"It is my fervent hope that this will never occur to anyone else":
A Disability Justice perspective on COVID-19 and HIV/AIDS within the Missouri criminal legal system
A Disability Justice perspective on COVID-19 and HIV/AIDS within the Missouri criminal legal system
Content warnings for police brutality, mentions of death, discussion of unsafe living conditions, and images of a prison uprising.
As COVID-19 infections continue to disable Missourians and other across the nation with Long COVID, the phrase “mass disabling event” has begun to crop up in the newsline. For many of us in the queer community, this is not the first time we’ve lived through a mass disabling virus; it’s difficult not to think of HIV/AIDS, and how it was mishandled by the government.
Mass disabling events like these hit certain demographics the hardest: Black, Brown, and Indigenous people, the AAPI community, low-income and unhoused people, and the queer and trans communities.
This exhibit seeks to shed light on another, often-ignored demographic: people in incarceration. Through artifacts that show public policy as it deviates from lived experience, and how those most affected respond to these dire conditions, we will see a tale of two pandemics, unfolding 30 years apart, mirroring each other across time and space.
The artifacts displayed here discuss policies and protocols for HIV/AIDS and COVID-19 within the criminal legal system. It's important to understand what the official rules are, so you can then understand how these rules are often either baseless and cruel, or not implemented at all, to create poor conditions for those incarcerated.
Artifact description: A copy of the Internal Management Policy and Procedure for the Kansas Department of Corrections regarding Management of Inmates with AIDS and AIDS-Related Complex, approved in 1986.
Image description: embedded PDF
Accessibility Note: For screen readable transcript, click here.
Artifact description: A memorandum from Commissioner Dale Glass regarding COVID-19 precautionary protocol at the Saint Louis City Justice Center, initially issued in February of 2020.
Image description: embedded PDF
Accessibility Note: For screen readable transcript, click here.
Despite the prevention policies above, in the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic, prison populations had infection rates five to six times higher than in general populations in the community, while mortality rates were two to three times higher (Piquero), and HIV rates in the early 1990s were almost 9.5 times higher. Below you'll find the statistics regarding both pandemics, as well as two individual accounts of the legal systems failure to handle situations with safety in mind.
Artifact description: A Bureau of Justice report entitled HIV in Prisons: 1994.
Image description: embedded PDF
Accessibility Note: Text from PDF above is screen readable if you click on the "pop-out" button in the top right corner of the embedded PDF.
Artifact description: A letter from a Kansas City resident, Joseph Carlton, detailing his experiences as an HIV-positive person with police in Kansas City.
Image description: embedded PDF
Accessibility Note: Text from PDF above has transcript in the PDF comments, viewable if you click on the "pop out" button in the top right corner of the embedded PDF.
Artifact description: A summary of the report on COVID-19 in Missouri Prisons and Jails, compiled by the Missouri Appleseed Network.
Image description: embedded PDF
Accessibility note: Text from PDF above is screen readable if you click on the "pop-out" button in the top right corner of the embedded PDF.
Artifact Description: YouTube video recorded by ArchCity Defenders detailing the conditions of incarcerated people during the COVID-19 pandemic at the Saint Louis City Justice Center, and a report compiled by the Missouri Appleseed Network on COVID-19 in Missouri .
Image description: embedded video
Accessibility Note: Transcript available if you click the "pop-out" button in the top right corner of the video, click "more..." under the video description, and click "show transcript".
Here we see the consequences of the Missouri criminal legal systems’ action, with legal action and uprisings. Unfortunately, these actions have yielded little or no improvements.
Below is a copy of a Kansas City Board of Police Commissioners citizen complaint report filled out by Joseph Carlton, alongside a response from the Board and an ACLU intake form.
Image description: embedded PDF
Accessibility note: For a screen-reader-friendly transcript of the above PDF, view the comments on the PDF document directly by clicking the "pop-out" icon in thee top right of the embedded PDF.
Below is a picture taken of the uprising at Saint Louis Justice Center on Saturday, February 6th, 2021. Inside sources state that COVID-19 conditions played a large role in causing this event. A news article published in the Riverfront Times regarding the event can be found here
Image description: Image description: Photo of uprising at Saint Louis Justice Center on Saturday, February 6th, 2021. Inmates stand in front of broken windows holding signs that say "FREE 57", "FREE WightWight" and "PDI HotHEAD". They are dressed in dark yellow inmate uniforms and wearing masks made of white cloth, with the cloth also wrapped around their faces. There are burn marks on the face of the building where they're standing.
