The page will be continuously updated to enrich the contents.
A version of the contents on this page has been edited into a special section of Volume 27 of Space, Society and Geographical Thought, published on 25 March 2024. The publication is bilingual, in Japanese and English. Please read the special section by clicking here.
It is with great sadness that the International Steering Committee of the East Asian Regional Conference in Alternative Geography (EARCAG) reports the passing of our dear friend and colleague Professor TANG Wing-Shing on 26 January 2024. For nearly 25 years, Wing-Shing had played an important role in EARCAG, whose growth and expansion benefited from his intellectual insights and organisational efforts. We extend our heartfelt condolences to Wing-Shing’s family.
Based in Hong Kong, Wing-Shing was a critical geographer and urban scholar, whose research focused on interrogating the mainstream urban thinkers with socio-historical processes and patterns of urban development, most notably in mainland China and Hong Kong, and formulating new ontology, epistemology, and methodology for this cause, especially his Tongbian-informed spatial methodology and the spatial story approach.
Contents
In 1999, Wing-Shing attended the inaugural meeting of EARCAG in South Korea, which he described as ‘a big success’ and ‘one of the best [conferences] I [have] ever attended’. It was decided at the end of the inaugural meeting that the next meeting was going to take place in Hong Kong, and ever since then he had become an active member of the International Steering Committee. In 2001, he led the organisation of the 2nd EARCAG meeting at Hong Kong Baptist University, where he had been teaching until retiring from his position of Full Professor of Geography in 2018. He co-edited, with MIZUOKA Fujio, a book entitled East Asia: A Critical Geography Perspective to publish some selected papers from this meeting. In 2016, Wing-Shing chaired the local organising committee to hold the 8th EARCAG meeting in Hong Kong again.
Over the years, Wing-Shing attended all the ten EARCAG meetings in South Korea, Hong Kong, Japan, Taiwan, and Malaysia. Wing-Shing organised or chaired conference sessions themed on, for example, ‘Post-gentrification’ (the 10th EARCAG in Taipei, 2022), ‘Social Justice and the City in East Asia’ (the 7th EARCAG in Osaka and Tohoku, 2014), the Urban Research Plaza Special Session on ‘Alternative Urban Redevelopment’ (the 6th EARCAG in Selangor, 2012), and ‘Urban Redevelopment in East Asia’ (the 5th EARCAG in Seoul, 2008). In total, he presented 15 papers at these meetings, shedding light on different geographical issues in mainland China and Hong Kong and aiming at achieving theoretical breakthroughs. He also attended the EARCAG Geopolitical Economies (EARCAG-GPE) workshops twice, in Canada and Taiwan, and presented 2 papers there.
The following list details the papers presented by Wing-Shing.
The list of papers presented by Prof TANG Wing-Shing at EARCAG
2022 | 10th EARCAG, Taipei
Towards a Land Situated Spatial Story as Informed by the Tongbian Philosophy (co-authored with Solly Benjamin)
2018 | 9th EARCAG, Daegu
Gentrification is Dead: ‘Nano’-isation in Hong Kong (co-authored with Maurice Yip)
2017 | 3rd GPE Workshop, Taipei
The Umbrella Movement in Hong Kong: A Spatial Story Approach
2016 | 8th EARCAG, Hong Kong
'Hegemony' of Property, Social and Political Struggles and Spatial Justice in Hong Kong: The Cases of Court Injunction in Admiralty during the Umbrella Movement and in Land Grabbing in Ma Shi Po, New Territories (co-authored with Yiu-Ming To)
2015 | 2nd GPE Workshop, Vancouver
Occupying Movements in Hong Kong: A Spatial Story Approach
2014 | 7th EARCAG, Osaka/Tohoku
High-density Development in Hong Kong and its Spatiality of (In)justice (co-authored with Joanna Wai-Ying Lee and Alan Smart)
2012 | 6th EARCAG, Selangor
Where is Spatial Justice in Urban (Re)development of Hong Kong – with Special Reference to the Sham Shui Po District?
2008 | 5th EARCAG, Seoul
Public Engagement as a Tool of Hegemony: The Case of Designing New Central Harbour Front in Hong Kong (co-authored with Joanna Wai-Ying Lee, Mee-Kam Ng, and Darwin Leung)
2006 | 4th EARCAG, Taipei
Space, Power and Street Sleepers in Hong Kong (co-authored with Ka-Hei Chan)
Working Class Geographies and Urban Redevelopment in an Industrial Township in Hong Kong (co-authored with Kit-Ping Wong, Ka-Hei Chan, and Kim-Ching Chan)
‘The Freedom of Shopping’ – The Commodification of Public Street in Hong Kong (co-authored with Pui-Yee Man)
Examine the New Rationality of Governmentality of the H.K. Government to Discipline Pig Farmers by Using the Yuen Long District as a Case Study (co-authored with Kin-Wing Chan)
2003 | 3rd EARCAG, Osaka/Tokyo
Global Restructuring, Urban Redevelopment and Population Displacement in Tsuen Wan, Hong Kong
Housing Movements for the Poor in Hong Kong: Fighting for the Public Rent Review
2001 | 2nd EARCAG, Hong Kong
Illegal Construction in Shenzhen: The Extension of Urban Governmentality over Time and Space
Development of Tsuen Wan New Town in Hong Kong: Power, Rationality and Space (co-authored with Kit-Ping Tammy Wong)
1999 | 1st EARCAG, Kyungju/Daegu
Governmentality, Time-space Colonisation and China’s Socialist Geography
In addition to his contributions to the debates and discussions taking place at those conferences and workshops, Wing-Shing was also willing to experiment with innovative initiatives for the growth of the EARCAG community, such as in 2023 he participated in the EARCAG open course initiative and delivered the online lectures on The Production of Space: A Critical Geography Perspective on China.
