How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-08 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Earrock's biggest strength: Designed for one headphone only — the AirPods Max — with an inner magnet that snaps the pads on automatically, plus acoustic memory foam and protein leather that wipes clean.
• Earrock's biggest trade-off: The protein leather surface feels different from the original mesh fabric, so anyone chasing the exact stock texture will notice the change immediately.
• Hmoke's biggest strength: Extra-thick, high-density slow-rebound memory foam that shapes to your ears and stays comfortable through long sessions, sized for a whole family of Sony WH models.
• Hmoke's biggest trade-off: It only fits the listed Sony models, so you have to confirm your headphone model before buying — it will not work on anything else.
• Who Earrock is for: AirPods Max owners who want a fast, magnet-on refresh in pink protein leather.
• Who Hmoke is for: Sony WH-XB900N / WH-CH710N / WH-CH720N / WH-RF400 / MDR-RF895RK owners who want thicker, softer pads without replacing the headphones.
Earrock's pads are a single-purpose product, and that's the point. They're made for the AirPods Max and nothing else. The design leans on three things: a skin-friendly protein leather cover, acoustic memory foam with a slow rebound effect, and an inner magnet ring. The magnet is the feature I'd highlight most — the pads attach to the ear cups automatically, so you're not wrestling with adhesive or stretching anything into place. For a headphone that costs real money, a swap that takes seconds and can be reversed just as easily is genuinely useful.
Who should skip it? Anyone who wants the original mesh texture. Earrock is upfront about this: the protein leather has a similar pattern to the stock cushion but feels different. If texture fidelity to the original is your priority, this isn't the pad for you. It's also worth noting the color is pink, so if you want your AirPods Max to stay visually stock, this is a deliberate change, not a subtle one. And the 12-month warranty is a reasonable safety net for a wear part. If you're weighing it against other options, check the current price on Amazon before deciding — that's the variable that shifts most.
Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads: Who It's For
Hmoke takes the opposite approach: one pad shape, many Sony models. The fit list is specific — WH-XB900N, WH-CH710N, WH-CH720N, WH-RF400, and MDR-RF895RK — and Hmoke repeats the "confirm your model first" warning more than once, which tells you the fit is tight and model-dependent. This is not a universal pad, and it isn't pretending to be.
Where Hmoke wins is thickness and feel. These are extra-thick cushions built from high-density slow-rebound memory foam and soft protein leather. The pitch is comfort over long wear — no swelling, no pain, and soft from the first time you put them on. For anyone doing music production, that matters more than it sounds. Long mixing sessions, repeated takes, headphones on and off for hours: a pad that shapes to your ear and doesn't press hard is the difference between finishing a session and tapping out early. The blue color is a small aesthetic choice, but it's part of what gives an older pair of Sonys a visibly refreshed look.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for AirPods Max owners → Earrock Replacement Ear Cushions (it's built for that one model, with magnets that attach automatically).
• Best for Sony WH-series owners → Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads (designed for WH-XB900N, WH-CH710N, WH-CH720N, WH-RF400, MDR-RF895RK).
• Best for a tool-free, seconds-long install → Earrock (the inner magnet does the work; no special tools, no adhesives).
• Best for long-session comfort and thicker padding → Hmoke (extra-thick, high-density slow-rebound memory foam that shapes to your ears).
• Best for easy cleaning and spill resistance → Earrock (water-resistant protein leather; stains wipe off).
• Best for reviving an older pair instead of replacing it → Hmoke (a few-minute pad swap gives your existing Sonys a fresh look).
• Best for the original mesh texture → neither (Earrock explicitly notes its protein leather feels different from the stock mesh).
• Best for a longer stated warranty window → Earrock (12-month warranty versus Hmoke's 1-year manufacturer warranty).
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to one question: which headphones are on your desk? If it's the AirPods Max, I'd buy the Earrock Replacement Ear Cushions — the magnet attachment is the cleanest swap here, and the protein leather plus acoustic memory foam is a sensible combination for daily listening and music production work where you want pads that stay clean and hold their shape. If it's a Sony from Hmoke's list, I'd buy the Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads — the extra-thick slow-rebound foam is the more comfort-focused design, and it's the smarter move than replacing headphones you already like. Match the pad to the model and you won't go wrong.
FAQ
can you sleep with over ear headphones
how to wear over ear headphones
Place the cups so they sit fully over your ears, not on them, with the headband resting on the crown of your head. The pads should seal around your ear without pinching. Hmoke's slow-rebound foam shapes to your ear over time, and Earrock's foam is designed to settle back rather than flatten.
how to wear over ear headphones properly
Center each ear inside the cup and adjust the headband so the pads apply even, light pressure on both sides. If the seal breaks, bass and isolation suffer. Earrock notes its protein leather helps dull external noise, and Hmoke's thicker cushions rely on a full seal for the same effect.
how should over ear headphones fit
Snug but not tight — you should be able to wear them for a long stretch without soreness. Hmoke describes its pads as comfortable even during long wear, with no swelling or pain. Earrock's slow-rebound memory foam is meant to keep its shape rather than compress flat over time.
• Sony ZX Series vs New Bee USB Headset: Headphones with Mic
• Kamon 5 vs GGSTOPWATER Open Ear Headphone comparison
• Kinivo BTH240 vs Kinglucky Clip-On Earbuds Comfortable
• BlueParrott C400-XT vs Skullcandy PLYR Multi-Platform
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.