Motivational Patterns in Calvin
Low engagement → his situational interest is not being triggered
Low interest → there is not a creative outlet in class for him to express himself in a way that is familiar and comfortable to him
Low persistence → Content is not piquing his interest
Negative reactions & emotions → his individual interests exist but are often completely cast off when he mentions them in class
Issues in Interest with Learning
Disinterested because there’s not a big creative outlet in class; Calvin is creative and often expresses himself through drawings.
He’s not opposed to the learning itself; he’s opposed to the activities that go along with the learning
He knows the information, but the importance behind learning the information hasn’t been explicitly expressed
He goes into the tests feeling like he’s going to fail or feels as if he is meant to be "entertaining" staff in the teacher's lounge
Hidi, S. & Renninger, K. A. (2006). The four-phase model of interest development. Educational Psychologist, 41, 111-127.
Interest as a motivational variable refers to the psychological state of engaging or the predisposition to reengage with particular classes of objects, events, or ideas over time.
Individual interest is always motivating; it builds on what a person perceives, cognitively represents to oneself, and considers as possibilities for activity (Renninger, 1990, 2000).
Triggered Situational Interest
Maintained Situational Interest
Emerging Individual Interest
Well-Developed Individual Interest.
The four-phase model of interest development describes phases of situational and individual interest in terms of both affective and cognitive processes. It also identifies situational interest as providing a basis for an emerging individual interest.
PATTERN: low interest → negative reactions → low persistence → reduced opportunity for learning
As the four-phase model indicates, a student's interest must be triggered before it can be maintained, and so on and so forth. In this comic, Calvin's situational interest is not triggered by the discussion of Lewis and Clark. However, he tries to reroute the topic of discussion to his interest. By doing so, he attempts to engage his situational interest himself. But when Mrs. Wormwood shuts it down, his situational interest dissolves. Therefore, he is not able to engage with the content past situational interest and is not able to progress into the three following stages of interest development.
Calvin has low interest with the material being learned in class, he is not motivated to participate
Interest is connected to a student's emotional response - Calvin = negative emotinal response to classroom activity
Because Calvin doesn’t seem to have an interest with the lesson he isn’t activity participating
The environment or lesson is not capturing enough of Calvin’s attention to keep him interested.
Interest can encourage students to be persistent with learning, Calvin does not become persistent and has to leave the classroom (aftering shouting out)
Ainley, M., Hidi, S., & Berndorff, D. (2002). Interest, learning, and the psychological processes that mediate their relationship. Journal of Educational Psychology, 94(3), 545–561.
PATTERN: low interest → negative reactions → low engagement → low persistence → reduced opportunity for learning
In this comic strip, the audience is presented with many of the same overlapping issues as the previous one. Calvin presents symptoms of boredom as his situational interest is not being triggered. He has little/low interest in the material because he is unaware of the purpose behind the learning. Therefore, this manifests itself as low persistence in sticking with the content. Instead, Calvin acts out and is removed from the classroom, leaving no room for learning opportunities.