CHOI Byung-doo, one of the founders of EARCAG, recalls his memories of how Wing-Shing started to join the EARCAG community in 1999:
When the Inaugural International Conference of Critical Geography (ICCG) was held in Vancouver, Canada (1997), neoliberalism was in full swing and expanding on a global scale with serious negative impacts. Critical geographers were no exception in responding to this global economic crisis. In his paper presented at the conference with the title, ‘Global economic crisis and the need for an international critical geography’, Neil Smith, who not only led the ICCG but also supported strongly the founding of the East Asian Regional Conference in Alternative Geography (EARCAG), described the moments as follows: “There is a dramatic restructuring of global geography, from the local to the global scales, which creates an extraordinary opportunity for geographers (and geography) with a critical understanding of the social and political economy that results from the present crisis.” But we, East Asian critical geographers had another important task ahead of us. It has to be explored how capitalism on a global scale operates especially in the East Asian region with a different setting from the West.
In particular, for several years from mid-1997, the East Asian economy had experienced a serious financial crisis which turned out to be a part of neoliberal globalization process, as it was called the ‘IMF crisis’, though the situations might differ by country. Critical scholars in East Asia as well as those around the world expressed great concern about its structural backgrounds and results, critically examining the contradictions and limitations inherent in the neoliberal globalization. As suggested by Neil, “we have to create a theoretically informed political activism that links to the struggles of people everywhere” against the neoliberal process of global capitalism.
Perhaps in this kind of thought, Wing Shing might present his paper at the first meeting of EARCAG, which aimed at “developing a similar [time-space] concepts to capture the dynamics of a totally different spatial setting: China. ... [China’s socialist governmentality] is different from that observed in the West.” As implied in the above quotation, Wing Shing’s idea was directly linked to the proposal of EARCAG: “The EARCAG (East Asian Regional Conference in Alternative Geography) aims to establish an international network among alternative geographers in East Asia and to explore further perspectives to investigate local geographical issues in East Asia. Instead of merely translating spatial theories developed in the Western context into local languages, East Asian alternative geographers are needed to reconsider in their own context in order to enrich alternative geography. The EARCAG supports their challenges and encourages their activities.”
In order to encourage the participation of East Asian scholars in the inaugural meeting of ICCG, I compiled a list of critical geographers in East Asia and sent emails to inform and encourage their participation to the conference. I remember that Wing Shing’s name was on the list. Although he did not attend the ICCG meeting, he readily accepted my invitation to the 1st meeting of EARCAG. According to one of emails I sent to him at the time; “I appreciate your decision on attending the Kyongju conference, even though I am not sure whether my application for funding would be in success or not. Kyongju locates in the East-Southern region in Korean Peninsula. You can get in Kyongju by express train (called 'Saemaul') from Seoul. Or I will wait for you and other foreign participants who will come to Pusan by airplane from Seoul. I will email you a further information on our conference soon.” Hence I first met Wing Shing and George Lin, another participant from Hong Kong at Gimhae Airport on January 23, 1999, and drove them to Gyeongju, the venue of the conference.
At the first meeting of EARCAG held in Gyeongju and Daegu, Korea, Neil gave the keynote speech, and 18 people presented their papers in 6 sessions, including foreign participants, Chatchai Pongpryoon from Thailand, Wing-Shing Tang and George C.S. Lin from Hong Kong; Robert Hassink from Netherlands visiting Research fellow in Korea; Kenji Tsutsumi, Tetsushi Fujita, Toshio Mizuuchi, Fujio Mizuoka, and Naoki Oshiro from Japan. At the conference, “we had a very sincere presentation of papers and energetic discussion of our topics, with an explicit agreement that we critical and alternative scholars in East Asian countries, need to explore socio-spatial issues, encouraging our own perspectives.” After the conference, Wing Shing commented, “the conference was a big success. It was one of the best I ever attended.”
Many colleagues and friends have met Wing-Shing for many years through EARCAG. The following steering committee members recollect these precious moments and their friendships with Wing-Shing:
CHOI Byung-doo:
“The first time I met Wing Shing was in 1999, when he arrived at Gimhae Airport to attend the first meeting of EARCAG, and I drove him to Gyeongju conference venue. Since then, he and I shared close friendships and academic comrade. Perhaps he attended all of the EARCAG conferences and we talked about EARCAG. I also remember I met him staying at a jjimjilbang when he personally traveled to Daegu.
