by a Chinese medicinal debate that occurred from the fourteenth to seventeenth century, alongside the maritime expansion of the Manchus, the Dutch, and the British in the areas around the Chinese seas.
The primary sources shed light on the commodification of sea cucumber in the Indian and western Pacific ocean regions. It highlights the trade of sea cucumber between major polities such as China and native people prior to the 1900s, as evidenced by the Straits Settlement records, traditional Chinese medicinal texts and sources documenting the process of sea cucumber farming by the native people.
Sea cucumber trade was not only limited to Japan and the Nusantara regions such as Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia but was also done so by the aborigines in Australia and in Ceylon. However, it is worth noting that the aborigines in Australia had fished the sea cucumber as a form of subsistence and used it in their cooking as compared to the other regions that were trading it as a commodity, with China being the main importer of sea cucumber due to interests in supposed medicinal properties (stated in the Ben Cao Gang Mu) and thus made into a Chinese delicacy.
Colonial powers, namely the British, were interested in this sea cucumber trade and had changed trajectory from marine fishing of pearls to sea cucumber. As seen in our secondary sources, it caused an overexploitation of sea cucumbers and the aborigines were unhappy about this new vested interest in their source of food. Thus, the native people resisted against the colonial powers and launched attacks on their vessels. Once again, it is note-worthy that the aborigines in Australia resisted this change whereas those in the Malay region worked under the colonial powers, providing these foreigners with priceless emic knowledge and experience of sea cucumber fishing.
Anderson, Sean C, Joanna Mills Flemming, Reg Watson, and Heike K Lotze, “Serial Exploitation of Global Sea Cucumber Fisheries”. Fish and Fisheries 12 (3): 317–39, December 30 2010, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-2979.2010.00397.x. (accessed September 20, 2023)
Chen Jiaxin, “Overview of sea cucumber and sea ranching practices in China,” SPC Beche-de-mer Information Bulletin #18, May 2003, pp 18-23, http://www.spc.int/DigitalLibrary/Doc/FAME/InfoBull/BDM/18/BDM18_18_Chen.pdf (accessed September 10, 2023)
Choo Poh-Sze, “Fisheries, trade and utilization of sea cucumbers in Malaysia,” FAO Fish Technical Paper (463), 2004, pp 57-68, https://digitalarchive.worldfishcenter.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.12348/2040/2335.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y (accessed September 20, 2023)
Guanmian Xu, “Pepper to sea cucumbers: Chinese gustatory revolution in global history, 900-1840”, (November 10, 2021). https://hdl.handle.net/1887/3239180 (accessed September 12, 2023)
Ismail, Latifah, "Pak Man jelas cara buat minyak gamat." June 14, 1992. From Berita Harian. https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/article/beritaharian19920614-1.2.24.1.2 (accessed September 12, 2023)
Lina Noviyanti Sutardi, Aulia Andi Mustika, Andriyanto, Rahmawati Januar, and Aisyah Nurfitria Ayumi. “Aktivitas Gel Kombinasi Ekstrak Rimpang Kunyit Dan Gel Gamat Terhadap Penyembuhan Luka”. Acta VETERINARIA Indonesiana 10, no. 2 (2022): 193–200. https://doi.org/10.29244/avi.10.2.193-200. (accessed September 15, 2023)
Mark Baine and Bobby Forbes, “The taxonomy and exploitation of sea cucumbers in Malaysia,” SPC Beche-de-mer Information Bulletin #10, May 1998, pp 2-7, http://www.spc.int/DigitalLibrary/Doc/FAME/InfoBull/BDM/10/BDM10_02_Baines.pdf (accessed September 19, 2023)
Peak Loo Kiew, Mashitah Mat Don. “Jewel of the seabed: sea cucumbers as nutritional and drug candidates.” International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition volume 63, no. 5 (December 2011): 616-636. https://doi.org/10.3109/09637486.2011.641944 (accessed September 23, 2023)
Pinang Gazette and Straits Chronicle, “Some of Ceylon’s Exports.” September 5, 1895. From Pinang Gazette and Straits Chronicle. https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/article/pinangazette18950905-1.2.24?qt=trepang&q=trepang (accessed October 12, 2023)
Salleh, Saini, “ Teori Dr. John N. Miksic, Pakar Kajipurba.” May 2, 1992. From Berita Harian. https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/page/beritaharian19920502-1.1.12 (accessed September 29, 2023)
Straits Settlement. A24: Penang Consultations Page 520 of 567, August 21, 1826. Manuscript. From National Archives of Singapore, Raffles Museum and Library. https://www.nas.gov.sg/archivesonline/private_records/record-details/881d7763-b5e3-11ea-a812-001a4a5ba61b (accessed October 23, 2023)
The Canberra Times, “Historic cultural link and a rare delicacy.” February 9, 2012. From The Canberra Times. https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6177199/historic-cultural-link-and-a-rare-delicacy/ (accessed September 29, 2023)
The Singapore Free Press and Mercantile Advertiser, “ Trepang Seekers.” August 9, 1922. From The Singapore Free Press and mercantile Advertiser. https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/article/singfreepressb19220809-1.2.3?qt=trepang&q=trepang (accessed October 2, 2023)
The Straits Budget, “A Dutch Restriction.” October 28, 1898. From The Straits Budget. https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/article/straitsbudget18981028-1.2.58?qt=trepang&q=trepang (accessed October 1, 2023)
The Straits Times, “Marine Discovery at Hong Kong.” July 28, 1907. From The Straits Times. https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/article/straitstimes19070727-1.2.26?qt=sea,%20cucumber&q=sea%20cucumber (accessed October 4, 2023)
The Straits Times, “Warlike Natives.” August 18, 1909. From The Straits Times. https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/article/straitstimes19090818-1.2.94?qt=trepang&q=trepang (accessed October 2, 2023)
Thiviya Sunmugam, Hanisah Azhari, Shiow-Fern Ng, Fazren Azmi. “Influence of the Oil Phase on the Wound Healing Activity of Sea Cucumber Extract Based Cream Formulations.” Sains Malaysiana 50, (3 March 2021): 839-847. https://doi.org/10.17576/jsm-2021-5003-24 (accessed September 20, 2023)
Wu, Yiluo, “海参 (海蔘).” 本草从新, Volume 18, Qing Dynasty 1757 AD. https://www.zysj.com.cn/lilunshuji/bencaocongxin/index.html (accessed October 10, 2023)
Yaohan, “At All Yaohan Stores. Festive Favourites.” Advertisement. From Weekend East. September 5, 1986. https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/article/weekendeast19860905-1.2.10.1?qt=sea,%20cucumber&q=sea%20cucumber (accessed September 29, 2023)