How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to upgrade the fit and grip of your Apple AirPods 1st or 2nd Gen so they stop slipping out mid-workout, choose COMPLY SoftCONNECT; if you need a corded silicone set for sleep, study or travel noise blocking, choose MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone.
• COMPLY SoftCONNECT — biggest strength: a patented silicone sleeve with NON-memory foam tips built specifically for Apple AirPods 1st & 2nd Gen and Apple EarPods, giving a secure in-ear grip without the compress-and-hold routine of traditional foam.
• COMPLY SoftCONNECT — biggest trade-off: the tips must be removed before charging, they're not compatible with AirPods Pro, and AirPods/EarPods themselves are not included.
• MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone — biggest strength: lightweight silicone with a lanyard cord and high-efficiency noise isolation, positioned for sleep, study, work and travel.
• MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone — biggest trade-off: it's a standalone corded silicone set, not a replacement tip for any specific brand of earbuds, so it only helps if you want that corded format.
• Choose COMPLY SoftCONNECT if you already own AirPods 1st/2nd Gen or EarPods and want them to stay put.
• Choose MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone if you want a cheap-to-carry corded set you can wear lying down or on a plane.
COMPLY SoftCONNECT is a replacement earbud tip, not an earbud. That single fact decides everything about who should buy it. It's made by Hearing Components under the COMPLY brand, comes as two pairs of soft foam tips in the Large size with a silicone pouch, and is designed to slip over the stems of Apple AirPods 1st & 2nd Gen, Apple EarPods, and most generic models of comparable size. The patented silicone sleeve is the attachment mechanism — that's what keeps the tip locked onto your device instead of rolling off in your pocket.
The real selling point is the NON-memory foam. Traditional memory foam tips make you squeeze them, insert them, and hold still while they expand. SoftCONNECT skips that ritual entirely: quick insertion, quick removal, and — per the spec — a fit comfortable enough for all-day listening without ear fatigue. If your daily complaint is "my AirPods feel loose and I keep pushing them back in," that's exactly the problem this product is engineered to solve. Workouts, commutes, walking the dog — anything where a hard plastic pod wobbling in your ear is annoying.
On care: clean them gently with warm water and a soft cloth, or use the COMPLY cleaning kit sold separately. Avoid alcohol-based cleaners and lotions — they degrade the foam. That's a minor routine, but worth knowing before you buy.
MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone: Who It's For
MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone is a different animal entirely. It's a standalone set of silicone earbuds with a cord, sold as a single reusable black unit. There's no charging case, no battery, no Bluetooth — just soft, flexible silicone shaped ergonomically to sit in your ear for long stretches. The cord is the defining feature, and it's clearly aimed at people who wear something in bed, at a desk, or on a plane and don't want to lose a loose bud under the pillow.
The silicone construction is where the noise isolation comes from. This is passive blocking — the material physically reduces what reaches your ear canal — not electronic cancellation, despite the product name. MUCKLILY positions it for snoring, sleep, study, meditation, travel and general focus and relaxation. That's a coherent use case: you want the world quieter, you want to stay comfortable for hours, and you want something compact and light enough to toss in a bag. At roughly 0.98 x 0.83 x 0.83 inches and about 0.32 ounces, portability is genuinely part of the pitch.
Who should skip it? If you own AirPods and your problem is fit, this isn't a fix — it doesn't attach to AirPods at all. If you want real active noise cancellation with a battery and circuitry, silicone plugs won't deliver that. And if you need a replacement tip for a specific headphone model, MUCKLILY isn't designed for that job either. It's a self-contained, corded, reusable silicone set, and it's best judged as exactly that.
• Best for AirPods 1st/2nd Gen owners → COMPLY SoftCONNECT. The silicone sleeve is purpose-built for those stems.
• Best for all-day wear without the memory-foam compress ritual → COMPLY SoftCONNECT. NON-memory foam means fast in, fast out.
• Best for sleep, snoring and lying-down listening → MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone. The cord keeps it from vanishing into your sheets.
• Best for study, meditation and focus → MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone. Passive silicone isolation, no power required.
• Best for travel and portability → MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone. Compact, lightweight, one reusable piece.
• Best for workout grip → COMPLY SoftCONNECT. Secure in-ear fit and reliable grip are the headline claims.
• Best for charging convenience → MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone. COMPLY tips must be removed before charging your AirPods.
• Best for buyers who want nothing to charge or pair → MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone. Zero electronics, zero setup.
In my opinion, the right pick depends entirely on what's already in your pocket. If you own AirPods 1st or 2nd Gen or EarPods and your frustration is fit — slipping, aching, constant adjusting — I'd buy the COMPLY SoftCONNECT. It solves one specific problem well, and the NON-memory foam design is the reason to choose it over generic foam tips. If instead you want a corded silicone set for sleep, study or travel, I'd buy the MUCKLILY Noise Cancelling Silicone; it's a simple, lightweight, no-electronics solution built for exactly those moments. Neither replaces the other.
FAQ
No. The noise isolation comes from the silicone construction blocking sound passively. There's no battery or active circuitry — it's a physical barrier, not electronic cancellation. Expect it to muffle, not silence.
They're solving different problems, so value depends on your use case. A tip that makes your existing AirPods wearable again is worth more to some buyers than a standalone sleep set, and vice versa. Check the current price on Amazon for each before deciding.
No. MUCKLILY is a standalone corded silicone set, not a replacement tip for any specific earbud model. If you want to improve AirPods fit, the COMPLY SoftCONNECT is the one designed for that job.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.