As we all know, Wing Shing organized the EARCAG conference twice in Hong-Kong, enabling passionate presentations and discussions among up to 100 participants. He also was a key member of EARCAG steering committee and worked to wisely resolve some hard situations. He showed us how critical and alternative geography of East Asia should move forward, and led us along that way. A few months ago, young scholars participated additionally in the EARCAG steering Committee, creating a fresher and more innovative atmosphere. Hence as we look forward to further development of EARCAG in the future, I wish our steering committee members and East Asian critical geographers would carry on Wing Shing spirit even though he has left us.
While I am writing this condolences, I was quite happy to reminisce about Wing Sing on the one hand, and I felt very sad on the other. I will miss Wing Shing, one of my best foreign friends. I wish he may rest in peace in the new world he dreamed of, and I want to let his family, friends, and critical geographers of East Asia hear what he would whisper in the lyrics of the song I am listening to as I write this. The title of the song is a thousand winds, which is sung with lyrics in Chinese, Japanese, Korean as well as English.
A Thousand Winds
Do not stand at my grave and weep
I am not there. I do not sleep.
I am a thousand winds that blow.
I am the diamond glints on snow.
I am the sunlight on ripened grain.
I am the gentle autumn rain.
When you awaken in the morning's hush
I am the swift uplifting rush
Of quiet birds in circled flight.
I am the soft stars that shine at night.
Do not stand at my grave and cry;
I am not there. I did not die"
CHU Ling-I:
"I began my academic pursuits very late in midlife. Wing-Shing not only inspired me intellectually but also provided timely guidance when I felt lost. I am immensely grateful for his warm encouragement, which has freed me from doubts and uncertainties, guiding me to focus on what I can do.
With the preparation of the EARCAG open course in 2023, I was fortunate to have the opportunity to interact more closely with Wing-Shing. He conducted four online lectures with the theme "The Production of Space: A Critical Geography Perspective on China." I remember asking him a silly question that had been bothering me: why does Henri Lefebvre need to employ three aspects (or trilectic) when discussing the production of space? He provided a highly insightful interpretation using the concepts of "Yin/Yang" or "Tong Bian" from Chinese philosophy. At that time, this was quite a shock to me, and I struggled to understand why he insisted on using Chinese concepts to interpret Western theory. Through his four rigorous and solid lectures, I gradually understood that his emphasis on intellectual attempts neither to pit Western/Chinese theories against each other nor to forcibly merge the two. The key, he believes, lies in understanding the production of space through the intertwined processes of historical and geographical relations and translations. In other words, he stresses the importance of using the spatial story as a method to grasp the layered translations of our history and geography. He reminds us not to simply transplant Western theories, as the real question worth pondering is how we can articulate our own spatial stories.
I will never have the opportunity to express my gratitude to him in person, and I deeply regret it. I do believe his knowledge and spirit can continue to inspire and motivate many even after his passing, guiding us to focus on stories we can tell and changes we can make."
IP Iam-Chong:
"To be honest, I do not remember when and where I first met Wing Shing. I read his works a long time ago when I was an undergraduate. He is definitely one of the most important geographers in East Asia, not to mention Hong Kong. I often came across him on different occasions, such as academic conferences, friends’ meeting places, rallies, assemblies, etc, in Hong Kong and Taipei. Although I never formally enrolled in his courses at the Baptist University, I regard him as my teacher and learned a lot from him. I was always impressed by his thoughtful speeches. He also cared so much about my academic career and showed his support to me. For example, to my surprise, when he served as external reviewer for the program of my department, he complained to my senior colleagues that they did not promote me more quickly!
My background is not geography. My little knowledge about critical and alternative geography of East Asia mostly came from Wing Shing. He demonstrated to us how it should look like and its possibilities for making the world better. I am happy to know that he inspired a significant number of young activists and scholars, especially those in Hong Kong, who benefited a lot from his teaching and support. I believe all of us, including the EARCAG Steering Committee, will carry on Wing Shing’s spirit. I will miss him. His contribution to the community and the academic world will always be remembered."
Jim GLASSMAN:
“Wing Shing was a uniquely warm and generous man, as well as a first-rate critical scholar. I have many fond memories of Wing Shing, but two kinds of experiences I had with him seem to me to illustrate the type of person he was.
One was my experience of his calm and constructive presence during EARCAG meetings, where he always seemed able--even in the midst of significant disagreement--to strike a conciliatory chord that maintained the critical discussion without allowing it to devolve.
The second experience was my brief but warm interactions with him last year when we were both involved in teaching the first ever EARCAG-supported Open (online) courses. Wing Shing and I shared some ideas during this time, both of us scratching our (greying) heads and trying to figure out how to navigate the spaces of transnational internet education. I've always suspected that he dealt with this more adroitly than I, and I'm so very sorry that I'll no longer be able to benefit from his insights on this kind of project.
I hope very much that EARCAG will keep his memory and his generous spirit of educational service alive through our future activities.”
HSU Jinn-yuh:
“I got to know EARCAG and Wing-Shing through the introduction of my master’s supervisor, Hsia Chu-joe, after he came back from the first Daegu meeting. I became the most junior steering committee member at the second EARCAG conference organized by Wing-Shing in Hong Kong, and I did not feel so comfortable in the meetings because all other members were my teachers, but Wing-Shing always told me “it’s okay” in Chinese with a Hong Kong accent, which brought me closer to him.
