In the context of scalar transport and mixing in fluid dynamics, a scalar refers to a quantity that has only magnitude and no direction, which can vary from point to point within a fluid. Common examples of scalar quantities in fluid dynamics include temperature, concentration of a chemical substance, or density. These scalars are termed passive when their values do not influence the flow field directly—though, in practice, variations in temperature and concentration can impact fluid properties like viscosity and density, subsequently affecting the flow. This simplification, however, is useful for modeling purposes. The study of passive scalar transport and mixing is vital across numerous scientific and engineering disciplines, including the pharmaceutical and food industries, oceanography, atmospheric sciences, and civil engineering. This understanding aids in addressing challenges related to pollutant dispersion, chemical mixing, and thermal management.
The passive scalar is typically governed by the advection-diffusion equation. A notable study by G.I. Taylor (1953) analyzed a solute advected by steady, pressure-driven flow in a circular pipe. He demonstrated that, at long times, the scalar distribution could be approximated by a one-dimensional diffusion equation with an enhanced constant effective diffusion coefficient, known as Taylor dispersion. This transformation from the original three-dimensional governing equation to the simplified one-dimensional equation reduces the number of independent variables from four to two. This exemplifies a fundamental mathematical technique: simplifying complex systems by eliminating "fast modes." My objective is to derive more precise reduced models of scalar dynamics, applicable in both deterministic and stochastic flow contexts.
The first case we considered is deterministic time-varying shear flows the result of random flow is discussed in the section of the scalar intermittency. We developed a theory on the effective diffusivity and skewness of the longitudinal distribution of a diffusing tracer advected a periodic time-varying shear flow by in a straight channel. Although applicable to any type of solute and fluid flow, we restrict the examples of our theory to the tracer advected by flows which are induced by a periodically oscillating wall in a Newtonian fluid between two infinite parallel plates as well as flow in an infinitely long duct. We identified optimal parameters for maximizing mixing, such as temperature, the frequency and phase of wall motion, tracer diffusivity, and fluid viscosity. These parameters not only enhance the mixing rate but also enable control over the concentration distribution by adjusting the phase of the wall motion, affecting the skewness sign. To experimentally validate our theory, we constructed a device featuring a computer-controlled robotic arm designed to generate the prescribed wall motion. This setup provides a practical and realizable experimental framework not only for studying time-varying random flows but also for exploring scalar intermittency, which concerns the statistics of scalars inherited from random flows, such as those found in turbulent environments.
Schematic showing the setup for the experiment and theory. I credit most of the experimental effort to Robert Hunt
Top view of the experiment. Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) technique is used to capture instantaneous velocity fields by tracking the movement of seeded particles within a fluid flow.
Top view of the concentration distribution
Reference
*Lingyun Ding, Robert Hunt, Richard M McLaughlin, and Hunter Woodie. Enhanced diffusivity and skewness of a diffusing tracer in the presence of an oscillating wall. Research in theMathematical Sciences, 8(3):1–29, 2021b. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40687-021-00257-4
Taylor G.I. 1953 Dispersion of soluble matter in solvent flowing slowly through a tube. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 219 (1137), 186–203.
Scalar intermittency in fluid dynamics describes the irregular and sporadic fluctuations in the concentration of a scalar quantity, such as temperature or chemical concentration, within turbulent flow. This phenomenon can be mathematically analyzed by examining the statistics of scalar increments over spatial or temporal scales, which typically reveal non-Gaussian, heavy-tailed distributions. Such distributions underscore the complex and nonlinear nature of turbulence and scalar mixing. Modeling turbulence as a stochastic process provides a framework to study how the randomness of the flow influences the statistics of the scalar field.
We analyze the behavior of a diffusing scalar advected by random flows involving white noise processes, Ornstein-Uhlenbeck processes, or renewing processes. While the random flow might suggest inherent randomness in the system, determinism can also emerge. To investigate this, we employ a new strategy focusing on the moments of the random scalar field, such as the mean and variance, which are key characteristics of this field. Under certain conditions, knowing all moments allows us to reconstruct the probability distribution of the scalar field. We begin by formulating the governing equations for these moments, known as moment closure equations. As these equations are deterministic, the standard perturbation method is applicable. By applying asymptotic expansion to the moment closure equations over long times, we can construct the probability distribution of the scalar field. Our analysis reveals that at the diffusion timescale, the governing equations approximate to an advection-diffusion equation with an averaged velocity field and a deterministic effective diffusivity, akin to a special form of the central limit theorem. Using this equation, we compute the probability density function of the random scalar field. Remarkably, our findings suggest that the system exhibits ergodic-like properties, where a single realization suffices to infer its statistics. This could significantly simplify experimental approaches to studying scalar intermittency and turbulent transport.
