Dog training is the application of behavioral analysis that uses the environmental events of antecedents and consequences to change the dog’s behavior, either to assist in specific activities or to perform certain tasks or to effectively participate in the contemporary domestic life. While training dogs for specific roles dates back at least to Roman times, training dogs to be compatible pets developed with suburbanization in the 1950s.
A dog learns from interactions it has with its environment. This can be through classical conditioning, where it links two stimuli; non-associative learning, in which behavior is changed by habituation or sensitization; and operant conditioning, where it links an antecedent to its effect.
There are several established methods of animal training, each with its adherents and critics. Some of the more famous dog training procedures include the Koehler method, clicker training, motivation training, electronic training, model rival training, dominance-based training, and relationship-based training. The common features of successful methods are knowing the animal’s traits and personality, accurate timing of reinforcement or punishment, and consistent communication. The use of punishment is controversial, as both humanity and effectiveness are questioned by many behaviorists.
Dog training is the teaching of certain skills or behaviors to a dog. Dog training involves teaching a dog to respond to certain commands and directions and to act independently by deliberately changing its natural behavior.
Dogs are trained to perform a variety of practical functions including search and rescue, herding livestock, guarding, detecting explosives or drugs, disability assistance, dogs are also trained to perform recreational functions including companionship, shooting assistance.
Dog training usually involves basic obedience training to gain control of the animal and then progresses to more advanced specialized training. Basic obedience training involves teaching a dog:
Remember training – teach the dog to come on command
Sitting training – teaching the dog to sit on command
Walk or Stroke Training – Teaching the dog to walk on or off with the handler
Keep training – teach the dog not to wander on command
Sociability training – teach the dog not to be aggressive towards people, other dogs or other animals.
While research on how dogs learn and on communication between species has changed the approach to dog training in recent decades, understanding the role of early trainers and scientists contributes to an appreciation of how certain methods and techniques evolved.
Before 1900
Around 127-116 BC. a Roman farmer, Marcus Varro, took advice on raising and training puppies for herding livestock. His writings indicate that not only was dog training for specific tasks well established, but the value of early training was recognized.
In 1848 W.N. Hutchinson’s book Dog Breaking: The Most Expedeful, Certain and Easy Method, Of Great Excellence, or Only Mediocrity Is Required, with opportunities and goals for those who love the dog and the gun. The book is primarily concerned with training hunting dogs, such as pointers and setters, and advocates some form of reward-based training, commenting on men who “ have a strong arm and a hard heart to punish, but no temper and no head to instruct “and suggests” Always be kind to his virtues. Be a little blind to his mistakes. ” Stephen Hammond, a writer for Forest and Stream magazine, argued in his 1882 book Practical Training that hunting dogs should be praised and rewarded with meat for doing the correct behavior.
War years
Konrad Most began training dogs for police work in Germany, and was appointed director of the State Breeding and Training Institute for Police Dogs in Berlin, where he conducted original research on training dogs for a wide variety of service tasks. At the outbreak of war in 1914, he was charged with organizing and directing the use of dogs to further the war effort. He headed the Experimental Institute for Armed Forces Dogs during World War II and then ran the Great Dane Farm, a center for the training of working dogs, including service dogs for the blind. He was instrumental in the formation of the German Canine Research Society and Society for Animal Psychology. His 1910 publication, Training Dogs: A Manual, emphasized the use of instinctive behaviors such as the prey drive to train desired behavior, advocated the use of coercion and exhortation, distinguished between primary and secondary reinforcers, and described formative behaviors, where components of an activity were concatenated, and the importance of timing of rewards and penalties. The book demonstrated an understanding of the principles of operant conditioning nearly thirty years before they were formally set forth by B.F. Skinner in The Behavior of Organisms.
