How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a permanent, dishwasher-safe replacement basket for a Cuisinart air fryer toaster oven, choose Cuisinart Non-Stick Airfryer Basket; if you need a big stack of disposable liners that fits almost any 5–8 quart air fryer basket, choose DSMY 150.
• Cuisinart Non-Stick Airfryer Basket — biggest strength: It's a real, reusable part. Non-stick steel, perforated for air circulation, dishwasher safe, and backed by a lifetime warranty — it's built to be used hundreds of times.
• Cuisinart Non-Stick Airfryer Basket — biggest trade-off: It only fits Cuisinart TOA-60 and TOA-65 models. If you own anything else, it's a paperweight.
• DSMY 150 — biggest strength: 150 food-grade wood-pulp liners, 8 x 8 inches, heat resistant up to 480°F, non-stick coated, and sized to drop into most 5–8 quart air fryer baskets.
• DSMY 150 — biggest trade-off: It's a consumable. You use one, you throw it away, and eventually you buy more. It also isn't a structural part — it lines a basket, it doesn't replace one.
• Buy the Cuisinart basket if you own a TOA-60 or TOA-65 and your original basket is worn, stained, or you want a spare.
• Buy the DSMY 150 if you own a 5–8 quart air fryer from pretty much any brand and you're tired of scrubbing the basket after every batch of wings.
This is a factory-style replacement part, and it behaves like one. The construction is non-stick steel with a perforated floor, and that perforation matters more than it sounds: air fryers work by moving hot air around food, and the more freely that air circulates under and around what you're cooking, the more even the browning tends to be. A solid pan traps air; a perforated basket lets it through. That's the whole design philosophy here, and it's the right one for air frying.
The dimensions tell you what to expect in practice. It measures roughly 11.2 inches wide by 1 inch deep by 1.4 inches tall, and it holds about 0.16 cubic feet. That's a shallow, wide tray — the kind that slides into a toaster-oven-style air fryer rather than a pull-out bucket. It weighs 16 ounces, so it's substantial in the hand but not heavy. It's silver, it's dishwasher safe, and it carries a lifetime warranty, which tells you Cuisinart expects it to survive years of normal use.
Who should skip it? Anyone who doesn't own one of those two models. The compatibility list is explicit — TOA-60 and TOA-65 — and there's no universal fit here. Also skip it if you were hoping for a liner solution; this is a rigid basket, not a disposable. And if you own a standard pull-out-basket air fryer, this shape won't do anything for you.
DSMY 150: Who It's For
The DSMY 150 is a completely different kind of product, and it solves a completely different kind of problem. It's a pack of 150 square paper liners, 8 x 8 inches, made from food-grade raw wood pulp. They're heat resistant up to 480°F, and the pleated corners are designed to resist curling when they hit the heat — a small detail that matters, because a liner that folds in on itself is worse than no liner at all.
The non-stick coating is the headline feature for most buyers. It's oil-proof and waterproof, so food releases cleanly and the basket underneath stays largely untouched. If you've ever spent ten minutes chipping dried chicken skin off a wire basket, you understand the appeal immediately. The liners don't need pre-heating, they can be adjusted down to fit your basket size, and they're microwave and oven safe as well, which stretches them beyond air frying.
That versatility is real. The same sheet can line a baking sheet, a pizza pan, a cake pan, or a muffin tin. You can use them for roasting, grilling, and steaming too. That's a genuinely useful thing to have in a drawer, especially if you cook a lot of sticky, saucy, or breaded food.
Who should buy it? Anyone with a 5–8 quart air fryer. The 8-inch square format is designed to fit most of the popular brands — Ninja, PowerXL, Gourmia, Instant Pot, Cosori and others are named as compatible. If you own one of those, you're the target buyer. It's also a good pick for someone who hates cleanup more than they hate buying refills.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for replacing a worn or stained basket → Cuisinart Non-Stick Airfryer Basket. It's an actual part with a lifetime warranty.
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup → DSMY 150. Line, cook, toss, done.
• Best for Cuisinart TOA-60 / TOA-65 owners → Cuisinart Non-Stick Airfryer Basket. It's the only one of the two that fits those models as a basket.
• Best for Ninja, Cosori, Instant Pot, Gourmia or PowerXL owners → DSMY 150. The 8-inch square format is built for that 5–8 quart class.
• Best for even air circulation and crispy results → Cuisinart Non-Stick Airfryer Basket. The perforated design lets hot air move under the food.
• Best for versatility beyond air frying → DSMY 150. Oven, microwave, baking pans, cake pans and muffin tins all work.
• Best for one-and-done buying → Cuisinart Non-Stick Airfryer Basket. You buy it once; the liners are a repeat purchase by nature.
• Best for high-heat cooking → DSMY 150. The liners are rated to 480°F, which covers essentially any air fryer setting you'll use.
In my opinion, the right answer here depends entirely on what's already sitting on your counter, and I'd rather say that plainly than pretend there's a universal winner. If you own a Cuisinart TOA-60 or TOA-65, I'd buy the Cuisinart Non-Stick Airfryer Basket — it's the correct part, it's dishwasher safe, and the lifetime warranty makes it a one-time decision. If you own any other 5–8 quart air fryer, I'd buy the DSMY 150, because it's the one of the two that will actually fit your machine and it removes the worst part of air frying. Buy the part if you need a part. Buy the liners if you need less scrubbing.
FAQ
The liners are 8 x 8 inches and designed for 5–8 quart basket-style air fryers. A Cuisinart TOA-60 or TOA-65 uses a different, toaster-oven-style tray, so these aren't the intended match. Check your basket's shape and size before ordering.
They're made from food-grade wood pulp and rated heat resistant up to 480°F, which covers normal air frying, baking, roasting and microwave use. The pleated corners are designed to keep them from curling in the heat.
They can reduce airflow at the bottom of the basket, and airflow is what makes air-fried food crisp. In my opinion, use them for messy or saucy foods where cleanup is the real problem, and skip them when you want maximum browning on the underside.
Ask what you own. Cuisinart TOA-60 or TOA-65 → the basket. Any 5–8 quart air fryer → the liners. Neither product is a universal fit, so compatibility is the deciding factor. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your machine.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Boxiki Kitchen Non-Stick Steel 6 vs EUSOAR Silver Cupcake Liners, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Grill vs ANQIA Non-Stick Disposable Air, Cuyulitcik 9 vs ZMoal Non Stick Disposable: Air Fryer