How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a direct-fit replacement you can order with confidence for a known Logitech headset, choose defean Earpads; if you need a generic cushioned upgrade in a brown finish with a simple install and don't mind confirming fit yourself, choose Saluaqui Replacement Headset Ear.
• defean Earpads — biggest strength: it names the exact headsets it fits (Logitech H390 / H391 / H600 / H609 / H760), so you know before you buy whether it applies to you.
• defean Earpads — biggest trade-off: it's an aftermarket part, and the brand states plainly that it carries no Logitech trademarks and has no affiliation with Logitech, so it's not an OEM accessory.
• Saluaqui Replacement Headset Ear — biggest strength: a comfort-and-isolation build — soft protein leather over plush, high-density foam with reinforced stitching — plus a tool-free install that takes seconds.
• Saluaqui Replacement Headset Ear — biggest trade-off: the compatibility wording stays generic ("for headphones," "for headset"), and it ships as a pair of brown earmuffs rather than the usual black, so it's a cosmetic commitment.
• Who each pick is for: defean is for the owner of a specific Logitech wired or wireless headset who wants the least guesswork; Saluaqui is for someone replacing worn cushions on a headset they already know the size of, and who wants a softer, more isolating feel in brown.
The defean Earpads exist to solve one narrow, annoying problem: the foam and covering on a Logitech headset flattens, cracks or peels long before the electronics quit. Instead of replacing the whole headset, you swap the cushions. What makes this listing easy to buy is the specificity — it's built for the Logitech H390, H391, H600, H609 and H760, which covers both wired desk headsets and the wireless H600/H609 family. In my opinion, that named-model list is the single most useful thing on the page, because fit is the one thing you can't fix after the fact.
The construction is straightforward: black protein leather over noise-isolation foam. Protein leather is the usual choice for this kind of pad because it wipes clean easily, resists the flaking you get from cheap vinyl, and gives you a bit of passive sealing around the ear. That sealing is what does the real work — it's not active noise cancellation, it's simply foam and a closed surface reducing how much outside sound reaches your ear, and how much of your audio leaks out. If you share an office or take calls in a noisy room, that matters more than any spec sheet number.
One more practical note: because the fit is model-specific, this is a "measure twice" purchase. Confirm your headset says H390, H391, H600, H609 or H760 on the headband, and you're done deliberating.
Saluaqui Replacement Headset Ear: Who It's For
Saluaqui takes the opposite approach. Rather than pinning itself to a handful of models, it sells a general-purpose replacement cushion: protein leather and foam, sold as a pair, in brown. The pitch is comfort and quiet. The padding is described as high-density and soft, with plush foam that adapts to the shape of your ear, which is the kind of language that points at long listening sessions — podcasts, calls, all-day desk work — where thin, collapsed pads start to ache.
The isolation angle is spelled out too: the cushions are meant to seal around the ear so the headset's original sound stays intact while outside noise is pushed back. Again, that's passive isolation from foam and a closed leather surface, not electronics. Realistically, a well-sealed pad can noticeably quiet a busy office or a café, and it can also tighten up bass response simply by improving the seal — but it won't erase a droning air conditioner the way active cancellation would. I'd treat the "tranquil world" phrasing as marketing and the underlying mechanic as sound.
Where Saluaqui earns real credit is durability intent: reinforced stitching, upgraded materials, and a flexible, elastic structure meant to survive being stretched on and off repeatedly. That's the failure point on cheap pads — the seam splits or the lip tears — so reinforced stitching is the right thing to brag about. Installation is described as tool-free: pull the worn pads, press the new ones on, seconds per side, and the fit is designed not to slip off. The brand also covers it with a 90-day manufacturer warranty.
Who should buy it? Someone replacing tired cushions on a headset they already own and whose pad size they're confident about, especially if they want a softer, more isolating feel and don't mind brown. Who should skip it? Anyone who wants a guaranteed model-specific match — because the compatibility wording here is deliberately broad and doesn't name a headset — and anyone who needs black pads. In my opinion, if you're not sure about sizing, that's a genuine risk with this one.
• Best for guaranteed fit → defean Earpads. It names Logitech H390, H391, H600, H609 and H760 outright.
• Best for a specific known headset model → defean Earpads. If your headband says one of those models, there's nothing left to verify.
• Best for soft, high-density padding → Saluaqui Replacement Headset Ear. Its whole pitch is plush foam that adapts to your ear.
• Best for reinforced, longer-wearing stitching → Saluaqui Replacement Headset Ear. Reinforced seams and an elastic structure are its stated durability story.
• Best for color options → neither, really. defean is black only; Saluaqui is brown only. Pick the one that matches your headset.
• Best for warranty length → defean Earpads. 12 months plus lifetime technical support, versus Saluaqui's 90-day manufacturer warranty.
• Best for a quick, tool-free swap → Saluaqui Replacement Headset Ear. It's described as a seconds-long, no-hassle install.
• Best if you want zero ambiguity before ordering → defean Earpads. The generic compatibility on the Saluaqui listing is the trade-off you accept for its broader, softer design.
I'd buy the defean Earpads. Not because Saluaqui is a bad pad — the reinforced stitching, high-density foam and tool-free install are all genuinely appealing — but because fit is the one thing you cannot fix later, and defean tells you exactly which headsets it's for while Saluaqui doesn't. Add the longer 12-month warranty and lifetime support, and for a small wear item that's the combination I'd want. If you already know your pad size, want a softer, more isolating cushion, prefer brown, and you're comfortable confirming compatibility yourself, Saluaqui is a perfectly reasonable call. In my opinion, most Logitech owners in that H390-to-H760 range should take the sure thing.
FAQ
Both rely on passive isolation: foam plus a closed protein-leather surface seals around your ear. That reduces outside sound and leakage, but it's not active noise cancellation, so expect a quieter, better-sealed feel rather than silence.
They're different bets. defean gives you a named-model fit, black pads, a 12-month warranty and lifetime technical support; Saluaqui gives you a softer, reinforced, tool-free pad in brown with a 90-day warranty. Check the current price on Amazon for both and weigh fit against comfort.
The listing describes them generically for headphones and headsets without naming a model, so measure your existing pad size and compare before buying. If you can't confirm the size or you need black, defean's model-specific listing is the safer route.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Kamon 5 vs Generic Earbuds, UGREEN Headphone Adapter vs ASKUBSKU Open Ear Headphone, Cyber Acoustics AC-4000 vs Btootos Earbuds, Ttbesmi Cute Kids True vs AT&T Comfort-Fit TWS