Normalized variable as a function of time for 5 independent flow realizations and 5 different Ornstein-Uhlenbeck processes damping parameters γ . Note the convergence of this quantity to the deterministic effective diffusivity, where the theoretical value is showed on the right of each row. Pictures in the right column are simply zoom-in of pictures in the left column at a larger time scale.
Reference
*Lingyun Ding and Richard M McLaughlin. Correlation function of a random scalar field evolving with a rapidly fluctuating gaussian process. Journal of Statistical Physics, 190(12):201, 2023a. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-023-03191-7
*Lingyun Ding and Richard M McLaughlin. Determinism and invariant measures for diffusing passive scalars advected by unsteady random shear flows. Physical Review Fluids, 7(7):074502, 2022a. doi: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.7.074502
*Lingyun Ding and Richard M McLaughlin. Ergodicity and invariant measures for a diffusing passive scalar advected by a random channel shear flow and the connection between the Kraichnan-Majda model and Taylor-Aris dispersion. Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, 432:133118, 2022b. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physd.2021.133118
*Roberto Camassa, Lingyun Ding, Zeliha Kilic, and Richard M McLaughlin. Persisting asymmetry in the probability distribution function for a random advection–diffusion equation in impermeable channels. Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, 425:132930, 2021a. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physd.2021.132930
Multispecies electrolytes are mixtures of different ions dissolved in a solvent, such as the mixture of NaCl and KCl solution. In an electrolyte solution, the electric current is carried by the dissolved ions. The electric field exerts significant body forces on the ions, affecting their fluxes, which is another key factor in mass transfer.
Even in the absence of an external electric field, differences in ion diffusivities induce an electric potential and generate additional fluxes for each species. This electro-diffusion process is governed by the advection-Nernst-Planck equation. This is work I aim to understand how fluid flow, electric potential and diffusion interact in multispecies electrolyte solutions. I derived the long-time asymptotic approximation of the governing equation under electroneutrality and zero current conditions and investigated how the diffusion-induced electric potential and shear flow enhance the effective diffusion coefficients of each species in channel domains. Notably, the asymptotic analysis generalizes Taylor dispersion, exhibits a scaling relation, and reveals phenomena such as upstream migration of species , spontaneous ion separation, and non-monotonic dependence of effective diffusivity on P\'eclet numbers. Additionally, the study suggests a method to infer concentration ratios and ion diffusivities from effective diffusivity measurements. Diffusion-induced electric potential is also important for simulating stratified fluid systems, controlling diffusiophoresis, modeling isotachophoresis and chromatography, and studying fluid instability. These applications will be explored in future research. This work is my first single author paper and is featured in Focus on Fluids, a section of the Journal of Fluid Mechanics (JFM) underscoring its potential significance.
Reference
Lingyun Ding. Shear dispersion of multispecies electrolyte solutions in the channel domain. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 970:A27, 2023. doi: https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2023.626
Numerical solutions of the advection-Nernst-Planck equation for ternary electrolyte with Pe = 2. The first ion species migrate opposes flow direction as a result of diffusion-induced electric potential.
Numerical solutions of the advection-Nernst-Planck equation for ternary electrolyte with Pe = 8. Flow is stronger in this case. The effect of flow becomes more prominent over the ion–electric interaction, resulting in all concentration profiles bending in the direction of the shear flow.
Flow deforms the scalar field into smaller filaments, which are subsequently smoothed by molecular diffusion . This process significantly enhances mixing compared to pure diffusion. However, identifying the flow configuration that maximizes mixing rates poses a challenge due to the highly nonlinear nature of the problem. To address that, we first have to choose a measurement to qualify the degree of mixing. Intuitively, the variance is a good measure of mixing quality. It measures fluctuations from the mean, and a mixed state is exactly one where the concentration is equal to the mean, i.e., it is uniform. However, when the diffusivity $\kappa$ is very small and the stirring process is relatively dominant, the variance is almost a constant. In this case, the variance is a less-than-ideal measure of mixing quality.
