Dynamic games can be an effective approach to modeling interactive behavior between multiple non-cooperative agents and they provide a theoretical framework for simultaneous prediction and control in such scenarios. In this work, we propose a numerical method for the solution of local generalized Nash equilibria (GNE) for the class of open-loop general-sum dynamic games for agents with nonlinear dynamics and constraints. In particular, we formulate a sequential quadratic programming (SQP) approach which requires only the solution of a single convex quadratic program at each iteration. Central to the robustness of our approach is a non-monotonic line search method and a novel merit function for SQP step acceptance. We show that our method achieves linear convergence in the neighborhood of local GNE and we derive an update rule for the merit function which helps to improve convergence from a larger set of initial conditions. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the algorithm in the context of car racing, where we show up to 32% improvement of success rate when comparing against a state-of-the-art solution approach for dynamic games.Â