Photo by Rob Coates on Unsplash
When Technology Starts to Think for us
In today’s classrooms, it is becoming more common to see students struggling with independent thought. According to Think Academy, the constant presence of technology can limit opportunities for deep thinking and problem-solving, as students often rely on instant information rather than developing their own reasoning skills.
Kids are growing up in a world where screens are everywhere, even in schools, and technology use has become abundant. We need to ask our selves:
“At what point does technology stop helping students learn and start replacing the kinds of critical thinking and connection that are needed?”
I wanted to explore what happens when we find a healthy balance between low-tech, hands-on learning and high-tech digital tools and what’s lost when we lean too far toward screens.
When we strike the right balance between traditional learning and digital learning, students gain the best of both worlds. Low-tech activities like journaling, building, experimenting, or simply talking face to face help kids slow down and think deeply. They make time and space for creativity, focus, and real human connection.
High-tech tools, when used purposefully, can enhance those same goals. They open access to new ideas, help students collaborate beyond the classroom, and make learning more engaging and interactive. This balance also connects to the principles of Universal Design for Learning (UDL), which emphasize offering multiple means of engagement, representation, and expression.
The good news is, there are resources to help educators work towards a balance. Such as the Taylor Institute for Teaching and Learning’s SAMR and TPACK models, helping educators evaluate how they’re using technology, whether it’s simply replacing traditional methods or transforming learning with intention. It reminds us that tech should enhance creativity and connection, not replace them.
A classroom that blends both reflects true inclusivity and recognizes that all students learn in their own ways. The problem is not the technology itself; it is when we start to depend on it too much or use it as a substitute for connection and critical thought.
Benefits of balance:
Increase engagement by keeping learning varied and active.
Encourage creativity by combining digital design with tactile experiences.
Build critical thinking by challenging students to move between digital and real-world problem-solving.
Photo by Marija Zaric on Unsplash
I’ve also seen the other side of things, both at home and in the classroom. Kids are spending more time than ever in front of screens, and it’s starting to show. Many find it hard to focus, think for themselves, or communicate without a device nearby. Some even seem uneasy when they have unstructured, screen-free time.
Antero Garcia, Associate Professor in the Graduate School of Education at Standford University shares that through his research, he believes the online tools we are using in the classroom "might be slowly poisoning us."
Over-reliance on technology can:
Limit collaboration: conversations become shorter, and eye contact disappears.
Reduce independent thinking: instant answers replace curiosity.
Cause burnout: too much screen time can actually make learning feel tiring and shallow.
We talk so much about preparing students for a digital future, but a huge part of that preparation should include teaching them how to disconnect, how to use technology intentionally, not constantly.
Pros, Cons, and Risks of Technology in Learning
Pros: When used with purpose, technology can make learning more engaging and creative. It helps students collaborate, access new ideas, and express their learning in different ways. It also prepares them for the digital world they’re growing up in.
Cons: When we lean too much on screens, students can lose some independence in their thinking. They might rely on quick answers instead of slowing down to problem-solve or create. It can also take away from hands-on learning, real conversations, and focus.
Risks: Too much screen time can cause overstimulation and make learning feel shallow. Students may lose some of that real-world connection, miss out on movement and play, and struggle to think critically without a device in front of them.
Photo by Annie Spratt on Unsplash ; Photo by Bermix Studio on Unsplash ; Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash
The most effective classrooms will use technology as a support, not the centrepiece.
For example:
Students might brainstorm ideas on paper before typing a paper or creating a shared digital project.
A math lesson might include hands-on manipulatives followed by a tech-based game or quiz.
During literacy, students might go through a UFLI lesson on the smart board before they write journal entries by hand.
Canadian programs like Kids Code Jeunesse model this approach beautifully. Their initiatives pair unplugged, hands-on activities with coding and digital creation, helping students understand not just how technology works but why it matters. They also offer teacher training that supports educators in bringing coding and computational thinking into their classrooms. It is a reminder that coding and creativity belong together and that learning through movement, play, and design remains essential.
Likewise, MediaSmarts’ Classroom Guide for Integrating Digital Literacy offers a practical framework for teachers across Canada to embed digital skills while still nurturing communication, empathy, and responsible tech use. Their resources encourage students to think critically about media, screen time, and online interaction. This is exactly the kind of balanced awareness classrooms need today.
These resources remind me that technology can support learning, not replace it. Children still need movement, creativity, and social interaction to grow into well-rounded thinkers. By finding balance, we can help students become innovative, modern thinkers who use technology with purpose and imagination.
Best Practices & Tips for Teachers
Finding balance between low-tech and high-tech learning starts with being intentional. Teachers don’t have to pick one side over the other; it’s about finding ways to blend both so students stay creative, connected, and curious. Here are some ideas that can help keep that balance in the classroom:
Start hands-on. Begin lessons with activities like journaling, building, or having group discussions before introducing any digital tools. Working by hand helps students slow down, reflect, and think more deeply.
Blend online and offline experiences. Try pairing digital activities with hands-on learning. For instance, students might write or draw in a notebook during a nature walk, then use a device later to research or share what they found.
Include creativity and movement. Add art, play, and physical activities to keep learning active and engaging. This helps students focus and reminds them that learning doesn’t always happen on a screen.
Teach digital responsibility. Use programs like Kids Code Jeunesse and MediaSmarts to guide students in using technology safely, responsibly, and with purpose.
Take time to reflect. Ask your students and yourself how technology is supporting or distracting from learning. Adjust when needed to keep lessons meaningful and balanced.
Photo by Element5 Digital on Unsplash
This research made me realize that finding balance isn’t just an educational issue; it’s a life issue. I want my own kids to be comfortable both on and off a screen. I want my future students to know how to collaborate, communicate, and think critically, not just click quickly.
As a teacher, I plan to:
Be intentional about when and why I use technology in lessons.
Include regular low-tech, hands-on learning experiences.
Teach students to pause, reflect, and question before they search for instant answers.
Encourage connection and conversation just as much as digital literacy.
Technology has an important place in education, but so do play, discussion, art, and imagination. When we find that middle ground, where technology enhances rather than replaces, we raise students who are not only capable with tools but confident, creative, and connected humans.