Social-Emotional Supports

Social-emotional skills such as

emotion-management, social and self-awareness, responsible decision-making,

among others, are essential skills that will prepare students to be successful in many facets of life

(Nagaoka, Farrington, Ehrlich, & Heath, 2015).


Emotions have been shown to enhance or interfere with the ability to learn, highlighting the importance of learning to manage one’s emotions (Dresser, 2012).

ELs face specific, unique social-emotional challenges.

The process of learning a second language in itself can contribute to social and emotional difficulties such as feelings of isolation from peers due to the fact that they may not speak English well. ELs may also experience anxiety and worry about completing school work in English, and may have trouble paying attention, staying on task, and following directions due to unfamiliarity with English, and not understanding what their teacher is asking them to do. There is evidence to support that ELs do, in fact, report more social-emotional problems at school (Niehaus, Adelson, Sejuit, & Zheng, 2017).

The Affective Filter

The affective filter, a term originally coined by Stephen Krashen, is a theory in the field of second language acquisition that describes an invisible psychological filter that can either help or hinder second language acquisition.

This theory helps to describe some of the ways that social-emotional challenges can affect academic and language outcomes for those who are learning a second language (Krashen, 1988; Vasquez, 2018).

A student with a:

  • HIGH affective filter experiences stress, feels anxious or self-conscious, and may be reluctant to participate, making it harder to learn a second language

  • LOW affective filter feels safe making mistakes and feels empowered to take risks and use language freely, which facilitates language learning

How Can We Try to Lower the Affective Filter?

The Responsive Classroom Model

The Responsive Classroom Model is an approach to teaching based on guiding principles that revolve around social and emotional skills, student-centered and inclusive teaching practices, and the successful partnership between teachers, students, schools, families, and the community (Responsive Classroom, 2020).

An important part of this model is morning meeting, which consists of a message, a greeting, an activity, and time to share.

Activities

  • Spending 15-20 minutes at the beginning and end of the day engaging in activities such as greeting each other, playing collaborative games, and reflecting works toward establishing a positive community where students know and respect one another.

  • Games that involves songs or chants like "Hello Neighbor" can be a great way for ELs to practice and remember new words and phrases.

(Responsive Classroom, 2001)

Greeting

Greetings can help to create a positive community where everyone knows and respects each other.

  • Use simple greetings that require little to no words.

  • Ex: wave, smile

  • If comfortable, start with simple words or phrases

  • Ex: “Hi,” “Hello,” “Good morning.”

  • Give students a chance to practice the greeting with a partner or small group first.

  • Research greetings in the cultures of students.

  • Ex: Some cultures avoid eye contact, especially with adults, as a sign of respect. The class could turn their bodies toward the person they’re greeting without making direct eye contact.

  • Learn a greeting in the home languages of the EL students. EL students may feel more welcomed, and the native English speakers may gain some insight into the challenges of functioning in a new language.

  • Ex: "Hola, Como estas?"

(Responsive Classroom, 2015)

Share Time

The opportunity to share and learn about each other helps to strengthen the classroom community. Sharing also allows students to practice and develop social skills like turn taking, listening, clear and respectful communication, and building empathy.

Students can use this opportunity to share about their culture, which broadens the cultural understanding of the class, and allows students to feel a sense of visibility and belonging.

Sentence frames for sharing can be provided to support ELs.

“A special food I like to eat is_________.”

Students can also hold up an item to share and respond to yes or no questions.

Additionally, it may benefit the students if teachers learn more about the cultures represented in the classroom.

(Responsive Classroom, 2001; Vincent, 2020)image: https://consciousdiscipline.com/free-resources/shubert/shuberts-classroom/friends-and-family-board/#examples

Routines and Procedures

Explicitly teaching norms and procedures for each part of the school day, and practicing them until they become consistent, stable, and predictable routines in the classroom may help ELs and all students to understand and feel safe in their environment.

Explicitly teach norms

  • Some students may not be aware of the unspoken rules that other students have been exposed to, and your classroom norms likely vary to some degree from other teachers.

  • It may be especially helpful for ELs to model and visually display the classroom norms.

  • Using pictures of your students modeling appropriate behavior for the posters can contribute to creating a positive classroom community and students may feel a sense of ownership over the rules and the classroom.

