ELECDER i45 vs JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective in 2026

How We Research

We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.

Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison

If you want a lightweight, foldable wired on-ear headphone you can toss in a bag and hand to a kid without worry, choose ELECDER i45; if you need a shockproof hard case to protect a pair of foldable Bluetooth over-ear or on-ear headphones you already own, choose JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective.

ELECDER i45 vs JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective at a Glance

• ELECDER i45 — biggest strength: a 40mm dynamic driver with a foldable, lightweight on-ear design, a 3.5mm wired connection and an inline microphone with media controls.

• ELECDER i45 — biggest trade-off: it's a wired headphone, so you're tethered to a device with a 3.5mm jack, and it doesn't come with any kind of travel case.

• JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective — biggest strength: a shockproof hard EVA shell with a soft inner lining, a carabiner and an inner mesh pocket, sized to hold many foldable over-ear and on-ear headphones.

• JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective — biggest trade-off: it is a case only. There are no headphones inside, and the fit depends on your headphone's folded dimensions matching the interior.

• Who each pick is for: the ELECDER i45 is for someone who needs an affordable, kid-friendly wired headphone for school, travel or a tablet. The JYGSFCHDC case is for someone who already owns a foldable wireless headphone and wants to stop it getting crushed in a backpack.

ELECDER i45: Who It's For

The ELECDER i45 is a wired on-ear headphone built around a single 40mm dynamic driver. That one driver is doing all the work, and ELECDER tunes it for what the spec sheet calls "Hi-Fi stereo bass" — meaning the low end is the point, with a crisp midrange sitting on top. For pop, hip-hop, podcasts and movie soundtracks, that's a sensible tuning. If you're a critical listener chasing flat, analytical detail, this isn't the tool — a single 40mm dynamic driver in a plastic-and-nylon on-ear shell is a fun-sounding headphone, not a studio reference.

Where the i45 makes the most sense is portability and durability for everyday, slightly careless use. The design folds, the size slider adjusts, and the whole thing is meant to be lightweight and space-saving. The ear cushions and headband are padded with ultra-soft foam, which matters more than people think on an on-ear: on-ear cans press against the outer ear, so padding and low clamping weight are what keep them wearable for a long study session or a long flight. The cord is a 1.5m nylon-braided cable that ELECDER describes as tangle-free, which is a genuinely useful spec for a headphone that lives in a school bag.

There's also a microphone with in-line media control, so you can take calls and skip tracks without touching the phone, and the earcups use sound isolation to cut down background noise. ELECDER also notes the design protects children's ears up to 85 dB, and the listing positions this squarely at school, kids, teens, travel, tablets and smartphones. The 3.5mm jack is the catch: it works with anything that still has a headphone port — most tablets, laptops, the Nintendo Switch, older phones — but not with a phone that dropped the jack unless you add an adapter.

Buy it if: you want a cheap-to-replace, foldable wired headphone for a student, a kid, or as a backup pair for flights and travel, and you like a bass-forward sound. Skip it if: you need wireless, active noise cancellation, or you're pairing with a device that has no 3.5mm output. The 24-month warranty and the included user guide round out a package that's clearly aimed at low-risk, high-use everyday listening rather than audiophile duty.

JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective: Who It's For

The JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective is not a headphone. It's the thing that stops your headphone from dying in a bag — and if you've ever pulled a pair of over-ears out of a backpack to find a cracked headband or a scratched earcup, you already know why this category exists.

The construction is the whole story here. The shell is hard EVA — the same foamy-but-rigid material used in a lot of protective gear — and it's lined with a soft inner layer. JYGSFCHDC lists it as shockproof, spill-resistant with a water-repellent finish, and dust resistant, so it's built for drops, bumps, scratches and light splashes rather than full submersion. The zipper runs smoothly for easy access, and there's an inner mesh pocket plus a carabiner, which is the detail I like most: you can clip the case to the outside of a backpack or a carry-on handle instead of burying it inside.

