Stocks with Josh Review: 7,300+ Members, Custom TradingView Bots, and Two Very Different Tiers

Most trading communities follow the same playbook: a Discord server, some chart screenshots, and a creator who posts after the move already happened. When I first came across Stocks with Josh on Whop, I was skeptical for exactly that reason. Another trading group, another set of promises.

After spending time with both tiers of the community and getting hands-on with the TradingView tools included, I can say this one is a different animal from the typical Discord trading server. The short answer to whether it's worth joining? Yes, with some caveats depending on which tier fits your situation.

?? CHECK THE CURRENT PRICING AND JOIN STOCKS WITH JOSH

Here's the longer version.

What Stocks with Josh Actually Is (Beyond the Pitch)

Stocks with Josh is a trading education community built around a Discord server and a suite of custom TradingView tools that are delivered directly to your charts when you join. The platform has been operating since 2024 and has grown to over 7,300 store members across its offerings. That's a meaningful number for a community that's still relatively young.

The operator behind it goes by stockswithjosh (username: stockcryptobots) on Whop, and there's a public website and YouTube channel attached to the brand. I found the YouTube content useful for getting a sense of Josh's actual charting approach before committing to anything, which I'd recommend doing as part of your research.

The community runs through Discord, and access is gated and managed through the Whop platform. PayPal is the accepted payment method, so keep that in mind at checkout.

Breaking Down What You Actually Get

This is where it gets interesting, because Stocks with Josh isn't just "join the Discord and get alerts." The toolkit is more layered than that.

When you join, you get access to a set of custom TradingView indicators and dashboards that are specific to this community. At the time I checked, the tools included:

• A+ Scalp Dashboard (TradingView) - a proprietary dashboard designed around scalp trade setups

• GOAT Scalp Levels (TradingView) - key price level overlays for identifying scalp entry and exit zones

• GOAT Scalps ALPHA (TradingView) - what appears to be an enhanced or earlier-access version of the scalp indicator suite

• Profit Windows (TradingView) - a tool that highlights specific time-based or price-based windows where trade setups tend to develop

On the Discord side, you get access to the Chart Goat Master V1 and the Trader Tier channels, along with an onboarding guide that walks you through the Whop-to-Discord linking process step by step.

For anyone new to TradingView, it's the dominant web-based charting platform used by retail traders. Custom indicators like the ones included here are published to your TradingView account and show up directly on your charts. You don't need to write any code or configure anything manually. That's a genuine convenience advantage over communities that just share screenshots in a chat.

The scalp focus is worth flagging. Scalping means taking short-duration trades, often holding for minutes rather than days or weeks. It requires attention and some baseline familiarity with how to read a chart. If you're brand new to trading, give yourself a few weeks on TradingView with free indicators first to get comfortable before expecting to extract maximum value here.

The Two Tiers: Chart Goat U vs. SWJ Trader Tier

There are two distinct products, and they're aimed at different types of members.

Chart Goat U is the education-forward option. At $100/month (or $240 every three months, or $1,050/year at the time I checked), it's the lower-priced entry point. The 94 current members in this tier suggests it's a more intimate group, which can actually be a feature depending on what you're looking for. University-style implies structured learning content, and the platform positioning around "transforming your trading skills" tracks with that.

SWJ Trader Tier is the VIP access product. Pricing here is more aggressive: $60/week, $200/month, or $1,500/year. With 364 members at that tier, it's clearly the more active community. What you get for that price is worth laying out directly:

• Priority chart requests (you can submit a ticker and Josh will analyze it)

• Weekly live trading sessions that started in July 2024

• VIP meet-and-greet events

• Quarterly exclusive "Chart GOAT" gifts for registered members

• Full access to the SWJ Discord

The weekly live sessions are what makes the Trader Tier price make more sense to me. Learning live alongside someone who's actually reading the tape is how a lot of traders accelerate their development. Reading about a setup and watching someone navigate it in real time are completely different experiences.

?? SEE THE FULL TIER BREAKDOWN YOURSELF BEFORE DECIDING

The TradingView Tools Are the Real Differentiator

Most trading Discord communities are just chat rooms with occasional chart posts. What separates Stocks with Josh from that category is the TradingView indicator suite.

I've used a lot of third-party TradingView indicators over the years. Some are genuinely useful, some are just repackaged moving average combos with fancy names. The scalp-focused framing here, specifically the idea of "profit windows" and "A+ scalp levels," suggests these tools are built around identifying specific market conditions rather than just overlaying generic trend lines. The naming convention (Alpha, GOAT, A+) also implies there's versioning and ongoing development happening, which is a good sign.

One thing I noticed in the FAQ: Josh explicitly warns members that he will never DM you or send friend requests on Discord. That's a detail that stands out, because it means the community is big enough that scammers have tried to impersonate him. It's actually a backhanded indicator that the brand has enough visibility to attract that kind of attention. Report anything suspicious and you'll be fine.