Poster: https://www.reallygoodstuff.com/class-expectations-jumbo-poster/p/165467/?gclid=CjwKCAjw8pH3BRAXEiwA1pvMsfarM0xyaT3KQEG3wUgzyw_A8Aj_S8QkRa249A9sgRf67-3feQQjiRoCgZsQAvD_BwE

Non-verbal cues

  • Predictable cues for attention getting, transitions, and other parts of the school day help to create a consistent, safe, easy to understand environment for ELs and all students.

  • Non-verbal signals, like sounds or hand signals, may be especially helpful to ELs because language is not required. The "peace sign" can be used as a quieting signal.

Classroom procedures

  • Going beyond explicit teaching of classroom norms, teaching procedures is outlining each step of a certain task or activity. Clear and simple directions may help ELs to understand what is expected of them and communicates high expectations.

  • Modeling the steps and allowing students plenty of time to practice in a low-stakes setting may be beneficial for EL students. For example, using a discussion about favorite colors, teachers can model with a student or another adult how to follow these steps. Sentence frames and a word bank can be extra supports.

  • This can then be used as a framework for teaching academic and language procedures, which can provide support for ELs.

  • Procedures for many activities, such as turn taking when discussing, playing a game, partner reading, etc. can be created and implemented.

Image: https://minds-in-bloom.com/fold-line/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MindsInBloom+%28Minds+in+Bloom%29

Growth Mindset

Students who believe their intelligence can be developed have a growth mindset, whereas students who believe their intelligence is fixed and cannot change have a fixed mindset (Dweck, 2015).

In a study assessing growth mindset, English learners were found to be less likely to report beliefs consistent with a growth mindset than other subgroups of their peers (Snipes & Tran, 2017). Researchers suggested that perhaps these beliefs about the nature of ability and payoff for effort could be contributing to disparities in academic achievement, or were possibly the result of previous negative experiences (Snipes & Tran, 2017). Either way, they suggest these findings indicate even greater importance in fostering a growth mindset in ELs (Snipes & Tran, 2017).

Scaffolding

  • Set individual goals to fit a student's current ability level, and provide challenge without overwhelming the student. The focus should be on growth and improvement, not perfection or measuring up to other students.

  • Provide scaffolding through questioning that is appropriate to the student's level of verbal proficiency. If students are struggling with production, they can be asked "Show me..." or "Which of these..." so that they can point or nod. As the level of production increases, prompting for an increased number of words will be appropriate. This scaffolding sets students up for a task that is challenging but attainable.

  • It can be helpful to focus less on error correction, and more on correcting language use in a supportive manner. For example, in your response, try rephrasing what the student said to reflect correct use of a word or sentence.

  • Encourage risk-taking. After providing students with evidence of how their brain can grow, and implementing community building classroom strategies, hopefully ELs and all students feeling comfortable taking the risks that are necessary for learning.

(Vasquez, 2018; Penn State, 2014)

Teacher talk

Words can encourage students and build confidence or can shut them down and discourage their efforts.

Instead of saying:

  • "Good job!"

  • "Nice work!"

  • "Excellent!"

Try:

  • "Your hard work is paying off!"

  • "What strategies did you use?"

  • "You kept going even when it got challenging!"

When students are struggling, instead of saying:

  • "Work harder"

  • "Keep trying"

Try:

  • "What part is proving difficult?"

  • "Let me try explaining it another way"

  • "I expect you to make mistakes; that is part of the learning process."

(Herrmann, 2016)

Modifications

  • Growth mindsets are not just for students! When something doesn't work, teachers should consider the obstacles to success, and think about different ways to support students. Modifications can range from rewriting or highlighting texts, to providing sentence frames, graphic organizers, and word banks, to utilizing different types of assessments.

  • Provide and list many strategies. A growth mindset is not just about effort, it is also about developing the metacognitive skills to understand when something isn't working and another strategy is needed, or knowing when and how to ask for help.

  • Allow students to reflect on challenges and support them in brainstorming solutions.

  • Build learning stamina. ELs may be easily frustrated, so start with shorter learning time and gradually extend as students are ready.

(Dweck, 2015; Penn State, 2014; Wyman, 2020)Image: http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-KidokeAesp8/UJ14bUMUptI/AAAAAAAAApg/DOs-irZoEkE/s1600/IMG_2300.JPG