How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Freshware's biggest strength: 24 separate food-grade silicone cups in six rainbow colors, each roughly 2.8 inches across the top, so you can bake a few, freeze a few, and use the rest as lunchbox dividers or air fryer molds.
• Freshware's biggest trade-off: each cup is small and floppy on its own, so you'll want to set them on a tray before filling, and the manufacturer itself suggests a light butter spray for cleaner release.
• CAKETIME's biggest strength: six genuinely jumbo wells — 3.5 inches across the top, 2.7 inches at the base, 1.8 inches deep — for bakery-style oversized muffins and frittatas that small standard cups simply can't hold.
• CAKETIME's biggest trade-off: it's one pan in one light blue color with a fixed six-cup layout, and because silicone is flexible you must support it on a metal tray or cookie sheet before filling.
• Who Freshware is for: grazers, meal-preppers and air fryer tinkerers who want many small, reusable, multi-purpose cups.
• Who CAKETIME is for: anyone who wants big, dramatic, single-batch bakes — giant muffins, deep frittatas, oversized english muffin rounds.
Freshware sells you a set of 24 individual round cups, each about 2.8 inches across the top, 1.8 inches at the base and 1.2 inches tall. They're made of food-grade, BPA-free silicone and rated from -104°F to 446°F, which covers the freezer, fridge, microwave, oven, air fryer and dishwasher. That heat range plus the flexibility is the whole point: one cup can go from freezing fat bombs to baking mini pot pies to holding sauce in a bento box, and then straight into the dishwasher.
The non-stick story here is a coating-free one — there's no aluminum and no applied non-stick layer, which is why Freshware frames these as the healthier alternative to metal tins. Practically, silicone this flexible still benefits from a little help: the brand recommends a light spray of butter for the cleanest release. That's a fair caveat, not a dealbreaker.
Who should buy it? If you cook in small portions, batch-prep breakfast egg muffins for the week, pack lunches, or want something that does double duty as a divider and a mold, 24 loose cups give you options a single pan never will. Six colors also make it easy to keep flavors or portions sorted. Who should skip it? If your goal is one pan of six huge muffins, this isn't that product — a 24-pack of small cups means filling and moving many pieces, and each cup is small enough that a jumbo muffin recipe won't fit.
CAKETIME takes the opposite approach: one light blue silicone pan with six big wells. Each cup measures 3.5 inches across the top, 2.7 inches at the bottom and 1.8 inches deep — noticeably wider and deeper than a standard cup, which is exactly what "jumbo" should mean. The pan as a whole measures roughly 12.28 by 8.39 inches with a very slim 0.47-inch profile, so it stores flat and slides into tight cabinets.
It's 100T food-grade silicone, BPA-free, and shares the same -104°F to 446°F range as the Freshware cups, so oven, microwave, dishwasher, fridge and freezer are all fair game. The polished surface is designed so muffins press out from the bottom with a finger — that's the release method the brand describes. One important usage note straight from the maker: because silicone is flexible, you should set the pan on a metal tray or cookie sheet before filling. Do that and it behaves; skip it and a loaded pan of batter will wobble.
Who should buy it? Anyone baking giant homemade muffins, deep frittatas, cornbread muffins, mini pumpkin pies or cheesecakes who wants one sturdy, wide format rather than many small cups. Who should skip it? If you want variety, portion control, or the ability to freeze a couple of items while baking others, a single six-cup pan locks you into one shape and one color. It also can't act as a lunchbox divider or a soap mold the way loose cups can.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer english muffin projects in small batches → Freshware Silicone Baking Cups. Loose cups fit whatever space your air fryer basket gives you, and you can cook two or ten without heating an entire pan.
• Best for jumbo, bakery-style muffins → CAKETIME Jumbo Muffin Pan. The 3.5-inch top and 1.8-inch depth give you a genuinely oversized well.
• Best for one-pan frittatas or egg bakes → CAKETIME Jumbo Muffin Pan. Six deep wells hold a real portion each, and the maker notes it's suited to breakfast egg bites.
• Best for freezer-to-oven flexibility → Freshware Silicone Baking Cups. Individual cups freeze and reheat independently.
• Best for easy release with minimal fuss → CAKETIME Jumbo Muffin Pan. The polished surface is designed for finger-press release; Freshware suggests a light butter spray for the cleanest demolding.
• Best for color variety and gifting → Freshware Silicone Baking Cups. Six rainbow colors in a set of 24.
• Best for flat, space-saving storage → CAKETIME Jumbo Muffin Pan. It's only about half an inch tall when empty.
• Best for portion control → Freshware Silicone Baking Cups. Small cups mean small, consistent servings.
In my opinion, most people torn between these two should buy the Freshware Silicone Baking Cups. Twenty-four reusable cups cover more of the everyday jobs — breakfast egg muffins, air fryer english muffin experiments, lunchbox dividers, freezing and reheating — and the -104°F to 446°F range means one purchase handles the freezer, oven and air fryer. I'd only steer you to the CAKETIME Jumbo Muffin Pan if your heart is set on big: six wide, deep wells for giant muffins, frittatas and oversized bakes that small cups can't match. If you bake jumbo portions regularly, CAKETIME is the one. If you want versatility, Freshware wins. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever fits your kitchen.
FAQ
how to air fry english muffins
Split the english muffin and place the halves in your air fryer basket, cut side up. A loose silicone cup like the Freshware ones is handy for holding toppings or a cracked egg alongside, since it's rated for air fryer heat. Cook until the edges crisp and the inside is warm, then fill.
Top each split half with sauce and cheese, then air fry until the cheese melts and the edges toast. Because loose silicone cups fit irregular basket shapes, the Freshware set lets you air fry a couple of portions without heating a whole pan — useful when you're cooking for one or two.
how to make air fryer english muffin pizzas
Build them the same way you would in an oven: sauce, cheese and toppings on split muffins. If you want a deeper, cup-style version, the CAKETIME Jumbo Muffin Pan's 1.8-inch-deep wells can hold a thicker bake — just set the pan on a tray first, as the maker advises.
how long to air fryer english muffin pizzas
Timing depends on your air fryer and how loaded the muffins are, so start checking early and pull them when the cheese bubbles and the edges brown. Silicone cups and pans rated to 446°F handle the heat fine; the real variable is your basket's airflow.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: BiaoGan Stackable Egg Steamer vs Monfish muffin pan Jumbo, HEIPON Perforated Silicone Baking vs Yomvzake Air Fryer Jumbo, GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan vs Miliocry Cupcake Liners