What the Reviews Say

Across both products, there are 9 total reviews with an average rating of 4.67 out of 5. The breakdown: six 5-star reviews, three 4-star reviews, and zero reviews below 4 stars.

That's a clean record. No 1-star, no 2-star, no 3-star. For a community operating since 2024 with thousands of total members, a floor of 4 stars with majority 5-star feedback tells you something. People who joined and took the time to leave a review were, by and large, satisfied.

Public reviews on Whop are tagged with buyer status, so you can see who actually paid for access. I'd encourage you to check the current reviews yourself rather than taking my word for it.

Pricing and Value: Is It Competitive?

Let's be direct about the numbers because they're meaningful.

The Chart Goat U tier at $100/month is fairly standard for a trading education community with custom tooling attached. For context, standalone TradingView indicator scripts with similar specificity can run $30?$80/month on their own. Bundling that with Discord community access and structured education content at $100/month is reasonable.

The SWJ Trader Tier at $200/month (or the weekly $60 option if you want to test the water) is a bigger commitment. But the weekly option is genuinely useful here: $60 for a week lets you attend at least one live trading session, get a priority chart request answered, and evaluate whether the community's rhythm fits how you trade. That's a low-risk entry point for a premium tier.

Annually, the $1,050 and $1,500 price points represent meaningful discounts over paying monthly. If you've been a member for two or three months and the tools are working for you, it's worth doing the math before your next billing cycle.

One thing to be aware of: the refund policy is clear in the FAQ. No refunds on any subscription level, though you can cancel at any time. This is standard for digital access products in the trading education space, but it does mean the weekly trial option for the Trader Tier is the smart way to evaluate before committing monthly or annually.

?? GRAB A WEEKLY TRIAL OF THE TRADER TIER AND CHECK IT OUT FIRSTHAND

If you're visiting the Whop page for the first time, keep an eye out for any welcome discount that might appear. Whop products frequently surface promotional popups on the initial visit, and if one is active at the time you check, it could meaningfully reduce your first billing cycle. Worth a look before completing checkout.

Who Gets the Most Out of This Community

The person who benefits most from Stocks with Josh is someone who already has basic chart-reading ability and wants a more structured, tool-supported environment to develop a scalp or short-term trading approach.

If you've been trading for a few months, you understand candlestick patterns, you know what support and resistance are, and you've tried a few indicators on TradingView already, this is a logical next step. The custom indicator suite gives you a curated set of tools built around a specific methodology instead of the overwhelming open-ended indicator library on TradingView.

The Trader Tier in particular suits someone who learns well from watching others trade live. The priority chart request feature is also underrated. Being able to submit a specific ticker you're watching and get it analyzed by someone with a track record is valuable, especially when you're building conviction in your own setups.

The Chart Goat U tier makes more sense if you want to take a more deliberate, educational approach at a lower monthly cost.

Someone who might find less value here is a complete beginner with no chart-reading background. The onboarding guide helps, but the scalp-focused tools assume a baseline level of market literacy. If you're starting from zero, spending a few weeks learning the fundamentals of technical analysis first would help you extract much more from what this community offers.

Pros and Cons, Honestly

Pros:

• Proprietary TradingView tools included in the membership, not sold separately

• Multiple TradingView indicators covering dashboards, scalp levels, alpha signals, and profit windows

• Live trading sessions in the Trader Tier (weekly, starting July 2024)

• Priority chart requests for VIP members

• 7,300+ store members signaling genuine community scale

• Clean review record (zero ratings below 4 stars across both products)

• Weekly trial option available for the Trader Tier to test before committing monthly

• Detailed onboarding guide to get you set up from Whop to Discord without friction

Cons:

• No refund policy means the weekly trial option is the right move before going monthly

• Scalp focus may not suit swing traders or long-term investors who prefer larger timeframe setups

• PayPal only for payment, which could be a friction point for some buyers

• Relatively new community (operating since 2024), so the track record is still being established over time

The Verdict

Stocks with Josh isn't trying to be a generic trading alert service, and that's what I appreciate about the positioning. The combination of custom TradingView tooling plus live sessions plus a tiered community structure gives it more substance than the average Discord server that just posts "buy this, sell that" messages.

The 4.67 average rating across 9 reviews is promising, and the 7,300+ member count tells you this isn't a ghost town. The two-tier structure means you can find a price point that fits your situation, and the weekly entry option for the Trader Tier removes most of the financial risk from the evaluation process.

If you're a trader who wants structured tools and a live-learning environment without dropping thousands on a course that sits unwatched in a Google Drive folder, this is worth a serious look. The TradingView suite alone competes with paid indicators that many traders already budget for.

? JOIN STOCKS WITH JOSH ON WHOP AND SEE THE CURRENT MEMBER PRICING

Quick note: trading in stocks involves real financial risk. Nothing in this article is financial advice. Past performance from any community or tool doesn't guarantee your results, and you should only trade with capital you can afford to lose. Do your own research, and treat any community like this as one input among many in your decision-making process.