In her sophomore novel, Circe, Miller yields the first-person perspective of the story of Greek mythology’s first witch to the book’s namesake herself. This as opposed to perhaps her most notable interaction, Odysseus. While the pragmatism of this decision means the reader is audience to the entirety of her life as opposed to that infamous meeting told by Homer, the natural consequence of this decision means Circe and the female companions on her island are able to hold onto a significant part of their autonomy. Their stories do not wholly revolve around the actions of surrounding men—because there are few to none at any given time once Circe is on Aeaea.
The same cannot be said for the women in Miller’s focused retelling of The Iliad. First of note is the conceiving of the half-divine hero himself. Consistent with the classic version of the myth, Achilles’ father, Peleus, is granted “permission” to Thetis, the hero’s divine mother, by other gods, and their marriage and son comes about as the result of her rape by Peleus. When she does reappear or is spoken of by adjacent characters, she’s depicted as cold, unloving, even disdainful. As said by Alexandra Roumbas Goldstein on the UK feminist blog, The F Word, just after the book’s release,
Calling it a ‘ravishment’ and describing Peleus’ cleverness and Thetis’ disdain for mortals—as if that was her only objection—are undoubtedly true to Patroclus’ dreamy tones, but it makes for an uncomfortable reading.
Another prominent female character, Briseis, is regarded as property—a status symbol—by the men surrounding her during the battle of Troy. First captured by Achilles during the conflict, she’s later taken and her assault eagerly threatened for the single intent of wounding Achille’s pride, and he doesn’t protest, thinking is she were to be assaulted the consequences would be in his favor. Briseis’ thoughts and feelings on the matter are irrelevant. Even Helen, the woman whose questionable abduction spurs the war, is only given the illusion of agency in the beginning of the novel when she chooses which of the suitors present she’ll marry; a solution presented by Odysseus for the sake of peace. It then stands to reason that “female agency only appears to impact the novel’s events—in the end, any power that women have is only a convenient tool that allows men and gods to pull hidden strings” (“Gender”).
While understandable both that Greek myth is not a known example for female power and agency, and that Miller attempts to stay faithful to the original epic, she is not beyond revising certain figures and resolutions for the sake of her focal relationship. In this, I believe the criticism of her employment of female roles as stereotypical and objectified is a fair assessment.
Image: Achilles and Briseis. 1st century BC, Naples National Archeological Museum. Fresco.
Works Cited
"Gender, Power, and Agency: Theme Analysis." LitCharts, 2022, https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-song-of-achilles/themes/gender-power-and-agency .
Goldstein, Alexandra Roumbas. "The Song of Achilles." The F Word, 2 Sept. 2012, https://thefword.org.uk/2012/09/the_song_of_ach/.