Marian Breland Bailey was instrumental in the development of empirically validated and humane animal training methods and in promoting their widespread adoption . Marian was a graduate student at B.F. Skinner. Her first husband Keller Breland also came to study with Skinner and they worked with him to train pigeons to guide bombs. The Brelands saw the commercial potential of operant training and founded Animal Behavior Enterprises (ABE). In 1955 they opened the “IQ Zoo” as both a training facility and a showcase of trained animals. They were among the first to use trained animals in TV commercials, and the first to train dolphins and whales as entertainment, as well as for the Navy. [14] Keller died in 1965, and in 1976 Marian married Bob Bailey, who was director of marine mammal training for the Navy. They pioneered the use of the clicker as a conditioned reinforcer for remote animal training. [13] ABE then trained thousands of animals from more than 140 species. [14] Their work received significant public attention through press coverage of ABE-trained animals, bringing the principles of behavioral analysis and operant conditioning to a wide audience.
Konrad Lorenz, an Austrian scientist who is considered to be developing the foundations of ethological research , further popularized animal behavior with his books Man Meets Dog and King Solomon’s Ring. Lorenz stated that there were three essential commands for teaching a dog: “lie down” (stay where you are), “basket” (go there), and “heel” (come with me).
In 1935 the American Kennel Club began obedience trials, and in the years that followed, popular magazines made the public aware of the benefits of having a trained dog and the recreational possibilities of dog training as a hobby. After World War II, the increasing complexity of suburban life demanded that the dog be obedient for a dog’s own protection and for the convenience of its owner. William Koehler had served as head trainer at the War Dog Training Center, in California, and after the war became head trainer of the Orange Empire Dog Club – at the time the largest dog club in the United States – instructor for a number of breeds. clubs and a dog trainer for Walt Disney Studios. In 1962, Koehler published The Koehler Method of Dog Training, in which he is highly critical of what he calls “useful training techniques” based on “the chatter of ‘dog psychologists'”. One of the training innovations attributed to Koehler is the use of a long line in conjunction with a complete absence of verbal communication as a means of instilling attention prior to any line training. Koehler insisted that participants in his training classes used “ emphatic corrections, ” which included leash shocks and throwing chains, and explained that gentle, nagging corrections were cruel because they caused emotional disturbances in the dog. Vicki Hearne, a student of Koehler’s, commented on the widespread criticism of his corrections, stating that it was the emotionally charged language used in the book that led to a number of lawsuits and the book being released for a while. Arizona was banned. Despite the controversy, his basic method is at the heart of many contemporary training systems.
In the 1980s, veterinarian and animal behavior therapist Ian Dunbar found that despite evidence about peak periods in animals, few dog trainers worked with puppies before they were six months old. Dunbar founded Sirius Dog Training, the first off-leash training program specifically for puppies, which emphasizes the importance of teaching dogs less than six months of bite inhibition, sociality and other basic housekeeping practices. Dunbar has written numerous books and is known for his international seminar presentations and award-winning videos on puppy and dog behavior and training.
Before the 1980s, Karen Pryor was a marine mammal trainer who used Skinner’s operant principles to teach dolphins and develop marine mammal shows. In 1984 she published her book Don’t Shoot the Dog: The New Art of Teaching and Training, an explanation of operant conditioning procedures written for the general public. In the book, Pryor explains why punishment often fails as a way of getting people to change, and describes specific positive ways to change the behavior of husbands, children and pets. Pryor’s training materials and canine seminars demonstrated how operant procedures can be used to provide training based on positive reinforcement of good behavior. Pryor and Gary Wilkes introduced clicker training for dog trainers with a series of seminars in 1992 and 1993. Wilkes used both aversives and rewards, and the philosophical differences soon ended the collaboration.