For me, as an economic geographer, critical geography is the perspective of Western Marxist geography in my learning process, and this so-called “critical” or alternative theory almost dominated my intellectual position in my early career. Positioning myself in this kind of Western left-wing perspective has been constantly copied in my published articles which applied the so-called empirical data in Taiwan, to validate the correctness of the critical theories. It is also under this perspective that I understand Wing-Shing’s research on Chinese cities and his application of Lefebvre’s “production of space”. But I found it difficult to digest his criticism of the Chinese urban studies in the mainstream geography community, given that most of the literature applied the dominant “critical” theories very well. I just naively wonder why bother to produce “our” own theories and concepts. However, the more work I have done, the more uncomfortable and ungrounded I felt in meeting the challenges from the local situations. I also began to reflect on the question of why the theories we read, that claim to be universal, are all put forward by these "critical" scholars in the West, and then scholars in East Asia, and of course in other regions, provide a lot of empirical research to verify and apply these theoretical concepts. I felt myself doing some kind of subcontracting, or OEM (original equipment manufacturing) in the academic division of labor with the Western critical masters. This feeling convinced me more and more of the need to critique these "critical geographies".
In this sense, Wing-Shing is ahead of us. Not only has he been able to grasp Western theories clearly, but he has also conceptualized the experiences that have grown up in China, and collaborated with scholars in India to truly implement the idea of starting from the margins to challenge the long post-war Western theoretical traditions. This was an important reason for me to invite him to Taiwan when I organized the 10th EARCAG conference in 2022. Too many international conferences held in East Asia do not have any keynote speakers being local scholars, but EARCAG has made a good start in this regard. I expect the EARAG group to inherit Wing Shing’s grounded research, to be able to dialogue with the mainstream of the West, but also to be able to produce concepts from local knowledge and experience. This work of decolonization is more important to the East Asian critical geography community than ever.”
HSU Szu-Yun:
“My memory with Wing-Shing goes back to my time as a PhD student and all the encouraging conversations I had with him during the EARCAG events, where Wing-Shing always started with a warm and caring conversation about my study and life – and it did not take me too long to realize how genuine he was as a person and as a critical scholar. On a typical rainy winter day after the 2022 EARCAG in Taipei, we had a casual lunch in the back alley of the National Normal University, where we were chatting about my teaching experiences at a Western institution, and how that had influenced my view of EARCAG. This turned out to be the last meeting I had with Wing-Shing, and his encouraging words back then were and will always be powerful. His impact on all of us as an individual and as a critical academic community shows that he will never truly leave us.”
Geerhardt KORNATOWSKI:
“In March 2020, I had the pleasure of organizing one workshop with Wing Shing. We invited scholars who work on social movements, as we felt it was necessary to focus on the emerging localities of significant protest movements outside, yet also in connection to, the West, following the events that had unfolded in Hong Kong between 2019 and 2020. Due to the pandemic, we could not organize it in Fukuoka, so we eventually did it online.
To Wing Shing, workshops (but also conferences and seminars) were precious moments of conviviality, to be enjoyed through rigorous, yet friendly academic discussions, but (perhaps even more importantly) also through good food and caring conversations. Wing Shing knew everyone in his network. He would sit down with everyone and even start talking about trivial things. I guess food for him was an important way to facilitate such an atmosphere. Often, he would inquire to us which cuisine we should choose for the workshop at hand. I’d like to think he grew fond of Thai food in Kowloon City because I would recommend it every time. He really liked the Beijing dishes in Tsim Sha Tsui (every time it would be the same course!). Most of the time he would take everyone to have Sichuan hotpot in Prince Edward (even if it was just to spice things up!).
Many would remember his early-time dim sum lunches, to which he took those who stayed behind after the workshops. There was/is an excellent place in Lok Fu, just not too far to walk from HKBU. He would order the best, yet always too much. The last time I met Wing Shing was in a dim sum restaurant in Sheung Wan at the end of 2023 (he had already moved to HK Island), where we had lunch with just the 2 of us. It was impossible to pay the bill without his consent.
Wing Shing visited Fukuoka twice, once for holiday purposes, and once on my invitation. I showed him some very local parts in the city, and we had some good yakiniku, along with lots of small talk. He really liked Japan and he was always puzzled by its urban spaces.”
MIZUUCHI Toshio:
“If there were encounters and scenes in life that one would never forget, it would be the meeting with Wing Shing during the first EARCAG organized by Byung-doo on January 23, 1999. The next morning, Wing Shing's presentation (which also captivated me with its Ted Talk-like speech performance), followed by my own presentation in the late afternoon, greatly stimulated each other's intellectual curiosity. The title of his presentation was "Governmentality, Time-Space Colonization, and China’s Socialist Geography", which focused on East Asia, nation-states, power, and development, illustrating his dedication to East Asia, with his slightly accented yet resolutely British English speech echoing in my mind.
