How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Cuisinart Replacement Parts — biggest strength: It is a single-purpose, model-specific crumb tray for the TOA-65, so fit is the whole point. Material is stainless steel with a polished finish.
• Cuisinart Replacement Parts — biggest trade-off: It only lists compatibility with the TOA-65. If your oven is a different model number, this is the wrong part.
• GWY Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: A 9.8" × 9.8" square nonstick crisper plate with a handle and four rubber bumpers, designed for the Gourmia GAF856 and GAF826 8-quart air fryers.
• GWY Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: It is built around an 8-quart Gourmia basket, so you must measure your basket before ordering or it simply will not seat right.
• Who Cuisinart Replacement Parts is for: TOA-65 owners replacing a worn or missing crumb tray.
• Who GWY Air Fryer Replacement is for: Gourmia 8-quart owners who want an easier-to-lift, easier-to-clean crisper plate with better airflow.
This is a boring product in the best sense of the word. The Cuisinart Replacement Parts crumb tray exists to do one job: catch crumbs and drips underneath the basket of a TOA-65 convection toaster oven air fryer. It is stainless steel with a polished finish, and it is sold as a single unit — one crumb tray, nothing else in the box. There is no coating to worry about, no handle, no airflow engineering. It sits where the original sat.
The compatibility line is the entire story here. The part is listed as compatible with the TOA-65, and the model name and number on the listing match that same designation. That is unusually narrow, and it is worth respecting. A crumb tray that is a few millimeters off will either rattle, slide, or not clear the door at all — and this oven uses a dropdown door, so a tray that sits proud of the cavity can catch on the way down. Buying the part that matches your exact model avoids all of that guesswork.
So who should buy it? Anyone with a TOA-65 whose crumb tray has warped, stained past the point of scrubbing, or gone missing. It is also the sensible pick if you want to keep a spare on hand so you are never cooking without one. Who should skip it? Everyone else. If you own a different Cuisinart oven, or a Gourmia air fryer, or anything basket-style, this tray is not going to help you. There is no adjusting it, no trimming it, and no second use for it. Match the model number first, then buy.
GWY Air Fryer Replacement: Who It's For
The GWY plate is the more interesting product of the two, because it is doing actual work inside the cooking chamber. It is a 9.8" × 9.8" square crisper plate and grill pan built for the Gourmia GAF856 and GAF826 8-quart air fryers. It is made of food-grade stainless steel with a nonstick coating, and the listing states it is BPA-free and meets FDA standards — the kind of claim that matters to people who are buying an air fryer specifically to move away from questionable cookware.
The design details are what separate it from a plain rack. There is a handle, so you lift the plate out of the basket instead of fishing under hot food with tongs. There is a whirlwind airflow pattern, which is the brand's way of saying the perforations are arranged to push hot air up and around the food rather than letting it pool. And there are four rubber bumpers in the box, which sit on the plate's edges and keep it from scraping and rattling against the basket interior.
Size is the catch, and the manufacturer says so twice in the listing. You are told to measure your air fryer basket before ordering, and to confirm the inner diameter works with a 9.8-inch square plate. That is not marketing hedging — a square plate in a roughly square basket either drops in flush or it does not, and there is no middle ground. The package dimensions come in at about 10.83 × 10.83 × 0.94 inches, so plan for a little clearance around it.
Cleaning is where this plate earns its place. The nonstick surface releases food, the handle makes it easy to move from basket to sink, and it is dishwasher-safe. The listing also warns against scrubbing it with abrasive cloths or metal balls, which would chew up the coating — and GWY includes a magic cleaning cloth in the box to nudge you toward the gentler route. It ships as one grill pan plus four bumpers.
Who should buy it? Gourmia GAF856 or GAF826 owners who are tired of food sticking to the stock basket, or who want a plate they can pull out and rinse instead of wrestling with the whole basket. Who should skip it? Anyone whose basket is not in that size and model range. If you are outside those two models, measure carefully or look elsewhere.
• Best for exact-model replacement → Cuisinart Replacement Parts. It is listed for the TOA-65 and nothing else.
• Best for a basket-style air fryer → GWY Air Fryer Replacement. Built for the Gourmia GAF856 and GAF826 8-quart units.
• Best for easy food release → GWY Air Fryer Replacement. Nonstick coating and a lift-out handle.
• Best for scrubbing without fear → Cuisinart Replacement Parts. Plain polished stainless steel, no coating to damage.
• Best for airflow and even crisping → GWY Air Fryer Replacement. The whirlwind airflow perforation pattern is designed for that.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → GWY Air Fryer Replacement. The listing states it is dishwasher-safe.
• Best for a no-fuss spare part → Cuisinart Replacement Parts. One tray, one job, no maintenance instructions attached.
• Best if you are unsure of your model number → neither, yet. Check your appliance's model plate before you order either one.
In my opinion, these are not competing purchases — they are answers to two different questions. If I owned a Gourmia GAF856 or GAF826, I would buy the GWY Air Fryer Replacement, because the nonstick surface, the handle and the airflow design all target the everyday annoyances of air frying: stuck food, awkward removal and uneven crisping. If I owned a TOA-65, I would buy the Cuisinart Replacement Parts crumb tray without a second thought, because a crumb tray is not a place to get creative — it is a place to get the fit right. Buy the one that matches the machine on your counter. If you own both appliances, honestly, buy both. Just check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since these are the kind of small parts where a quick look beats assuming.
how to clean air fryer drip tray
Let it cool completely, then lift it out by the handle if it has one. Wash it in warm soapy water with a soft sponge, and if the plate is nonstick and dishwasher-safe — as the GWY listing states — the top rack is fine. Never use abrasive pads or metal balls on a coated plate, since that destroys the nonstick layer.
how to clean cuisinart air fryer drip tray
The Cuisinart Replacement Parts tray is polished stainless steel with no coating, so it tolerates more scrubbing than a nonstick plate. Soak it in hot soapy water to loosen baked-on grease, then scrub with a normal sponge or nylon brush. Check your specific oven's manual for whether the tray is dishwasher-safe before putting it in.
how to clean ninja air fryer drip tray
Ninja trays are a different design from both products here, so follow your Ninja manual rather than borrowing instructions from a Cuisinart or Gourmia part. The general rule holds: cool first, soft sponge, no metal scourers on coated surfaces. If your Ninja tray is nonstick, treat it like the GWY plate.
how to clean breville air fryer drip tray
Breville oven trays are typically coated or enameled, and the same caution applies — no abrasive pads. Soak, then wipe with a soft cloth. Note that neither product on this page is listed as compatible with Breville, so if you own a Breville, confirm the part number for your model before ordering anything.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWY Air Fryer Wire vs YQL Stainless Steel Air: Air Fryer, SUNVIVI Roaster Oven vs Cuisinart Air Fryer +, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement vs CuraceQ 100Pcs