The 21st century has seen a boom in television programs and accompanying books on dog training and rehabilitation , including Joel Silverman’s Good Dog U, Dog Whisperer with Cesar Millan, It’s Me or the Dog featuring Victoria Stillwell, The Underdog Show, Dogs in the City and SuperFetch. The Association of Pet Dog Trainers recommends that television programs be produced primarily for entertainment, and while all programs will have good and bad marks, the viewer should critically evaluate the information before deciding which training tips to apply.TRAINING METHODS:
Koehler method
Strictly following the model outlined in the Koehler Method of Dog Training, some 50 years later, the Koehler Method is still taught in both classroom and private training forms. The method is based on the philosophy that a dog acts according to its right to choose its actions. Koehler explained that a dog’s learned behavior is a choice based on its own learning experience. When those choices are influenced by the expectation of reward, the behavior will most likely be repeated, and when those choices are influenced by the expectation of punishment, they will most likely cease. Once the dog has learned that his choices bring comfort or discomfort, he can be taught to make the right decisions. Action → Memory → Desire includes the learning pattern used by the method; the dog acts, remembers the consequences and forms the desire to repeat or avoid those consequences. Supporters believe that once the behavior has been correctly learned, it should be carried out so that any correction is fair, reasonable and expected. Although the model has been used consistently since 1962, some of the criminal procedures described in the book are now considered unnecessary, humane, or appropriate by many trainers.
Motivational training
Purely positive or motivational training uses rewards to reinforce good behaviour and ignores all bad behaviour. It is based on Thorndike’s Law of Effect, which says that actions that earn rewards tend to increase in frequency and actions that do not earn rewards decrease in frequency.
Motivational training has its roots in training animals in captivity, where coercion and correction are both difficult and dangerous, and ignoring bad behaviour is not problematic as the animal lives under controlled conditions. As a dog training strategy, purely positive training is achievable, but difficult, as it takes time and patience to master the rewards the dog receives for its behaviour. Some activities, such as jumping up or chasing squirrels, are intrinsically rewarding, the activity is its own reward, and in some activities the environment can provide reinforcement, such as when the neighbour dog’s response encourages barking.
Clicker training is a nickname given to a positive reinforcement training system based on operant conditioning. Clicker training can also be called marker training. The system uses conditioned amplifiers that can be delivered faster and more accurately than primary amplifiers such as food. The term “clicker” comes from a small metal cricket adapted to a children’s toy that the trainer uses to precisely mark the desired behavior; However, some trainers use a whistle, word, or even light as the conditioned reinforcer. The trainer supplies a primary reinforcer, such as a toy or treat, after the sound or signal. A common criticism of clicker training is that it is prone to the over-justification effect.
Electronic training
Electronic training involves the use of an electric shock as an aversive. Common shapes include collars that can be remotely triggered or triggered by barking, fences that provide a shock when a dog with a special collar crosses a buried wire, and mats that can be placed on furniture to provide a shock . Some aids have an aversive effect, such as a citronella spray when activated. The use of electric shock aversives for training dogs has been the subject of considerable controversy. Supporters argue that the use of electronic devices allows for remote training and has the potential to eliminate self-rewarding behaviors, and point out that when used properly, they have less risk of stress and injury than mechanical devices, such as throttle chains. Opponents cite the risks of physical and psychological trauma associated with improper or abuse.
In one study, lab-bred Beagles were divided into three groups. Group A received an electric shock when the dogs touched the prey (a rabbit doll attached to a musculoskeletal system). Group H was shocked when they disobeyed a previously trained recall command while on the hunt. Dogs in group R received the electric shock randomly, i.e. the shock was delivered unpredictably and out of context. Group A showed no significant increase in salivary cortisol levels, while Group R and Group H showed a significant increase. This led to the conclusion that animals that were able to clearly associate the electrical stimulus with their action, i.e. touching the prey, and thus were able to predict and control the stressor, did not show significant or sustained stress indicators, while animals that were unable to control the situation to avoid the shock, showed significant stress.
In 2004, a study was published based on the observation of a variety of breeds trained for protection work using shock collars, which found that while electronically trained dogs can excel as guard dogs, their behavior towards people and working conditions changed , often indicating increased uncertainty and reactivity.
