We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a dedicated replacement crisper plate that turns a Gourmia GAF824 8QT basket into a proper two-level cooking surface, choose CyHiThai 8QT; if you need flexible, reusable liners that protect any air fryer basket from grease and stuck-on food, choose Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer.
• CyHiThai 8QT — biggest strength: a rigid, food-grade carbon steel crisper plate sized for the Gourmia GAF824 8QT, with a double-layer nonstick coating, a lift-out handle, and four adjustable silicone feet you can tension to fit the basket.
• CyHiThai 8QT — biggest trade-off: it is a single-purpose insert. It fits one specific 8QT Gourmia model, and the nonstick surface needs gentle washing — no abrasive pads or metal scouring balls.
• Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer — biggest strength: a 3-pack of 8.5" x 8.5" BPA-free silicone mats with straight sides for full basket coverage, perforated for airflow, and reusable across the air fryer, oven, microwave and fridge.
• Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: a liner protects and releases food, but it does not add a raised cooking platform or grill-style surface the way a steel crisper plate does.
• Who each pick is for: CyHiThai 8QT for Gourmia GAF824 8QT owners who want a structural upgrade to the basket; Cee & Dee for anyone who wants low-effort cleanup and multi-appliance flexibility.
The CyHiThai 8QT is not a general-purpose accessory. It is a replacement crisper plate built specifically for the Gourmia GAF824 Digital Electric 8QT air fryer. If that is your machine, this is the piece that gives the basket a second cooking level — a square carbon steel rack you drop in, lift out by the handle, and use to crisp food that would otherwise sit in drippings.
The build is the interesting part. It is made of food-grade carbon steel that the brand states meets FDA standards and is BPA-free. The coating is a double-layer nonstick process, which the listing notes is designed to resist flaking and last longer than a single-coat finish. There is a handle for pulling it out of a hot basket, and it is dishwasher safe. It ships as one tray plus four silicone rubber feet as a gift, and those feet are functional, not cosmetic: the listing explicitly tells you to adjust their tightness so the tray seats properly in your specific basket. That is a small but genuinely useful detail, because 8QT baskets from the same model line can vary slightly.
Who should buy it: Gourmia GAF824 8QT owners who want to cook on a raised grid, get better airflow under the food, and stop scrubbing a stained basket floor. The handle and dishwasher-safe design make it a practical daily-use item rather than a gadget.
Who should skip it: anyone who does not own that exact Gourmia model. This is not a universal plate, and the brand is upfront that fit depends on tuning the feet. Also skip it if you hate hand-care rules — the listing warns against rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls, and includes a cleaning cloth to steer you toward gentler washing. If you want a one-size-fits-everything solution, this is the wrong product.
The Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer is a different category of accessory entirely. It is a 3-pack of square silicone liners, each 8.5" x 8.5", in pastel colors. Where the CyHiThai plate is rigid steel, these are soft, reusable mats you lay into the basket.
The design choice that matters is the straight-sided shape. The brand points out that tapered liners leave gaps at the basket walls, so grease and crumbs slide past them; a straight-sided mat covers the full footprint and actually catches the mess. That is a real difference in daily use, and it is the core reason to pick these over generic round or tapered liners. The perforated surface keeps air moving so food still crisps instead of steaming.
Material-wise, they are premium BPA-free food-grade silicone — reusable, durable, and positioned as a lower-waste alternative to disposable paper liners. They are also not air-fryer-only. The same mats work in the oven, microwave and refrigerator, which is why a 3-pack makes sense: one in the basket, one as a fridge or prep mat, one in the wash. Cleanup is warm soapy water or the dishwasher. Item weight is 9.6 ounces for the set, so they are light and easy to store flat.
Who should buy it: anyone who wants fast cleanup without committing to a specific air fryer model. The 8.5" square size suits square-basket fryers and larger round ones, and the multi-appliance use means you get value outside the air fryer too.
Who should skip it: cooks who want a raised grill surface, sear marks, or a platform that lifts food out of fat. Silicone liners hold food at basket level; they do not replace a crisper plate's function. And if you specifically need a replacement part for a Gourmia GAF824, this is not that part.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a Gourmia GAF824 8QT owner → CyHiThai 8QT. It is made for that model, and the adjustable silicone feet let you dial in the fit.
• Best for easy cleanup with zero fit anxiety → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. Straight-sided 8.5" x 8.5" mats cover the basket and rinse or dishwasher clean.
• Best for multi-appliance use → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. Air fryer, oven, microwave, fridge — the same mat works in all of them.
• Best for low-waste, reusable cooking → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. Three BPA-free silicone mats replace a steady stream of disposable paper liners.
• Best durability against scratching → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. Silicone has no nonstick coating to chip, while the CyHiThai plate requires gentle washing to protect its double-layer finish.
• Best if you want a handle for lifting food out → CyHiThai 8QT. The built-in handle is designed for pulling the plate from a hot basket.
• Best if you want the most versatile purchase for a household with several appliances → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. One 3-pack covers more situations.
In my opinion, most shoppers are better served by the Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. The straight-sided silicone mats fit a wider range of baskets, work in four different appliances, come as a 3-pack, and sidestep the nonstick-care rules that come with a coated steel plate. It is the safer, more flexible buy for a general kitchen.
I would recommend the CyHiThai 8QT only if you own the Gourmia GAF824 8QT specifically and want a proper replacement crisper plate — a raised grid, a lift-out handle, and a sturdier cooking surface. Buy it for the function, not as a general accessory. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before deciding, since the two serve very different jobs.
FAQ
No. It is designed for the Gourmia GAF824 8QT air fryer, and the brand advises adjusting the four silicone feet to match your basket. Treat it as a model-specific replacement part, not a universal insert.
They should not. The mats are perforated so hot air circulates through them, which is the point of the design. Just avoid letting food sit in pooled oil on top of the mat.
Both are dishwasher safe. The Cee & Dee mats are silicone with no coating to protect, so they tolerate normal washing. The CyHiThai plate has a double-layer nonstick finish that the brand says should not be scrubbed with abrasive cloths or metal balls.
Yes. They are sized 8.5" x 8.5" and the brand lists oven, microwave and refrigerator use, which is why they come in a 3-pack. The CyHiThai plate, by contrast, is meant for the air fryer basket.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Htanch SN8264 vs HEISENLIN Square Air Fryer: Air Fryer Grill, Weber ® Charcoal Cooking vs CyHiThai Air Fryer Grill, HQT 8QT vs INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Parchment: Power XL Air