The conference, which proved to be highly fruitful for both (of course all attendants), continued in Taegu on the 25th. I vividly remember the half-day tour on the final day, the 26th, visiting places like Gyeongju and Bulguksa Temple. The most impressive shot of Wing Shing and George Lin like a comedian, smiling and waving to each other at Kimhae Airport in the evening, when we vowed to meet again, still hasn't appeared. Exactly 25 years later, on January 26th, he passed away. Is such a coincidence possible in this world? It's incredibly regrettable and heartbreaking that what was meant to be a temporary parting with a vow to meet again ended up being the final farewell after just 25 years.
The encounter between the two of us in the end of 1990s profoundly changed the trajectory of our academic pursuits afterward. Unexpectedly, the expansion of research into East Asia began so sudden, that in the autumn of 2000, we applied for funding from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science for a project titled "Homelessness and Squatting Issues in Advanced Asian Regions: A Comparative Study of Japan, South Korea, and Hong Kong," which was successfully approved for a three-year period starting in 2001. From the very beginning, inquiring with Wing Shing, I learned there were no researchers studying homeless shelters / transit housing in Hong Kong at the time. I asked him how to start such research. From there, a series of shelter / transit housing / urban hostels surveys began, and interviews with NGOs and religious social welfare organizations were conducted. Since March 2001, both of us transitioned significantly to a community-based research style. Wing Shing's street-level activities intensified and deepened in the 2000s, as evidenced by the founding of the Hong Kong Critical Geography Group in 2002 and his subsequent career trajectory.
Reflecting on that time, Wing Shing said, "(Though URP fund,) I have started to build up more intimate networks with social welfare agencies in the city. Accordingly, I have started to know the local community much better than before. For example, the issue of homelessness used to be a vague concept in my mind, and community organizations like SoCO (Society for Community Organization) were alien entities to me. However, thanks to Toshio, everything changed. This has in turn provided an additional avenue for me to disseminate to the community my more theoretical works on the urban development of the city. This has turned out to be a win-win situation for me." (This passage is quoted from "Mizuuchi-san: An Admiration and Appreciation," contributed as a first draft in December 2021, to the journal of the Urban Research Plaza upon my retirement. It is a valuable text that captures his thoughts, and serves as a key to understanding his research developments in the 2000s.)
A major commonality between us was constantly seeking the optimal solution for how city states produce space (the representation of space) and how NGOs and users consume and manage that space negotiating to reach consensus in their community or neighborhood. Along with Wing Shing, who has gone to heaven ahead of me, still we both would like to pursue this in East Asia, whether it is a representation of space or not. This may be a part of his vision for critical geography in East Asia.”
MORI Masato:
“I came to know Wing Shing in the 4th EARCAG meeting in Taipei, 2006, which was the first attendance to international conference for me. I was impressed how presentations from Hong Kong shared similar critical perspective, and realised Wing Shing was a key person for the perspective in Hong Kong. I had been very happy to see Wing Shing in the following series of EARCAG meetings. He always kept smiling even after heated discussions. In a series of meeting and workshop, he had always been kind to all people: I have witnessed that he often invited people being alone to his table in teatime and banquet.
The last opportunity to see him and enjoy chat was in the 9th EARCAG, 2018, as I was compelled to cancel my presentation in the 10th meeting in 2022. It is now a huge regret not to attend it for me.
I really appreciate his academic supports. I, as a new steering committee member, really expected to do some new things in and for EARCAG with him. I shall keep numerous memories of him in my mind.
Thank you, Wing Shing.”
PARK Bae-Gyoon:
“Professor Wing-Shing Tang was always kind, thoughtful, and very committed to EARCAG. In particular, his sense of commitment and balance during EARCAG's important business meetings was an important reason for my respect for him. Whenever we were faced with difficult situations where decisions could not be made easily due to differences in positions, Professor Wing-Shing Tang always showed a balanced attitude of looking at the big picture and a long, broad stance and attitude of looking at the whole rather than individual personal interests. As someone who was the youngest member of the EARCAG Steering committee for more than a decade until the mid-2010s, I always admired this attitude and felt that I could rely on him as a big brother.
The next thing I would like to remember about Professor Wing-Shing Tang is that whenever he had the opportunity to meet and talk with me personally, he always told me that we should not uncritically import Western theories to explain East Asian urban and regional problems, but should develop our own theories and conceptual frameworks based on East Asian experiences. Based on this awareness of the problem, he adopted the theories of Western critical spatial thinkers such as Lefebvre to a certain extent, but applied Eastern philosophy based on the logic of yin and yang to create a new conceptual framework to explain urban problems in China and Hong Kong. It does not matter how successful these efforts were academically. I admire his fearlessness and boldness in attempting such an endeavour, and I think this is the path that future scholars in East Asia who study and practice critical geography should follow.
Professor Wing-Shing Tang's contribution to the development of critical urban and regional studies in East Asia is indescribable, and he will forever be remembered in our hearts.
送友人
李白 (A.D. 701 ~ 762)
靑山橫北郭
白水繞東城
此地一爲別
孤蓬萬里征
浮雲游子意
落日故人情
揮手自玆去
蕭蕭班馬鳴"
SHIN HaeRan:
“It is hard to think of EARCAG without Wing Shing's passionate participation. I vividly remember how he presented multiple sessions featuring studies that he collaborated on with his students. For my presentation, he once challenged me for relying solely on Western scholars' studies for my theoretical framework. Honestly, I didn't have an alternative at the time, and I still don't, but his point made me think about the structure of academia. He was a great friend and colleague. I will remember his critical studies and warm heart.”
