How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want deep, punchy in-ear sound with clever magnetic auto power-off for gym and travel use, choose Crave Octane; if you need open-ear awareness with active noise cancellation and longer battery for all-day wear, choose AYI Open Ear Air.
• Crave Octane — biggest strength: deep bass-focused in-ear sound plus magnetic ends that power the buds off when you clip them together and back on when you pull them apart. Biggest trade-off: no noise cancellation, and it leans on an older Bluetooth generation.
• AYI Open Ear Air — biggest strength: open-ear design that keeps you aware of traffic, people and surroundings, backed by active noise cancellation and a 10-hour battery. Biggest trade-off: open-ear fit means less isolation and less thumping bass than a sealed in-ear bud.
• Pick Crave Octane if you want that classic earbud feel — sealed, bass-heavy, sweat-resistant — and you like gear that turns itself off the moment you snap the buds together.
• Pick AYI Open Ear Air if you wear headphones for hours at a stretch, run or cycle near traffic, and want your ears to stay open to the world.
• Battery edge: AYI Open Ear Air at 10 hours vs Crave Octane at 8 hours.
• Comfort philosophy: Crave Octane relies on ear tips and hooks to lock into your ear canal; AYI Open Ear Air sits outside it entirely.
Crave Octane is a traditional in-ear Bluetooth earbud, and it plays to the strengths of that format. The sound profile is tuned around deep, thumping bass with clear treble — the kind of tuning that makes hip-hop, EDM and pop hit hard. If you've ever put in a sealed bud and felt the low end in your chest, that's the experience this design is chasing. The in-ear placement is what makes it possible: a tip that seals your canal gives bass somewhere to build.
The genuinely clever bit is the magnetic, powered ends. Snap the two buds together and they switch off; pull them apart and they wake up. It's a small thing, but it means you don't have to hunt for a power button or remember to shut them down after a workout — clip them and drop them in the included pouch. The set ships with three sizes of ear tips, three sizes of ear hooks, a storage pouch and a USB charging cable, so you can dial in the fit rather than fighting whatever single tip came in the box.
The IPX4 water and sweat resistance rating covers light sweat and splashes, which lines up with the jogging, cycling and daily-exercise use cases Crave names. The in-line microphone handles calls on the move. Bluetooth range is listed at 10 meters, and playback runs up to 8 hours — enough for a long training block, a commute, or a workday of background listening.
Who should skip it? Anyone who wants to hear traffic while running, anyone who dislikes things sitting inside their ear canal, and anyone who wants active noise cancellation. The data sheet lists noise control as None, so if you're trying to mute a plane cabin or a noisy office, this isn't the tool. It's also worth noting the control method is listed as touch while the mic is in-line — an unusual pairing you should be aware of before you buy.
AYI Open Ear Air takes the opposite approach. These are open-ear headphones — they rest outside your ear canal rather than plugging it, so sound reaches you while ambient noise still gets in. The stated goal is situational awareness and comfort during long listening sessions, and that's a real, practical benefit if you run on roads, ride a bike, or need to hear a colleague or a kid call your name without yanking a bud out.
Under the hood, the driver type is listed as bone conduction, which is the mechanism behind that open, airy presentation. You're not getting the sealed-in bass of an in-ear bud — physics doesn't allow it — but you're also not getting the pressure, itch or "plugged up" feeling that makes some people give up on earbuds after an hour.
The feature set is more modern in a couple of key ways. It runs Bluetooth 5.4, which typically means quicker pairing, a steadier connection and lower power draw than older Bluetooth generations. Battery life is listed at 10 hours, noticeably ahead of Crave Octane's 8. And unlike the Crave, it includes Active Noise Cancellation — a genuinely useful addition for calls and for cutting down steady background hum.
Durability is IPX4 waterproof, so sweat and light splashes are covered, same as the Crave. AYI positions it for sports, work and outdoor activities, and that triple framing tells you the design intent: something you can leave on your head all day without discomfort. It's a contemporary-style set in black, aimed at adults.
Who should skip it? If chest-thumping bass is your priority, an open-ear bone conduction design will feel thin next to a sealed in-ear bud. And if you work in a genuinely loud environment and want maximum isolation, open-ear is the wrong category entirely — ANC helps, but it can't match a properly sealed fit for blocking everything out.
• Best for bass and music immersion → Crave Octane. Sealed in-ear fit plus a bass-forward tuning is the clear pick when the music itself is the point.
• Best for battery life → AYI Open Ear Air. 10 hours versus 8 hours, and the newer Bluetooth 5.4 should sip power more efficiently.
• Best for running and cycling near traffic → AYI Open Ear Air. Open-ear awareness is the whole reason this category exists.
• Best for noise cancellation → AYI Open Ear Air. Crave Octane lists noise control as None; the AYI has Active Noise Cancellation.
• Best for a quick grab-and-go habit → Crave Octane. Magnetic ends that auto power off when clipped together are genuinely handy.
• Best for all-day comfort → AYI Open Ear Air. Nothing sitting in your ear canal, and the brand's whole pitch is pain-free long sessions.
• Best for accessories and fit tuning → Crave Octane. Three tip sizes, three hook sizes, a pouch and a charging cable are all in the box.
• Best for connectivity modernity → AYI Open Ear Air. Bluetooth 5.4 versus the older generation on the Crave.
• Best for workouts in general → Either. Both are IPX4, so both handle sweat and splashes; pick based on whether you want isolation or awareness.
In my opinion, I'd buy the AYI Open Ear Air if I had to choose one, mainly because the combination of 10-hour battery, Bluetooth 5.4 and active noise cancellation fits more of my day — work calls, outdoor runs, long listening sessions — than a sealed bass-forward bud does. That said, if your priority is pure musical punch and you like the magnetic auto-off trick, the Crave Octane is the better fit for you, and I wouldn't talk you out of it. The real deciding question is simple: do you want your ears sealed off from the world, or open to it?
Yes, in my opinion. Crave Octane uses a sealed in-ear fit tuned for deep, thumping bass and clear treble. The AYI Open Ear Air uses an open-ear bone conduction driver, which by design delivers less low-end punch because your ear canal isn't sealed.
AYI Open Ear Air lists 10 hours of battery life versus 8 hours on the Crave Octane. The AYI also uses Bluetooth 5.4, which is typically more power-efficient than older Bluetooth versions, so real-world endurance should favor it.
Only the AYI Open Ear Air lists active noise cancellation. Crave Octane lists noise control as None, so it relies purely on the physical seal of its ear tips to reduce outside sound. That seal helps, but it isn't the same as ANC.
Both are IPX4 rated for sweat and light splashes, so both are workout-friendly. The difference is awareness: AYI Open Ear Air lets in surrounding sound, which many runners prefer near traffic, while Crave Octane blocks more of it for a more immersive listen. Check the current price on Amazon for either before you decide.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.