Accessibility note: Image description also available in alt text.
The conditions those in the Missouri criminal legal system face currently with COVID-19, and have faced both historically and presently with HIV/AIDS, are unconscionable. We must advocate for the medical needs of those within the system, the accessibility of basic disease prevention tools, and adequate care for those who become infected and/or disabled as a result of these conditions. Local organizations are already doing this work; ArchCity Defenders has recorded the testimonies of incarcerated people and others impacted by the conditions of jails and prisons during the pandemic and the Missouri Appleseed Network has created a document detailing possible policies and protocols that jails and prisons could implement to stop the spread of diseases, whether that be COVID-19 or any future outbreaks of highly transmissible viruses. A complete reform and overhaul of the criminal legal system is desperately needed in the U.S.; learning about the prison abolition movement and getting involved helps us move toward that goal of freedom for all. None of us are free until all of us are free.
ON DISABILITY JUSTICE
Articles:
Indigenous Lives and Disability Justice by Jen Deerinwater
10 Principles of Disability Justice
Books:
Care Work: Dreaming Disability Justice
All the Weight of Our Dreams: on Living Racialized Autism
Exile and Pride by Eli Clare
Websites:
ON PRISON ABOLITION AND TRANSFORMATIVE JUSTICE
Articles:
Prison Abolition and Grounded Justice by Allegra M. McLeod
So You’re Thinking About Becoming an Abolitionist by Mariame Kaba
Books:
Are Prisons Obsolete? by Angela Davis
Websites:
Berk, Richard A. The Social Impact of AIDS in the United States. Abt Books, 1988. Accessed 3 December 2023.
Brien, Peter M., and Allen J. Beck. “HIV in Prisons, 1994.” Bureau of Justice Statistics, Mar. 1996, bjs.ojp.gov/library/publications/hiv-prisons-1994. Accessed 3 December 2023.
“Caged During Covid: Story #7.” YouTube, uploaded by ArchCity Defenders, 13 May 2020, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2yF8O5pw1qA. Accessed 1 November 2023.
Carlton, Joseph. Citizen Complaint Form. Box 25, Case Files–Joseph Carlton, HIV discrimination, 1990-1991. K0398 American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) Western Missouri Records. State Historical Society of Missouri, University of Missouri-Saint Louis, Saint Louis, MO. Accessed 1 November 2023.
Carlton, Joseph. Letter to Richard Berkeley. Box 25, Case Files–Joseph Carlton, HIV discrimination, 1990-1991. K0398 American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) Western Missouri Records. State Historical Society of Missouri, University of Missouri-Saint Louis, Saint Louis, MO. Accessed 1 November 2023.
Cohen, Robert. St. Louis Post-Dispatch. https://www.stltoday.com/print/a-section/activists-say-uprising-at-city-jail-facility-was-a-protest-of-inhumane-conditions/article_12f71ce1-fc12-51d9-962f-d86781c342cc.html. 6 February 2021. Accessed 3 December 2023.
Glass, Dale. Precautionary Protocol Initiated Regarding Coronavirus 4-23-20. City of Saint Louis Justice Center, Corrections Division, 23 April 2020, https://www.stlouis-mo.gov/government/departments/public-safety/corrections/documents/upload/Precautionary-Protocol-Initiated-Regarding-Coronavirus-4-23-20.pdf. Accessed 3 December 2023.
Kansas Department of Corrections. AIDS testing in prisons, 1987. Box 52, Research. K0398 American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) Western Missouri Records. State Historical Society of Missouri, University of Missouri-Saint Louis, Saint Louis, MO. Accessed 1 November 2023.
Piquero, Alex R et al. “Staying Home, Staying Safe? A Short-Term Analysis of COVID-19 on Dallas Domestic Violence.” American journal of criminal justice : AJCJ vol. 45,4 (2020): 601-635. Accessed 3 December 2023.
Questions or comments? Please click here to fill out our feedback form!
Curated by Emerson Morris, MFA candidate at University of Missouri-Saint Louis
Header Image by Markus Spiske on Unsplash