SHIN Hyun Bang:
“It’s a great loss for the critical Asian studies and urban scholarship. I was fortunate to attend the workshops he organised, which were characteristic of Wing Shing - both thought provoking and humorous, filled with exciting city walks and collegial engagement among old and new friends over delicious food. I remember how I was delighted to be part of the workshops and learnt a lot from them. His welcoming attitude made me feel at home at the time, a feeling further strengthened by his invitation to a dim sum lunch with his students. Wing Shing will be dearly missed by many colleagues and friends in the critical urban scholarship. Critical urban scholars from Asia have lost one of its beacons, which is going to be irreparable.”
SONN Jung Won:
“When Wing Shing gave the plenary presentation in the 2022 Taipei EARCAG, he looked equally energetic as I met him for the first time in a boat trip after the UK planning conference in London in 2006 and in EARCAG conferences afterwards. It was really a shock to me. His passing is a big loss for all of us. We finally have the critical mass to do anything that is actually East Asian urban studies (as opposed to application of Western theories to East Asian cities) and his experiences would have been extremely valuable in coming years. I will miss his gentle manners as well as his insightful research for years to come.”
Kit Ping (Tammy) WONG:
“In 1998, Wing-Shing joined the Geography Department at HKBU as a new professor, while I was a first-year undergraduate student. He was the only professor in the department to teach critical geographical concepts - an abstruse subject for first-year students, but laid an important foundation for my later academic pathway. He taught me a different way of analysing cities through historical geography, and became the supervisor of my final-year undergraduate thesis. The following year, he invited me to be his MPhil student, and brought me into a wider world of knowledge. In 2001, we attended the AAG conference in Los Angeles — my first experience presenting our work internationally. In 2002, I attended the 2nd EARCAG conference which was organised by Wing-Shing, and where I met many of his comrades from the greater academic community worldwide.
In the same year, Wing-Shing, another student and I formed a study group to explore critical theories such as space, power and social (in)justice. We felt a strong sense of urgent call due to the lack of knowledge and critical perspectives needed to explain the urban phenomena in Hong Kong. Firstly, geography students were mainly trained in the positivist and quantitative approaches, to become part of institutions like urban planning and education. Secondly, many students dislike reading long texts and struggle to understand difficult concepts and theories.
Our study group was unprecedented in the department, but we were determined to start from scratch. Working with Wing-Shing, I co-organised the study groups and led discussions, and, as his teaching assistant, connected with his students, and organised community visits. In the study group, we delved into critical theories such as “Urbanisation of injustices", David Harvey's "Unequal Geographical Development" and his spatial analysis, John Allen's "Lost Geographies of Power", Doreen Massey's "For Space" and "The Power Geometry of Time-Space", Henri Lefebvre's "The Production of Space", Michel Foucault's "Governmentality", and others. I was new to these literatures, and lacked the confidence to guide students in reading them. However, such intensive reading guided my everyday life in my young ages: studying day-by-day until the university closed at midnight. This let me deeply immersed in all these critical urban theories, profoundly influenced my academic and personal life, and fundamentally changed my perspective.
In the early 2000s, critical geographies did not play any role in public discourse. However, the city began to experience various kinds of urban crises and social conflicts in the course of urban development after 1997. During this period, Wing-Shing began to conduct different research projects, and collaborated with other researchers. He began to actively intervene in academic and public discussions through the critical perspective of urban studies, rethinking processes of urbanisation and power relations, and various issues of social (in)justices. This perspective was a continuation of his concern on the urban and land issues since the 1980s, that combined with a new condition of post-1997 Hong Kong, followed by a range of experiences and reflections from various struggles, especially in the second half of the 2000s.
We went to the old working-class neighbourhoods in Tsuen Wan, learnt about the process of urban renewal and the history of workers’ movement for housing in the midst of socio-economic restructuring. We studied the development trajectory of Tin Shui Wai new town in a geo-political context of Hong Kong and the peripheralization of working-class families. In 2004, we joined the struggles against the redevelopment of Lee Tung Street in Wan Chai, and later the preservation of “Blue House”. Wing-Shing launched a community project in Wan Chai, which brought different people together to discuss the vision of spatial planning for Wanchai in future. He pushed forward critical theories, established a close relationship with other scholars, local councillors, NGOs, social activists and local residents. By 2007, we were all at the Star Ferry and Queen’s Pier and struggled against land development and claimed for our public space. Wing-Shing gave his speech at the “People’s Forum”, among other scholars, alongside the hunger strikes against the demolition.
Over these years, our lives were criss-crossed between the pursuit of critical theories and the struggles in different controversial sites. This was what we said, “with one foot in the university and the other in the community”. Late at night, we were still at Edinburgh Place, trying to defend the Star Ferry and the Queen’s Pier. We had to revise our languages to communicate with non-geography scholars, activists, social workers and residents; and we also had to reflect our views on what constituted a critical perspective and built our own theory for Hong Kong. In his criticism of the official story of “tiny land, many people” to understand urban development of Hong Kong, the so-called economic view of “land supply and demand”, the simplistic view of grassroots’ lives as just a matter of poverty, Wing-Shing never compromised and held back his arguments, and boldly pointed out the blindspots of the academia.