Hence, instead of variance, we adopted a multi-scale norm that is motivated by Sobolev norm $H^{-1}$ for a general domain with a no-flux boundary. Unlike the variance which treats all scales evenly, the mix norm downplays the role of small scales so that the norm isn't a constant in the absence of diffusion. Moreover, if the mix norm of a scalar field equals zero, then it is well mixed in the sense of the ergodic theory. We then derive an explicit expression for the optimal flow that maximizes the instantaneous decay rate of the mix norm under fixed energy and enstrophy constraints. Numerical simulations indicate that the mix norm decays exponentially or faster for various initial conditions and geometries and the rate is closely related to the smallest non-zero eigenvalue of the Laplace operator. These results generalize previous findings restricted for a periodic domain for its analytical and numerical simplicity. Additionally, we observe that periodic boundaries tend to induce a faster decay in mix norm compared to no-flux conditions under the fixed energy constraint, while the comparison is reversed for the fixed enstrophy constraint. In the special case of even initial distributions, two types of boundary conditions yield the same optimal flow and mix norm decay.
Reference
Sirui Zhu, Zhi Lin, Liang Li, and Lingyun Ding. Optimal stirring strategies for passive scalars in a domain with a general shape and no-flux boundary condition. Advances in Applied Mathematics and Mechanics, 2024. doi: https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.05684
Z. Lin, J.-L. Thiffeault, and C. R. Doering. Optimal stirring strategies for passive scalar mixing. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 675:465–476, 2011.
J.-L. Thiffeault. Using multiscale norms to quantify mixing and transport. Nonlinearity, 25(2):R1–R44, January 2012.
Evolution of the scalar field under an optimal stirring strategy with a fixed enstrophy constraint. The scalar field achieves rapid mixing in the ergodic sense, converging weakly to a uniform state. Below are the simulation for diffrerent domains.
Particle-laden flows involve solid particles suspended in a fluid medium, a crucial phenomenon in both natural and industrial settings. These multiphase flows are central to various applications, from sediment transport in environmental science to process optimization in chemical manufacturing. The complex interactions between particles and fluid significantly influence flow properties and behavior, making their study essential for improving systems reliant on effective particle transport.
Diffusion-driven flow is an intriguing phenomenon resulting from molecular diffusion. In density-stratified fluids, such as oceans, whenever the impermeable solid boundary is non-parallel to the gravitational field, a flow emerges driven by the buoyancy force, ensuring that the density field satisfies the no-flux boundary condition. Diffusion-driven flow has significant implications in various fields. In oceanography, the salinity-induced density stratification along the continental shelf promotes upwelling flow, crucial for the vertical exchange of oceanic properties. Similarly, fluids in narrow fissures can stratify due to non-uniform scalar distributions or vertical temperature gradients, such as Earth's geothermal gradient, causing significant solute dispersion over geological timescales. Additionally, when a wedge-shaped object is immersed in a stratified fluid, the resulting flow can propel the object forward, with such phenomena further explored in multiple studies. This flow mechanism also plays a role in particle attraction and self-assembly in stratified fluids and can measure molecular diffusivity. Lastly, it is involved in layer formation in double-diffusive systems due to insulating sloping boundaries.
We explore dispersion induced by diffusion-driven flow, initially examining the mixing of passive scalars advected by unsteady flows in parallel-plate channels with linear density stratification. We provide series representations for velocity and density fields, highlighting distinct oscillatory behaviors in bounded and semi-infinite domains. Additionally, we analyze passive tracer mixing and present an explicit expression for the time-dependent effective diffusion coefficient, which oscillates with an amplitude exceeding its steady-state value. Notably, the unsteady flow can temporarily reduce the effective diffusion coefficient below pure molecular diffusion, though it is significantly enhanced over longer periods. This research has been highlighted as an "Editors' Suggestion" in Physical Review Fluids.
