How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
My top pick is the Hamilton Beach Air Fryer Toaster, because it packs 1800 watts, a genuine 10-way cooking menu and a full accessory kit into one of the smallest footprints here — which matters a lot when counter space is the real constraint.
• Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster — best for feeding a family; pick this if you need a 4-lb chicken or a 9" x 13" pan to fit, and you want a top-mounted fan with four heaters aimed down at the food.
• Allstare 304 — best for keeping a Cuisinart oven running; pick this if your crumb tray has rusted, warped or gone missing and you own a TOA-65, TOA-65W or CTOA-130PC-series model.
• Kalorik 22 — best for preset-driven everyday cooking; pick this if you'd rather tap a picture of wings than set a temperature, and you want dishwasher-safe accessories.
This is the one I'd hand to most people. The 1800-watt element is the headline, and the practical payoff is that the oven circulates hot air hard enough to cook a whole meal in under 20 minutes by the brand's own description. It's a combo machine rather than an air fryer with a toasting mode bolted on: air fry, bake, broil, toast, dehydrate and more, ten functions total, all driven from an LED capacitive-touch panel. Four of those are dedicated air fry presets, which is the part that actually gets used — fries, wings, chicken, vegetables, with little to no oil.
The size is where this earns its place. At roughly 15.4" deep by 15.1" wide by 12.7" high, it's compact for what it holds: a 12-inch pizza, up to 3 lbs of wings, or six slices of toast. It has two rack positions, and the included mesh air fry basket sits on the upper rack with the bake pan or broil rack underneath to catch drippings. That stacked arrangement is genuinely useful — you get crisp results up top and no greasy mess below. The bake pan, broil rack and mesh basket all come in the box, so there's nothing extra to hunt down.
Two smaller details I like: the panel remembers your last cooking adjustments, so you're not re-entering your usual temperature every single time, and there's a Stay On setting for longer dehydrating runs. The stainless steel body with a tempered glass dropdown door is easy to wipe down.
The trade-off is capacity ceiling. A 4-lb chicken is not happening here, and a big 9" x 13" casserole won't fit either. This is a machine for one to three people, or for side dishes and quick meals alongside a main oven. If you regularly cook for a crowd, size up. If your counter is tight and you mostly air fry, toast and reheat, I think this is the best-balanced pick of the four.
Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster
The capacity is the reason to buy it. It fits a 4-lb whole chicken, 3 lbs of wings, six slices of toast, or a 9" x 13" pan for lasagna, brownies and casseroles. The interior measures 0.9 cubic feet, and the unit is listed as extra large at 19.25" deep, 23" wide and 16" high. That's a serious chunk of counter — measure before you commit, because this is not a tuck-it-in-the-corner appliance.
Controls are touchscreen with an integrated cooking guide, temperature moves in 25-degree increments, and it's programmable. One spec worth flagging honestly: the product information lists a maximum temperature setting of 400°F, while the feature copy mentions customizing up to 450°F. If you rely on very high-heat roasting, check the manual for your specific unit. Accessories are generous — air fry basket, a 9.9" x 14.4" baking pan that doubles as a drip tray, wire rack and a removable crumb tray. The limited 3-year warranty is the longest in this group.
The trade-offs are footprint and the temperature ambiguity above. In my opinion, this is the pick for anyone whose air fryer toaster oven will be the primary oven — the 9" x 13" pan compatibility is what separates it from everything else here.
This one isn't an oven, and I want to be clear about that up front. The Allstare 304 is a replacement crumb tray — the slide-out pan that sits at the bottom of a Cuisinart air fryer toaster oven and catches crumbs, oil and drippings. If you already own one of those ovens, it's the kind of part you don't think about until yours rusts, warps or disappears into a dishwasher somewhere.
It's made from food-grade 304 stainless steel, which is the right material call: it handles high heat without deforming and resists rust far better than the cheaper metals generic trays tend to use. It measures 15.7" long by 12" wide by 1" high, and it's a single pack. It replaces OEM part number TOA-65CT and fits TOA-65, TOA-65W, CTOA-130PC1, CTOA-130PC2 and CTOA-130PC3 models specifically — not Cuisinart ovens generally. The brand's own note is worth repeating: don't order by appearance, check the model number and measure your original tray, because these pans look alike across models.
The main trade-off is obviously scope — this doesn't cook anything, and if you own a different Cuisinart model or another brand entirely, it won't fit. Buy it as a maintenance item, not as an upgrade.
Kalorik 22
The Kalorik 22 is the most approachable machine of the group. It's a 22-quart toaster oven with air frying built in, controlled by a large touchscreen LED display paired with a physical control dial — a combination I appreciate, because tapping a screen for temperature and then spinning a dial for time is faster than doing both on glass. Temperature and time are both adjustable, up to 450°F.
The ten smart presets are the selling point: Pizza, Toast, Bake, Fries, Vegetables, Wings, Air Fry, Oven, Broil and Reheat. That Reheat setting is quietly one of the most useful things on any countertop oven — leftovers come back crisp instead of steamed. The air fry function uses a turbo fan to produce crispy results without added oil.
Capacity lands between the other two ovens: a 12-inch pizza or up to six slices of bread. It measures 16.5" deep, 14.7" wide and 10.65" high, and weighs 12.8 lbs, so it's lighter and a bit narrower than the Hamilton Beach despite the larger stated quart figure — different manufacturers measure interior volume differently, so trust the physical dimensions. The stainless steel body with a dropdown door looks tidy on a counter.
Cleanup is where it pulls ahead: the included baking tray, air rack and air frying basket are all dishwasher-safe, and there's a slide-out crumb tray for the worst of the mess. It ships with the oven, air frying basket, air rack, baking pan and crumb tray.
The trade-off is that it's preset-led rather than precision-led. If you like dialing in exact temperatures for dehydrating or proofing, the function list here is narrower than the Hamilton Beach's ten ways to cook. But for everyday wings, fries, toast and reheating, I'd recommend it to anyone who wants to press one button and walk away.
I compared published specifications and feature sets — wattage, capacity, cooking functions, control type, included accessories and physical dimensions — and weighed them against how people actually use a countertop oven. The ranking is our independent editorial opinion, based on those specs and real-world use cases, not on marketing claims. No brand paid for placement, and no manufacturer saw this guide before it published.
An oven-style unit like these uses a fan and heating elements inside a box, so you can cook on racks or in pans and fit items a basket can't hold — a 12-inch pizza, a whole chicken, a 9" x 13" casserole. A basket air fryer has a smaller, deeper chamber that tends to crisp faster in small batches.
Plan for the full footprint plus clearance. The Hamilton Beach is about 15.1" wide, the Kalorik about 14.7", and the Cuisinart about 23" — that last one needs real room and space behind it for the door and vents.
Yes, metal bakeware and foil are standard for oven-style air fryers. Just keep them off the heating elements and don't block the airflow path the fan depends on, or you'll lose the crisping effect.
Only if yours is damaged, rusted or lost. If you own a Cuisinart TOA-65, TOA-65W or CTOA-130PC-series oven, the Allstare 304 is a direct-fit replacement — verify your model number and measure the original tray first.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer oven digital, toaster oven air fryer, digital air fryer oven