This is the intellectual life I have experienced with Wing-Shing that I will never forget. In our pursuit of theory and practices, each social movement constantly challenged our limits in knowledge, and at the same time opened up our thoughts. In 2011, I started my PhD studies, extended my research from Hong Kong to China. As Wing-Shing has been a scholar in China’s urban studies since the 1980s, he advised my study. Our conversation was therefore extended to urban issues in China, as well as the relationship between China and Hong Kong. We went to Shenzhen, Dongguan and Guangzhou to conduct fieldwork in the cities and urbanised villages. The last 25 years of my academic journey is filled by Wing-Shing’s advice, encouragement and support. Wing-Shing played the most important role in my life for he taught me what critical knowledge is, and being the role-model of a public intellectual.”
Maurice YIP:
“Many of my fellow Steering Committee members met Wing-Shing through EARCAG, but in my case it was through Wing-Shing that I was introduced to EARCAG and to a much wider world, both academically and personally. I completed my undergraduate and MPhil degrees under Wing-Shing’s supervision, during which I had the opportunity not only to assist him in organising the 2016 meeting in Hong Kong, but also to attend the 2018 meeting in Daegu together. We interacted almost every day, and this frequent interaction continued even after I left Hong Kong. I wasn’t sure, but I probably took up and wasted too much of his time, yet my personal growth benefited immensely from our discussions on a wide range of topics, from very rigorous academic and intellectual debates to very casual TV dramas, films, and popular songs (although he could always relate the latter to his philosophical thinking – which I am still trying hard to understand a bit). He has changed the fundamental way in which I make sense of the world. I am grateful for everything he had done for me.
Wing-Shing spent (a lot of) time with his students and the community, in addition to spending time with his family. I bet not many professors would spend their precious weekends holding reading groups with students and community members, taking us to different parts of the city just to read and discuss academic texts in the context of local society. Wing-Shing really cared about people, society, and the world. I think it is this admirable attitude of being a caring person that formed the basis of his critical perspectives and voices for spatial justice. Even in today’s competitive academic system, Wing-Shing did not follow the mainstream trend, nor did he sacrifice the standard and quality of his work in order to publish a large number of papers quickly. Rather, he encouraged his students and colleagues to debate and think, to take time for intellectual development, to intervene for better social change. Wing-Shing cared about people and liked to interact with them, which was probably the reason why he enjoyed conferences and workshops so much, as they provided the appropriate setting for academic debate and making friends.
We knew of Wing-Shing’s quest for excellence and his commitment to challenging the dominant literature and developing original theories. He didn’t restrict himself as an urban geographer, but he positioned himself as a critical geographer, not merely for the development of the field called human geography, indeed his geographical work was conducted for contributing transformative knowledge to the world. He saw EARCAG as a space that could make such goals possible, academically rooted in the local and regional contexts but being able to interact with the global society. His spirit will stay with us, motivating us to pursue academic breakthroughs and struggle for alternative futures.”
Wing-Shing will be missed. We remember the times when we would gather to share mocha and engage in thought-provoking conversations with Wing-Shing during the session breaks of the conferences and workshops. His warmth and generosity extended beyond mere hospitality to the realm of enriching our minds, offering us delicious food for thought and refilling our glasses with both drinks and laughter. Wing-Shing’s critical insights demonstrate a testament to his care and love for his city, the region, and the world, contributing to our collective struggles for the alternative futures.
For knowing more about Wing-Shing’s life and work, we invite the EARCAG community to read the obituary notice from Wing-Shing’s family (https://bit.ly/in-memory-of-prof-tang-wing-shing), and also the memorial pieces from the Department of Geography at Hong Kong Baptist University (https://geog.hkbu.edu.hk/upload/files/1/file/65bb3b06701ff.pdf) and the Hong Kong Critical Geography Group (https://hkcgg.wordpress.com/memoriam).
We also invite the EARCAG community to share your thoughts and memories at the bottom of this page.
We look forward to appropriately honouring Wing-Shing’s life and contributions at the future EARCAG meetings.
International Steering Committee
East Asian Regional Conference in Alternative Geography
Carolyn CARTIER (University of Technology Sydney):
“Professor Wing Shing Tang, leading urban geographer of Hong Kong, original theorist of China's transformation, and esteemed colleague on five continents, will continue to inspire original and critical work as well as be perennially recalled for his generous and modest approach, extending kind support to students and colleagues and intellectually energizing his peers. Wherever he went he multiplied possibilities. He set a very high bar for intellectual camaraderie and thoughtful humanity which, in his memory, we will continue to recall, seek to reach, and enjoy and appreciate in continuing dedication to his work.”
CHEN Hung-Ying (National Chengchi University):
“I came to encounter Prof. Tang Wing Shing in late 2018 and early 2019. When I asked him to be my host for a visiting position at the Hong Kong Baptist University via email exchanges, he generously agreed to be my host for a short-term visit to the Department of Geography and the Centre for Chinese Studies of the Hong Kong Baptist University, that I was able to get to know him beyond a prestigious scholar, but also as a person whose life history, key practices as a public intellectual, and everyday practices fully demonstrate the infinite possibilities that a critical East Asian geographer can present.