Further, I investigate diffusion-driven flow in nonlinear density-stratified fluids, demonstrating that classical power series expansions fail to provide accurate approximations across a broad parameter range. I propose a novel asymptotic expansion method inspired by center manifold theory, which uses derivatives of the cross-sectional averaged density field for expanding velocity, density, and pressure fields. This method also leads to an evolution equation for the averaged density field, which resembles the traditional diffusion equation but with a diffusion coefficient replaced by a positive-definite function dependent on the derivative of the solution. This approach offers a robust framework for modeling slow manifold phenomena, such as convection in curved pipes and thin film fluids.
The dispersion enhanced by diffusion-driven flow. We glue three capillary pipes to a base. The inclination angles of the pipes from left to right are 90 , 45 , and 30. In the beginning, three capillary pipes are filled with the same amount of FeCl3 and fresh deionized water at the bottom and the top, respectively. We glue the end of pipes to prevent evaporation. To reduce the effect of thermal fluctuation, we put the pipes and base into a tank filled full of deionized water. The left panel is a snapshot at the beginning. The right panel is the photo after two days. Due to the density stratification, the diffusion-driven flow exists in the titled pipes. As a result, the tracer has the biggest longitudinal dispersion in the pipe with inclination angle 30 and has the smallest longitudinal dispersion in the vertically mounted pipe.
Velocity field of diffusion-driven flow in a rectangular chamber inclined at 45 degrees. The left panel shows the initial density profile as a step function, while the right panel depicts it as a staircase-like function.
Reference
Lingyun Ding. Diffusion-driven flows in a non-linear stratified fluid layer. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 2024. doi: https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2024.870 arxiv https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2311.17386
*Lingyun Ding and Richard M. McLaughlin. Dispersion induced by unsteady diffusion-driven flow in a parallel-plate channel. Phys. Rev. Fluids, 8:084501, Aug 2023b. doi:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.8.084501
Sedimentation of particles in stratied uids ubiquitously occurs in natural environments and plays a vital role in marine snow, oil spill properties and distributions of dense microplastics in the oceans, and most recently in marine particulate aggregation.
Abaid et al. (2004) studied the experimental sedimentation of a sphere in stratified salt water, documenting for the first time an intriguing bounce phenomenon where a dense sphere momentarily stops, rises, and then continues falling. This temporary levitation prolongs the settling time, potentially leading to the accumulation of particulate matter near strong density transition layers in the environment, such as haloclines or thermoclines. For more details, I recommend the video made by Richard Mclaughlin and also other materials in his website.
Our objective is to identify the critical density of the sphere below which the levitation phenomenon occurs. Experimental evidence indicates that the critical density exhibits a linear dependence on fluid densities. As the thickness of the density transition layer increases, the critical density tends to converge towards that of the lower fluid layer. We propose a potential energy-based theory to estimate critical density, which accurately matches experimental observations. Future work includes investigating the motion of porous particles, air bubbles, and oil droplets in the stratified fluid to gain insights into marine snow and particle aggregation and to improve methods for cleaning oil pollution.
Particle settling in a two-layer stratified fluid, temporarily levitating as it passes through the interface of the stratification.
In the plot, ρb represents the particle density, while ρ1 and ρ2 are the densities of the top and bottom fluids, respectively. Particles can levitate or bounce when the densities fall within the blue region.
Reference
Abaid, N., Adalsteinsson, D., Agyapong, A., McLaughlin, R.M., 2004. An internal splash: Levitation of falling spheres in stratied uids. Physics of Fluids 16, 1567 1580.
*Roberto Camassa, Lingyun Ding, Richard M McLaughlin, Robert Overman, Richard Parker, and Ashwin Vaidya. Critical density triplets for the arrestment of a sphere falling in a sharply stratified fluid. Recent Advances in Mechanics and Fluid-Structure Interaction with Applications: The Bong Jae Chung Memorial Volume, page 69, 2022. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-14324-3
Particle-laden flows involve solid particles suspended in a fluid medium, a crucial phenomenon in both natural and industrial settings. These multiphase flows are central to various applications, from sediment transport in environmental science to process optimization in chemical manufacturing. The complex interactions between particles and fluid significantly influence flow properties and behavior, making their study essential for improving systems reliant on effective particle transport.