Model rival training
Based on the principles of social learning, model-rival training uses a model, or a rival for attention, to demonstrate the desired behavior. The method was used by Irene Pepperberg to train Alex the African Gray Parrot to label a variety of objects. McKinley and Young conducted a pilot study on the applicability of a modified version of the model-rival method to the training of domestic dogs, noting that the dog’s origins as a member of large and complex social groups promote observational learning. The model rival training involved an interaction between the trainer, the dog, and a person acting as a model rival, that is, a model for desired behavior and a rival for the trainer’s attention. With the dog in mind, a dialogue about a particular toy began between the trainer and the model rival. The trainer praised or scolded the model rival, depending on whether the model rival had properly named the toy. Performance times to complete the task were found to be comparable for dogs trained with operant conditioning or the model rival method. In addition, the total training time required to complete the task was comparable for both methods
A Hungarian dog training group called Népszigeti Kutyaiskola uses a variant of model-rival training they describe as the Mirror method. The philosophy of the mirror method is that dogs instinctively learn by following the example of others in their social sphere. The core of the program is the involvement of the dog in all aspects of the owner’s life and positive reinforcement of copying behavior. Mirror method dog training is based on using a dog’s natural instincts and tendencies rather than working against them.
Relationship-based training
Derived from the theories of symbolic interactionism, relationship-based training uses the patterns of communication, interpretation, and adaptation between dogs and their trainers. Building on a positive relationship between them, the method aims to achieve results that benefit both the dog and the trainer, while improving and strengthening their relationship. The basics include: making sure the dog’s basic needs are met before a training session, figuring out what motivates the dog and using it to elicit behavior, interpreting the dog’s body language to help communicate between dog and dog. trainer, using positive reinforcement to encourage desired behavior, training incompatible behaviors to replace unwanted behaviors, and controlling the dog’s environment to limit the possibility of unwanted behaviors. A relationship-based approach to dog training does not rely on the use of particular training aids or treats, the relationship is always there, and the connection between dog and trainer is strong enough to achieve the training goals.
Training can take as many forms as there are trainers, but a detailed study of animal trainers has found common features of successful methods: a thoughtful interpretation of what the animal does prior to training, accurate timing and consistent communication.
Dog communication
Dogs have become closely associated with humans through domestication and have also become sensitive to human communicative cues. In general, they have a lot of exposure to human speech, especially while playing, and are believed to have a good ability to recognize human speech. Two studies examined the ability of a single dog believed to be exceptional at its understanding of language. Both studies have shown that at least some dogs have the potential to understand many simple commands based on just the sounds emitted by their owners. However, the studies suggested that visual cues from the owner may be important for understanding more complex spoken commands
Innate characteristics
When considering the natural behavior of specific dog breeds, it is possible to train them to perform specialized, very useful tasks. Labrador retrievers, for example, are the breed of choice for detecting explosives. This is due to a combination of factors, including their appetite, that allow them to stay focused on a task despite noise and other distractions. Most working dog breeds can be trained to find people with their sense of smell (as opposed to their sense of sight). Cocker Spaniels can be trained as part of a termite detection team. Their relatively small size allows them to fit in tight spaces and their light weight allows them to walk on ceilings that would be dangerous for anything heavier. While uncommon, termite detection dogs are much more reliable at detecting termites than people who rely on a basic tap and listen system. Due to their ability to learn cues by seeing and due to their energetic and athletic nature, German Shepherds can be trained for work in addition to search and rescue teams and human arrest teams
CONCLUSION:
Individual training is used in dogs that have an urgent or unique training problem such as anxiety, hyperactivity, aggression (and other related problems), separation anxiety, biting, excessive barking, insecurity, destructive behavior, walking difficulties, and inappropriate elimination. This type of training would normally be undertaken where the problem naturally occurs rather than in a class situation. Classroom training can be effective in stimulating socialization and peer group play. Classes are often offered at a more affordable rate and can address problem behaviors as well as teach new skills. Classes can range from puppy and beginner training to more advanced training and skills training such as performing tricks, preparing for dog sports, or therapy work.
At Fix Your Dog Anthony uses a secret dog training method originating from Italy!
We service all of Ontario including the Niagara region eg. St Catharines, Welland, Niagara on the Lake, Thorold, Ridgeway etc. We also serve Stoney Creek, Burlington, Mississauga Oakville Toronto and all of the GTA!
To learn more about our method please contact Anthony today!
One session with our method will do what months of any of the historic methods listed above could ever do! I guarantee it or I wont accept your money! You know I must be serious with an offer like that!