How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
• GCQ 2 — best for squeezing air-fry performance out of a Cuisinart compact oven you already own; pick this if you want a stainless basket-and-pan set sized at 10.7" x 9.1" x 2.1" and 11.3" x 9.7".
• Cuisinart Replacement Parts — best for replacing a lost or warped crumb tray; pick this if you own a TOA-28 and need the exact compatible part.
• Plum chef Compact Air Fryer — best for a small kitchen that wants one do-everything countertop unit; pick this if you want an 11 QT, 1000W oven with air fry plus toast, bake, broil, grill, and warm.
• Oster ® Compact Air — best for larger batches in a tight footprint; pick this if you want an 18 Qt (17L) capacity that fits a whole chicken or a 9-inch pizza, with three rack positions.
This is not an appliance. It's a stainless steel basket and tray set built for the Cuisinart TOA-26, TOA-28 and AFR-25 compact air fryer toaster ovens, and it's the pick I'd hand to someone who already has one of those ovens sitting on the counter and feels like the air-fry mode never gets quite crispy enough. The basket measures 10.7" x 9.1" x 2.1" and the tray 11.3" x 9.7" — matched to that oven's interior so food sits up in the airflow instead of flat on a baking sheet. GCQ also notes it fits other air fryer toaster ovens of the right size, so if you're measuring, those numbers are what matter.
In daily use, the point is elevation and airflow. Wings, fries, and vegetables that used to steam on a solid pan get hot air underneath them, which is the whole difference between "baked" and "air fried." The basket has smooth handles, so pulling it out of the oven is straightforward, and it's dishwasher safe — the manufacturer notes that even stuck-on bits come off after a quick soak. It's food-grade stainless steel, BPA-free, and non-toxic, with a stated maximum heat resistance of 480°F.
Two things a buyer needs to know. First, preheating is not optional. GCQ states plainly that the set must go into a preheated 300°F oven for 10 minutes before first use, or it may deform, bend, or be damaged and end up with a shorter lifespan. That's unusual for cookware and easy to skip — don't. Second, skip abrasive scouring pads and metal balls when cleaning, per the manufacturer. Treat those two rules as part of the product, and it's a sensible, low-drama addition to an oven you already like. If you don't own a Cuisinart TOA-26, TOA-28, or AFR-25, measure before buying.
This one is a single replacement crumb tray for the Cuisinart TOA-28 compact air fryer toaster oven. That's the entire scope. No basket, no pan, no rack — just the slide-out tray that catches crumbs and drips at the bottom of the oven. If yours got bent, lost in a move, or stained past the point you want to look at it, this is the part.
It's for a specific buyer: someone who already owns a TOA-28 and wants the oven working properly again. The compatibility note is narrow on purpose — the part is stated as compatible with the TOA-28, and I'd take that literally. If your model number reads differently, this isn't the piece for you, and guessing here just means a return.
Practically, a crumb tray is a boring part that does real work. It keeps drips off the heating elements, which cuts down on smoke and that burnt smell the next time you toast something. Pulling it out and rinsing it is far easier than tipping an oven over the sink. Cuisinart lists it at 9.6 ounces with package dimensions of 13.74 x 10.43 x 1.02 inches, consistent with a flat tray shaped for that oven's footprint.
The trade-off is obvious and worth saying out loud: this is not a way to add air-frying to anything. It's maintenance, not an upgrade. If you're shopping because you want crispier food, look at the basket set above or a full oven below. If you're shopping because your TOA-28's tray is trashed, this is exactly right and nothing else on this list is.
This is a complete countertop oven rather than an accessory, and its whole pitch is fitting where nothing else fits. It's rated at 11 QT, with a 10.63"D x 11.81"W x 12.6"H footprint in black with a stainless steel interior. Plum Chef describes the capacity as enough for one to three people — a layer holds up to two slices of bread, a 6-inch pizza, or eight chicken wings. If you cook for two and your counter is already crowded, that's the honest target.
The function list is long for a unit this size: air fry, toast, convection bake, bake, convection broil, broil, grill, and warm, plus five preset menu buttons for chicken wings, toast, kebab, fish sticks, and french fries. Power is 1000W with 360° hot air circulation, and the max temperature setting is 450°F with a 60-minute timer. There's a built-in window so you can watch progress without opening the door and dumping the heat — a small feature that genuinely changes how often you check on food.
Plum Chef says the air fry mode cuts over 95% of fats compared to traditional frying, and the unit is ETL-listed for safety. Controls are touch, and it ships with a bake tray, mesh rack, and retrieval clip; the listing also references a grabber, baking pan, air fryer basket, and drip tray. Either way, you get the pieces to bake, air fry, and catch drips without buying extras. It's backed by a one-year warranty with a stated 24-hour customer service response.
Oster ® Compact Air
Oster's take is the one I'd point a family toward. The capacity is 18 Qt (17L), which Oster says fits a whole chicken or a 9-inch pizza — noticeably more room than the Plum Chef, and enough to cook for several people at once. Despite that, the dimensions are 16.9"D x 18.5"W x 12.3"H, so it's still a countertop unit rather than a second full-size oven.
Five functions cover air fry, bake, broil, toast, and warm. The air fry mode uses what Oster calls Turbo Convection Heat Technology, and the company states it delivers a crispy finish with 99.5% less oil compared to traditional deep fryers. Three adjustable rack positions are the feature I'd actually use most: one level for a tray of fries, or two levels to cook a side and a main at the same time without shuffling pans.
Controls are manual knobs with a timed cooking function up to 60 minutes. That's a deliberate choice — no touch panel, no presets, nothing to learn. Some people will find that refreshing; others will miss one-touch programs. The door is a dropdown style in black with a metal door material, and the removable crumb tray makes cleanup a matter of sliding it out. Four accessories are included: a baking pan, crumb tray, wire rack, and air fryer mesh rack.
The trade-off is that manual control cuts both ways. You're setting time and function yourself every time, which is fine for someone who cooks by feel and mildly annoying for someone who wants a wings button. And at 18.5 inches wide, it takes up more counter than the other ovens here — check your space before you commit. For a household that wants one appliance to toast bagels in the morning and roast a chicken at night, this is the pick.
How We Picked
We compared the published specs and features of each item — dimensions, capacity, wattage, cooking functions, materials, controls, and included accessories — and weighed them against how people actually use a small countertop oven. The ranking is our independent editorial opinion. No brand paid for placement, and no manufacturer saw this list before it went up.
It's designed for the Cuisinart TOA-26, TOA-28, and AFR-25. GCQ says it also fits other air fryer toaster ovens of the right size, so measure your interior against the 10.7" x 9.1" x 2.1" basket and 11.3" x 9.7" tray before ordering.
Yes. GCQ states it must go into a preheated 300°F oven for 10 minutes before first use, or it may deform or bend and last a shorter time. It's a one-time step, but skipping it risks the product.
It varies a lot. The Plum Chef is an 11 QT unit suited to one to three people, holding two slices of bread, a 6-inch pizza, or eight wings per layer. The Oster is 18 Qt (17L) and Oster says it fits a whole chicken or a 9-inch pizza.
The GCQ 2 basket and tray set, in my opinion — it's the cheapest way to get real air-fry airflow in an oven you already have. If your crumb tray is the problem instead, the Cuisinart replacement part is the fix.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: toaster oven air fryer accessories, digital air fryer toaster oven, air fryer toaster oven