The particle-laden flow project is one of the research focuses within Professor Andrea Bertozzi's team, where I collaborate closely with my peer, Sarah Cassie Burnett. I credit most of the experimental effort to Sarah Cassie Burnett and am grateful for the support provided by Professor Andrea Bertozzi.
Many research works have demonstrated that, even at relatively modest volume fractions of particles, the presence of these particles significantly influences the flow dynamics, leading to distinct behaviors based on the volume fraction. Consequently, it is imperative to quantitatively model the interaction between the fluid and particles. Such models fall into two broad categories: discrete and continuum. Discrete models, which track individual particles, are relatively accurate but computationally intensive. On the other hand, continuum models treat fluid and particles as separate continuous phases, each governed by coupled equations. Our study consists of significant particle concentrations, making continuum models the preferred approach.
Two widely used continuum models for analyzing particle suspensions are the diffusive-flux model and the suspension balance model. The diffusive flux model assumes that the particles migrate via a diffusive flux induced by gradients in both the particle concentration and the effective suspension viscosity. The suspension balance model introduces a non-Newtonian bulk stress with shear-induced normal stresses, the gradients of which cause particle migration. Both models have appeared in the literature of particle-laden flow with virtually no comparison between the two models. For particle-laden viscous flow on an incline, in a thin-film geometry, one can use lubrication theory to derive a compact dynamic model in the form of a system of coupled conservation laws. We can then directly compare the two theories side by side by looking at similarities and differences in the flux functions for the conservation laws, and in exact and numerical simulations of the equations. We compare the flux profiles over a range of parameters, showing fairly good agreement between the models, with the biggest difference involving the behavior at the free surface. We also consider less dense suspensions at lower inclination angles where the dynamics involve two shock waves that can be clearly measured in experiments. In this context the solutions differ by no more than about 10%, suggesting that either model could be used for this configuration.
In the Research experience for undergraduate student program (REU) 2023 at UCLA, Sarah Burnett and I mentored four undergraduate students, Jonathan Woo, Wing Pok Lee, Luke Triplett, Yifan Gu on this project. After REU, they continued on the project and presented their results at the American Physical Society Annual Meeting Division of Fluid Dynamics. With the support from professor Andrea Bertozzi, we finally finished a paper on this topic, which is titled “Acomparative study of dynamic models for gravity-driven particle-laden flows” and is published on Applied Mathematics Letter.
A schematic of a settled particle-laden suspension on an inclined
Slurry flow along an inclined plane, front start developing fingering structure.
Reference
Wing Pok Lee, Jonathan D. Woo, Luke F. Triplett, Yifan Gu, Sarah Burnett, Lingyun Ding, and Andrea Bertozzi. A comparative study of dynamic models for gravity-driven particle-laden flows. Applied Mathematics Letters, 2024 in press, https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.23561
David Leighton and Andreas Acrivos. The shear-induced migration of particles in concentrated suspensions. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 181:415–439, 1987.
Ronald J. Phillips, Robert C. Armstrong, Robert A. Brown, Alan L. Graham, and James R. Abbott. A constitutive equation for concentrated suspensions that accounts for shear-induced particle migration. Physics of Fluids A: Fluid Dynamics, 4(1):30–40, 01 1992.
Prabhu R. Nott and John F. Brady. Pressure-driven flow of suspensions: simulation and theory. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 275:157–199, 1994.
Prabhu R Nott, Elisabeth Guazzelli, and Olivier Pouliquen. The suspension balance model revisited. Physics of Fluids, 23(4), 2011.
A spiral separator, also known as a spiral concentrator or gravity separator, efficiently separates particles in wet conditions based on their specific gravity. This device features a helical trough spiraled around an upright column. Introduced at the top, the slurry—comprising mixed particles and liquid—descends through the spiral. Here, particle density causes them to aggregate towards the inner wall. Interactions between particles and fluid dynamics facilitate their concentration at different radial positions, leading to a banded separation at the spiral's outlet. Adjustable splitters further segregate the sorted materials into distinct streams. This paper theoretically analyzes slurries with two particle densities, predicting their distribution profile at the exit where they separate into different streams.
