Introduction - How Romance Lost Its Way
People have always struggled to love well. What has changed is the culture surrounding them. The once-familiar progression of courtship carries less authority, leaving individuals to negotiate their own terms.
Personal choice has expanded, options seem more abundant and expectations are harder to pin down. Dating apps and social media give old behaviors new reach and an apparently endless supply of people on whom to practice them.
As a result, modern dating can feel like navigating a minefield.
Emotionally unavailable partners, perpetual players, commitment-averse romantics and chronically guarded singles are familiar figures. We recognize their behavior, complain about it and hope the next person will be different.
It’s easy to see ourselves as the people dodging the mines—harder to admit we may have planted a few. Identifying everything wrong with modern dating will take us only so far. If we hope to find lasting love, we must also examine how we choose, what we offer and what we do when attraction puts our judgment to the test.
This book explores the connections among attraction, love and sex—and how we sometimes undermine the relationships we say we want.
Consider how easily desire can get ahead of intention. Two people become physically intimate before either has decided what the relationship means. Sex becomes part of the initial screening process, while trust and long-term intentions, if they develop at all, come later. “Situationships,” “talking stages” and “it’s complicated” give names to that uncertainty. There is intimacy, but little emotional clarity. A connection, but no shared destination.
This is where Cupid offers a useful analogy. The god of desire and attraction does more than gently suggest affection. He disrupts our composure and presses us toward what we want. He bypasses judgment in favor of intensity.
You can continue to envision him as a cute, mischievous winged toddler at your own peril. In earlier Greek depictions, Eros appears as a grown-ass young adult—old enough to cause real trouble, with no guarantee of the wisdom to prevent it.
In one tradition, he is the offspring of Aphrodite, the goddess of love, and Ares, the god of war. That parentage alone should give us pause. His arrows land with the force of a closed-fist slug.
Attraction can be exhilarating, but it can also pull us toward someone whose intentions, temperament or capacity for commitment we have barely examined. The feeling arrives before the understanding.
Cupid gets our attention, but he can’t do the work of getting to know someone, asking difficult questions, keeping agreements or repairing the damage when we fall short. That part belongs to us.
A few well-placed quips, sexual tension and a shared desire to have fun can be enough to start a romance or a fling. The stakes rise when the person who excites us becomes the person with whom we share bills, raise children, make career decisions and navigate the daily demands of life.
A partner can support our aspirations, push us toward accomplishments we never thought possible or steadily pull us away from the life we hoped to build. Choosing that person is among the most consequential decisions many of us will make. Yet few of us are taught how to make it.
For some, marriage remains the centerpiece around which everything else is organized. Others want companionship alongside careers, friendships, children, travel and pursuits they have no intention of abandoning.
Wanting a partner doesn’t mean wanting that person to become our entire world. We may still expect a great deal from the relationship—emotional fulfillment, sexual attraction, honest communication, shared responsibilities and room to remain an individual. A full life outside a partnership doesn’t necessarily mean fewer expectations within one. We have to decide which are essential, which are negotiable and whether we can offer what we ask of someone else.
Sorting that out while searching for someone can wear us down. A favorite hobby or a Netflix binge starts to look better than another date that goes nowhere. We may still want commitment, but we need more than the patience to keep dating. We need to understand what might make the next experience different.
The first section of this book, Old Rules, New Reality, examines the beliefs and expectations we inherited and how they serve us in today’s dating culture.
The second, Setting Your Edge: Attracting the Right Energy, turns our attention toward what we want, what we bring and how we choose.
The final section, Executing from the Correct Playbook, puts those insights to work through practical steps toward more lasting connections.
Along the way, you’ll encounter mainstream opinions, popular assumptions and beliefs you may have held for years. Some will stand up to examination. Others may help explain why you keep arriving at an outcome you say you don’t want.
You may nod in recognition or feel the urge to argue. Before defending a belief, though, ask what has earned it your loyalty. Have you examined it closely? Has it served you well? Or does it simply sound good, feel right or appease an old hurt?
It is possible to win the argument and still miss the point.
As you read, consider whether these ideas help you understand your choices—and make better ones. Knowing the game means little if we keep making the same moves.
Now, let’s get started.