When I arrived in Hong Kong in April 2019, he, who had already retired at the time, prepared a spacious and independent office for me despite not knowing me before and all the administrative obstacles. He also introduced me to his students who were active in various fields, allowing me to read about Hong Kong intensively and deeply in a short period. From the lunches to the daily conversations to the comments from his students and colleagues, people speak highly of him for his openness, wittiness, and self-disciplined attitude toward critical geographical education and research. I am deeply grateful for all his generosity, his selflessness, and how his critical vision has nourished generations of East Asian critical geographers. I always thought that could I act as he does to others in a similar circumstance. I never thought that the goodbye would be forever.
Thank you, Prof. Tang, for physically cultivating a fertile ground for critical geography and urban practice in East Asia and beyond.”
Jamie DOUCETTE (University of Manchester):
“It is very sad to receive this news. Wing-Shing's warm and guiding presence was always felt at EARCAGs. His scholarship, commitment, and solidarity with grassroots struggles really embodied the spirit of critical geographical enquiry that EARCAG embraced. He always had excellent ideas and was warm and generous with feedback and contacts for research. He leaves such a positive legacy.”
Salvatore ENGEL-DI MAURO (State University of New York at New Paltz):
“It is with great sadness to learn of Professor Tang's passing. He was a dear and generous colleague. I still have the Hong Kong Critical Geography Group t-shirts he shared with me and now they are even more precious. He had brought one of them to me when we met at one of the annual meetings of the Association of American Geographers (I think it was in Boston, if my recollection is not faulty). The other was a gift given when I had the privilege of attending and presenting at the Hong Kong EARCAG conference in 2016, when we last had the chance to see each other in person. Without his assistance, including by securing funds, it would not have been possible for me to go. His contributions to the field of Human Geography and to Critical Geography in particular have been among the reasons for my involvement in such academic work. He was always upbeat and very sharp, a shining example to us all.”
Tim OAKES (University of Colorado at Boulder):
“Wing-Shing was a great mentor to me, and a huge influence on my scholarship. I first met him when I came to Hong Kong on my way to do dissertation fieldwork in Guizhou. That was 1993. At that time, he organized for me to give a talk at CUHK. He also helped me with many other things as I prepared for my fieldwork and a future academic career. We stayed in touch over the years of course, and collaborated on a couple projects. He always had such a clear-headed perspective on things, and was a master at engaging theory critically based on his deep knowledge of land and related issues in Hong Kong. The last time I saw him was in Taipei, for the EARCAG conference in December, 2022. I was giving a keynote address and he introduced me. I think it was actually his recommendation that resulted in the keynote invitation. His support always meant so much to me. His introduction was, as usual, warm and funny. I will miss him terribly, and I am so sorry for such a huge loss.”
PARK Se Hoon (Korea Research Institute for Human Settlements):
“I was shocked and saddened to know that Prof. Wing Shing Tang passed away last month. With deepest sorrow, I would like to send my sincere condolences to his family and, here, want to share my memories of him with all the people who suffer from his sudden passing.
Prof. Wing Shing Tang was an committed researcher, energetic writer, inspiring mentor, and, above all, a good friend to all the people around him. I first met him at the critical geography conference held in Daegu, South Korea, in 1999, when he was already a renowned scholar at Hong Kong Baptist University and I was a Ph.D. student at Seoul National University. During the conference, I was charmed by his warm and friendly manner as well as his critical perspective on contemporary urban studies in East Asia. For me, he opened a new window of critical urban studies based on East Asian experiences that were hard to be explained through the mainstream urban theories. Since then, Prof. Tang has been my mentor and, at the same time, a life-long friend, despite the physical distance between Hong Kong and Seoul.
It is heartbreaking for me to refresh such lovely memories of him from the past twenty-something years. I met him mostly through the EARCAG conferences along with some other academic events. We organized seminars, wrote papers and made study trips together in many cities in East Asia. He also provided me with opportunities to work with superb scholars in the region such as Liling Huang, KC Ho, and Wan Liu. As our friendship deepened, we also met in Seoul and Hong Kong on our holidays, often joined by family members. We talked, walked, and ate together in Tsim Sha Tsui, Wan Chai, and Mong Kok in Hong Kong, and in Myeong Dong, Yeouido, and Chenggye-cheon in Seoul. In the past twenty years, Hong Kong has become the city that I visit most, and Prof. Tang has always been there to welcome me. Last year, I exchanged a piece of email with him in which he invited me to Hong Kong to tour some new development sites together. I did not make it, but also, I did not know it was the last chance to see him.
In the past couple of days after I received the tragic news, I realized how big Prof. Tang is in my life. I learned immensely from him with respect to not only how to be a good thinker but also how to be a good person. Henry Thoreau once said that “nothing makes the earth seem so spacious as to have friends at a distance; they make the latitudes and longitudes." I feel exactly the same when I remember him and, in this regard, I deeply appreciate for everything that he brought to me.
Now my thoughts are with Prof. Tang’s family and everyone who is affected by his untimely passing. May he rest in peace.”