How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a kid-proof, school-ready headphone built around safety and durability, choose ELECDER i37; if you need a lightweight vintage-styled wired headset for studio and desk listening, choose TOKIDNY Vintage.
These two get compared a lot because they both sit in the cheap wired-headphone space, but they are aimed at completely different people. One is a children's headphone with a foldable frame and a long tangle-free cord. The other is a retro-looking over-ear set sold for recording and work. Once you line up the specs, the choice stops being close.
• ELECDER i37 biggest strength: A foldable, adjustable on-ear design with cushioned pads, lead-free and BPA-free materials, and a 4.9 ft tangle-free cord — clearly built for kids carrying it to school.
• ELECDER i37 biggest trade-off: It's wired only, with a 3.5 mm jack and no wireless mode, so it needs a device with a headphone port and it's tuned for isolation rather than critical listening.
• TOKIDNY Vintage biggest strength: A classic over-ear look with a claimed clear mid-range and pure highs, positioned for studio, recording and music-listening use.
• TOKIDNY Vintage biggest trade-off: The listing carries no warranty, the spec sheet is thin, and the data actually lists "In Ear" ear placement while the title says over ear — that inconsistency is worth knowing before you buy.
• For kids, school and travel → ELECDER i37.
• For a retro desk or studio-style headset on a budget → TOKIDNY Vintage.
The i37 is unapologetically a kids' headphone. The pitch is comfort and safety first: a foldable, adjustable headband, cushioned on-ear pads, and a 4.9 ft tangle-free cord that's meant to survive being shoved into a school backpack or an airplane seat pocket. The ear cups are shaped so kids can learn left from right, which sounds like a small thing until you've watched a six-year-old put headphones on backwards for the tenth time.
Materials matter here too. The i37 is described as lead-free and BPA-free, and the on-ear cushion is designed to reduce ambient noise — classroom chatter, car noise, plane drone — while still letting a child stay aware of what's going on around them. That balance is the whole point for a parent: enough isolation to focus on a Chromebook lesson, not so much that a kid tunes out the world entirely.
Connection is plug-and-play. The gold-plated 3.5 mm jack and L-shaped plug work with Chromebooks, tablets, laptops, smartphones, DVD players and Kindles. There's no charging, no pairing, no app. It's wired, 32 ohm impedance, dynamic drivers, 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz — the standard range you'd expect at this tier.
Who should buy it: parents of school-age kids, anyone buying for a Chromebook classroom, and travelers who want one headphone that survives a road trip. It's also a reasonable fit for petite adults, since the frame is small by design. Who should skip it: anyone who wants wireless, anyone who needs a microphone for calls, and anyone shopping for serious audio fidelity. At 5.6 ounces it's light, but the pink colorway and kid-focused build make it an odd pick for a grown-up's home office. The 1-year warranty and 24/7 email support are the real value-add for a product in this category.
The TOKIDNY Vintage sells a mood as much as a sound. It's a wired over-ear headset with a retro, classic look — the kind of thing that fits a studio desk, a recording setup, or a shelf next to a turntable. The marketing leans on "crystal clear audio," pristine vocals, clear mid-range and pure high pitches, with the target being music lovers, creators and people who like the vintage aesthetic.
The practical case is simple: it's wired, so there's no charging and no pairing, and it connects by cord to computers or music players. The description calls out ergonomic comfort for extended listening with minimal ear fatigue, plus a snug adjustable fit so it stays put during movement. It's also genuinely tiny — listed at 15 × 11 × 4 cm and 27.22 g — which makes it a compact, toss-in-a-bag accessory rather than a big studio can.
Now the honest part. The data sheet is inconsistent. The title and description say over ear; the product information lists ear placement as "In Ear," and the folding feature field also says "In Ear." The connectivity field says "Hybrid," which doesn't tell you much. There's no stated frequency range, no impedance figure, no driver type, and the warranty description simply reads "No Warranty." Materials are listed as PVC sponge, and the color is black.
Who should buy it: someone who wants a cheap, light, wired headset with a retro look for casual desk listening, light recording, or as a prop-adjacent accessory. Who should skip it: anyone who needs a documented warranty, anyone who needs confirmed over-ear fit, and anyone who wants specs they can actually compare. If you're buying for a child or for daily school abuse, this is not the pick — the i37 is.
• Best for kids and school → ELECDER i37. Lead-free and BPA-free materials, kid-sized adjustable frame, left/right learning cues.
• Best for travel and backpack life → ELECDER i37. Foldable design and a 4.9 ft tangle-free cord that's built for seat pockets and school bags.
• Best for warranty and support → ELECDER i37. 1-year warranty plus 24/7 email support, versus no warranty listed for the TOKIDNY.
• Best for a retro studio look → TOKIDNY Vintage. The vintage over-ear styling is the entire point of the product.
• Best for ultra-light portability → TOKIDNY Vintage. At 27.22 g and 15 × 11 × 4 cm, it disappears in a bag.
• Best for spec transparency → ELECDER i37. Impedance, driver type, frequency range and connection type are all stated; the TOKIDNY sheet leaves most of that blank.
• Best for wireless needs → neither. Both are wired; the i37 uses a 3.5 mm jack, and the TOKIDNY connects by cord.
• Best for adults wanting a desk headset → TOKIDNY Vintage, provided you're comfortable with the unclear over-ear/in-ear listing.
In my opinion, the ELECDER i37 is the safer buy of the two, and it's the one I'd pick. Not because it sounds better — I have no way to judge that from a spec sheet — but because it tells you exactly what it is: a foldable, adjustable, kid-focused wired headphone with stated impedance, driver type, frequency range, materials, a 1-year warranty and real support behind it. The TOKIDNY Vintage is a fun-looking retro accessory, but a data sheet that contradicts itself on ear placement and lists no warranty is a lot of uncertainty. If you want a headset for a child, a student or a commute, go ELECDER i37. If you specifically want the vintage look and accept the trade-offs, the TOKIDNY is a defensible pick. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before deciding, since that's the one thing that can shift the math.
Yes, that's exactly what it's designed for. It's foldable, adjustable, made with lead-free and BPA-free materials, and comes with a 4.9 ft tangle-free cord that suits backpacks and classroom Chromebooks.
According to the product information, no. The warranty field reads "No Warranty," so if warranty coverage matters to you, the ELECDER i37 — which includes a 1-year warranty and 24/7 email support — is the better fit.
No. Both are wired. The ELECDER i37 uses a 3.5 mm jack, and the TOKIDNY Vintage connects by cord to computers or music players, with no charging required.
That's the confusing part. The title and description say over ear, but the product information lists ear placement as "In Ear." If confirmed over-ear fit is essential, keep that inconsistency in mind.
The ELECDER i37, clearly. It's sized for children and teens, built with kid-safe materials, and designed to reduce background noise while keeping a child aware of their surroundings. The TOKIDNY Vintage is aimed at studio and work listening, not children.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Galirity Headset vs ELECDER i37: Wireless Foldable, Wantek USB-A/USB C/3.5mm vs ELECDER i37: Noise Cancelling on, SIMOLIO Kids Headphones vs WHAMVOX Vintage