We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-02 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a proven, warranty-backed refresh for a worn Logitech headset, choose defean Earpads; if you need replacement cushions for a Plantronics or Poly Voyager/BLACKWIRE model, choose HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. These two look similar on the shelf — black, protein-leather, foam-filled cushions — but they are built for completely different headsets, and picking the wrong one is a waste of your time.
• defean Earpads — biggest strength: A 12-month worry-free warranty plus free lifetime technical support, which is unusually generous for an aftermarket ear pad.
• defean Earpads — biggest trade-off: It only fits Logitech models (H390, H600, H609 and the related family), so it is useless if you own a Plantronics or Poly headset.
• HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads — biggest strength: Broad cross-compatibility inside the Plantronics/Poly ecosystem, covering Voyager Focus UC, Focus 2 UC, BLACKWIRE 5210/5220/7225 and more.
• HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads — biggest trade-off: The listing carries a 1-year manufacturer warranty rather than lifetime support, and you must confirm your exact model before buying.
• Who each pick is for: Logitech H-series and wireless headset owners → defean. Plantronics/Poly Voyager and BLACKWIRE owners → HAOMUK.
defean makes this pad specifically for the Logitech H390, H600 and H609 wireless headsets, with the model family called out again in the manufacturer part number. That narrow focus is the point: it means the cushion is shaped for those cups rather than being a generic oval that "sort of" fits. If you have been living with a flattened, flaking H390 pad on an otherwise perfectly good headset, this is the direct fix.
The material is black protein leather over noise-isolation foam. Protein leather is the same class of material most office headsets ship with — it feels soft against the ear, wipes clean easily, and gives you a bit of passive isolation from surrounding chatter. For a headset that lives on a desk in an open office or gets used for long calls, that combination is exactly what you want. defean also states the pads go through strict quality inspection, and backs them with a 12-month worry-free warranty and free lifetime technical support, plus a straightforward replacement-or-refund path if something is wrong.
One honest caveat: defean is explicit that this is an aftermarket product and that it has no affiliation with the headphone company. There is nothing sneaky about it — it just means you are buying a third-party part, not an OEM one. I would recommend defean for anyone whose Logitech H390, H600 or H609 simply needs new cushions, and I would steer you away if your headset is a Plantronics or Poly model, because this pad was never designed for those cups.
HAOMUK's pad lives on the other side of the fence. It is built for the Plantronics and Poly line: Voyager Focus UC, Voyager Focus UC B825 (binaural), Voyager Focus 2 UC USB-A, and the BLACKWIRE 5220, 5210 and 7225 headsets. That is a genuinely wide net within one brand family, and it covers a lot of the headsets you see in call centers, home offices and hybrid setups.
The design brief here is "match the original." HAOMUK says the cushions are the same size as the originals, made from high-quality protein leather, and — importantly — added thickness compared to a worn-out pad. Anyone who has used a Voyager Focus for a couple of years knows the failure mode: the foam collapses, the leather cracks, and the headset suddenly feels loose and uncomfortable. A fresh, slightly thicker cushion restores that snug fit and gives the headset a new look without replacing the whole thing.
Installation is tool-free and described in a few simple steps: remove the old ear cups, align the card position on the headphone, press firmly, and tidy up the position. No glue, no prying with a screwdriver. HAOMUK also notes it offers other brands and models of replacement pads, and it repeatedly asks you to confirm your headphone model before purchase — which is good advice, because the compatibility list is specific. Warranty coverage is listed as 1 year manufacturer.
• Best for Logitech H390/H600/H609 owners → defean Earpads. That is its entire compatibility list, so it is the safe, purpose-built choice.
• Best for Plantronics/Poly owners → HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. Voyager Focus UC, Focus 2 UC and BLACKWIRE 5210/5220/7225 are all covered.
• Best for long-term peace of mind → defean Earpads. A 12-month warranty plus free lifetime technical support is a stronger safety net.
• Best for restoring a loose, collapsed headset → HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. The added thickness is the whole reason to swap pads on a worn Voyager.
• Best for tool-free installation → HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. The align-and-press method is spelled out clearly.
• Best for a simple, no-guesswork reorder → defean Earpads. One brand family, one part number, done.
• Best material match to the original → a tie. Both use protein leather over foam, so neither one is a downgrade in feel.
• Best if you are unsure of your model → neither, yet. Check the model printed on your headband first; these two do not overlap.
In my opinion, the deciding factor here is not quality — both pads use protein leather and foam, and both are designed to match the originals — it is compatibility. If you own a Logitech H390, H600 or H609, I would buy the defean Earpads, mainly because the 12-month warranty and free lifetime technical support make it the lower-risk purchase for a part that wears out. If you own a Plantronics Voyager Focus UC, Voyager Focus 2 UC or a BLACKWIRE 5210/5220/7225, the defean pad will not fit at all, and HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads is the one I would pick. Match the model first, then buy.
No. defean lists compatibility only for the Logitech H390, H600 and H609 wireless headsets. For a Voyager Focus UC or BLACKWIRE model, you need the HAOMUK pads instead.
HAOMUK describes them as the same size as the originals with added thickness, which is what helps a compressed, worn headset feel snug again. They are made from protein leather, matching the original material.
defean states a 12-month worry-free warranty plus free lifetime technical support. HAOMUK lists a 1-year manufacturer warranty. On paper, defean offers the longer-term support commitment.
HAOMUK says its pads install in a few simple steps without any tools — remove the old cups, align the card position, press firmly. defean does not specify a tool requirement, so treat it as a standard push-on replacement.
If price matters to you, check the current price on Amazon for whichever model matches your headset before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Pulsat Earmold Silicone Fin vs Sunffice Open Ear Headphone, FiiO /Snowsky Retro Nano vs Anker Soundcore Liberty 5, BYDETATA AI Language Translation vs UYRUREL Case, eleror Invisible Mini vs HIFI WALKER Swimming Headphones