Wet spiral concentrators are prevalent in industries like coal and mining, particularly for isolating heavy minerals such as gold, tin, and tungsten. They are also favored over dry methods for hazardous materials like asbestos, preventing airborne dispersion by mixing minerals with liquids. Similarly, in the food industry, this method separates denser starch particles from gluten in flour production. Additionally, centrifugal devices used in bioengineering employ density-based separation to isolate mixture components.
Previous studies have investigated steady-state solutions for mixtures of liquids and a single particle species in thin-film flows. However, these models are constrained to single-species systems and cannot describe the dynamics of multi-species separation. In contrast, our analysis extends to mixtures containing two particle species of differing densities, revealing that they undergo radial separation—an essential mechanism for practical applications in separating particles of varying densities. This work models gravity-driven bidensity slurries on an inclined spiral by incorporating particle interactions, using empirically derived formulas for particle fluxes from previous bidensity studies on inclined planes. Specifically, we study a thin-film bidensity slurry flowing down a rectangular channel helically wound around a vertical axis. Through a thin-film approximation, we derive equilibrium profiles for the concentration of each particle species and the fluid depth. Additionally, we analyze the influence of key design parameters, such as spiral radius and channel width, on particle concentration profiles. Our findings provide valuable insights into optimizing spiral separator designs for enhanced applicability and adaptability.
Reference
Lingyun Ding, Sarah Burnett, and Andrea Bertozzi. Equilibrium theory of bidensity particle-laden suspensions in thin-film flow down a spiral separator, doi: https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.23568
S. Lee, Y.Stokes, and A.L.Bertozzi, Behavior of a particle-laden flow in a spiral channel, Physics of Fluids26(2014).
D.Arnold, Y.Stokes, and J.Green, Particle-laden thin-film flow in helical channels with arbitrary shallow cross-sectional shape, Physics of Fluids 31 (2019).
The slurry (or pulp), containing a mixture of particles and liquid, is introduced at the top of the spiral at a predetermined rate. As the slurry descends, liquid, heavy (blue) and light (red) particles seperate from each others.
The stable (a) and unstable (b) equilibrium configuration. Heavy particles are shown in dark blue and lighter particles are red. The rows increase in time from top to bottom, demonstrating the behavior of different starting configurations when perturbed by the secondary flow.
Turbulence in fluids can be broadly categorized into two regimes based on the strength of nonlinear interactions: the well-known strong 'eddy' turbulence and the equally significant but less familiar weak 'wave' turbulence. Eddy turbulence, characterized by large-scale vortex interactions, follows the classic Kolmogorov cascade model. In contrast, wave turbulence involves small-amplitude waves driven by weak nonlinear interactions that redistribute energy across various scales, such as surface waves on the ocean excited by winds. This type of turbulence is not only prevalent in oceanic and atmospheric dynamics but also in diverse systems like magnetohydrodynamic waves in conducting fluids, internal gravity waves in stably stratified fluids, and inertial waves in rotating fluids. Wave turbulence also extends beyond fluid dynamics, influencing fields such as astrophysics, optics, and even cosmology, showcasing its broad relevance and application.
Wave turbulence in geophysical flows} play an important role in energy exchanges across different scales. While vortical flows typically transfer energy upscale, wave energy usually transfers downscale, driving small-scale mixing. However, the upscale transfer of wave energy remains underexplored. I study the inverse wave cascade in the one-dimensional rotating shallow water equations. Our analysis reveals that waves injected at small scales transfer upscale predominantly through resonant quartic interactions between wave modes. This non-local energy transfer spans scales and occurs in intermittent bursts, leading to a shallower wave spectrum and higher amplitude wave fields in physical space. The statistics of the wave field were seen to depart from Gaussian at larger scales, while smaller scales exhibited Gaussian behavior. This show departure from typical assumptions used in wave turbulence theory, where the wave phases for example are assumed to be random and uncorrelated with Gaussian dynamics. The work is also featured in the Focus on Fluids section of JFM, underscores its potential significance in the field.
Reference
Jim Thomas and Lingyun Ding. Upscale transfer of waves in one-dimensional rotating shallow water. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 961:A2, 2023. doi: https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2023.114
Gregory Falkovich. Inverse cascade and wave condensate in mesoscale atmospheric turbulence, Physical review letters, 1992 doi: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.69.3173
Velocity spectrum in shallow water equation with forcing at large wave numbers. Inverse wave cascade is observed.