The fit is where you need to pay attention. Interior dimensions are 5.8" x 5.5" x 2.6", exterior 6.5" x 6" x 3.0". JYGSFCHDC lists compatibility with Marshall Major V/IV/III, Skullcandy Crusher Evo, Hesh Evo and Hesh ANC, Bose QuietComfort, and more broadly with foldable wireless over-ear and on-ear models from JBL, Sony, Soundcore, Sennheiser and Bose. The key word is foldable. A big headphone that doesn't fold, or one whose folded footprint exceeds those interior measurements, won't be a good match. Measure before you buy.

Two honest notes. First, it's case only — the listing says this explicitly, and there's nothing else in the box. Second, JYGSFCHDC advises ventilating the case for one to two days if a new-material odor is present on arrival. That's a normal off-gassing note for EVA goods, but it's worth knowing so you're not surprised.

Buy it if: you own a foldable wireless over-ear or on-ear headphone and want hard-shell protection for travel, commuting or school, and you like the idea of clipping it to the outside of a bag. Skip it if: your headphone doesn't fold, is bigger than the interior dimensions, or you're looking for a headphone rather than storage.

Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?

• You need an actual headphone → ELECDER i45. The JYGSFCHDC product is a case. It will never play a note.

• You already own a foldable wireless headphone and want to protect it → JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective.

• Best for kids, school and shared tablets → ELECDER i45, thanks to the 3.5mm wired connection, padded on-ear fit, folding design and the 85 dB ear-protection note.

• Best for bass-forward everyday listening → ELECDER i45, with its 40mm dynamic driver tuned for stereo bass.

• Best for travel and commuting → JYGSFCHDC case if you're carrying Bluetooth headphones; the hard EVA shell, carabiner and inner mesh pocket are built for exactly that.

• Best for wired convenience and calls → ELECDER i45, with its inline microphone and media control on a 1.5m tangle-resistant braided cord.

• Best for peace of mind about drops and scratches → JYGSFCHDC case, whose shockproof, dust-resistant, water-repellent shell is the whole point.

• Worth checking before you commit → compatibility. The i45 needs a 3.5mm jack on your device; the case needs your headphone to fold within 5.8" x 5.5" x 2.6". Get either wrong and you'll be disappointed.

My Verdict

These two products don't really compete — they solve different problems, and in my opinion the smarter move is to think about which problem you have right now. If you're buying a headphone for a student, a kid, or as a wired backup for travel, I'd buy the ELECDER i45: folding on-ear design, 40mm bass-forward driver, inline mic, tangle-resistant 1.5m cable and a 24-month warranty make it a sensible everyday pick. If you already love your wireless over-ears and just want them to survive your backpack, I'd buy the JYGSFCHDC Headphone Case Protective instead. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your situation — and if you need both a headphone and something to carry it in, you're looking at two purchases, not one.

FAQ

what are the best open ear headphones

That's a different category from both products here. The ELECDER i45 is an on-ear headphone — the earcups rest on the ear rather than leaving it open — and the JYGSFCHDC item is a carrying case, not a headphone at all. If you specifically want an open-ear design, neither of these is it.

are on ear headphones good

For many people, yes. On-ear headphones like the ELECDER i45 sit lighter and more compact than full over-ears, and its padded ultra-soft cushions, adjustable slider and foldable frame are designed for comfortable, portable listening. The trade-off is that on-ear cups press against the ear, so fit and padding matter more than they do on an over-ear.

are open ear headphones good

Open-ear headphones leave the ear canal unobstructed, which some people prefer for awareness of their surroundings. That's not what the ELECDER i45 does — it uses sound isolation to reduce background noise, and the JYGSFCHDC case is purely storage. Judge each product by what it's actually designed for.

what are the best in-ear headphones

In-ear models are a separate product type again. The ELECDER i45 is explicitly an on-ear, wired headphone with a 40mm dynamic driver and a 3.5mm jack, and the JYGSFCHDC product protects over-ear and on-ear headphones. If in-ear is your priority, look at in-ear models rather than either of these.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.

When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.

See also: KOUJAON Earbud Case Headphone vs Aircawin Bose, Riwbox Kids Headphones vs Perfcaze Hard Headphone Case, Spigen Rugged Armor Designed vs BOVUGAC Case: Charging Case