We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
The best toaster oven air fryer accessory I'd buy first is the INFRAOVENS Parchment Baking Paper — a 100-sheet pack of perforated 12 x 13 liners that keeps racks and baskets clean while still letting hot air move through your food.
• INFRAOVENS Parchment Baking Paper — best for mess-free everyday cooking and baking; pick this if you want 100 perforated 12 x 13 liners that fit most toaster oven and air fryer racks and let air circulate.
• Allstare DT201 — best for replacing a worn-out Ninja Foodi crumb tray; pick this if your model number is on its compatibility list and you want a 304 stainless steel drip pan sized 14.3'' x 11.8''.
• Générique 1PC — best for silicone baking in pink; pick this if you want a reusable non-stick mold for eggs and cupcakes, with a rolling pin and pastry board in the set.
• Generic 1PC — best for silicone baking in grey; pick this if you want the same reusable non-stick mold setup in a neutral color, with a rolling pin and pastry board included.
This is a 100-sheet pack of perforated parchment liners, each cut to 12 x 13 inches. The brand lists fit with Cuisinart TOA-60 and TOA-65, Breville, Black and Decker, Hamilton Beach, Cosori, Ninja and others — and the sheet itself tells you to measure your rack before buying, which is the honest way to approach a liner that lives or dies on dimensions. Material is paper with a silicone component, rectangular, black, and you get 100 liners in the box.
What do perforations actually buy you? On a solid sheet of parchment, the bottom of your food sits in a pocket of trapped moisture and steams. The holes let hot air pass through the liner so the underside of a batch of wings or frozen fries can still crisp while the paper catches the grease, crumbs and sticky glaze that would otherwise bake onto your rack. That's the everyday win: you pull the liner, toss it, and your rack still looks like a rack instead of a crime scene.
For baking, the math changes slightly. Cookies, reheated BBQ wings, anything saucy or cheesy — these are the jobs where a liner saves you the scraping session afterward. The brand also pairs the pack with a reusable black grilling mat, and that mat has a second use worth knowing: for loose or liquid foods it blocks pieces from dropping through the rack openings. So you have two tools in one box and you choose based on the food.
The trade-off is real and the brand states it plainly: never preheat or run the appliance with the liners alone inside. They're light, they will lift, and they can get caught in the heating element. Always put food on top to weigh them down. If you routinely preheat an empty oven and then slide food in, this is the one habit you have to change. Also, 12 x 13 won't suit very small or unusually shaped racks — measure first. In my opinion this is the single most useful accessory for anyone who cooks in a toaster oven air fryer several times a week, because it turns cleanup from a chore into a two-second action.
Allstare DT201
This is a replacement crumb tray — one pack, 14.3 inches by 11.8 inches, 0.6 inch tall, in 304 stainless steel with a silver finish. It's a direct part swap, not a universal accessory, and the compatibility list is specific: Ninja Foodi models DT200, DT201, DT201B2NP, DT201C, DT201NP, DT202BK, DT251, DT251B1, DT255CO, DZ201C and DT255A. It's also listed against OEM part numbers 108SH200 and 105SH200.
Why 304 stainless steel matters here: it's food-grade, it's rated for high heat, and it resists the rust and warping that thinner or coated trays tend to develop over repeated cycles. The pan sits under the rack and catches whatever falls — crumbs, oil, drips from a roast chicken or a tray of bacon. That keeps the bottom of the oven cleaner and, in practice, keeps your food from sitting in pooled grease. Cleaning is the easy part: slide it out, dump the crumbs, wipe with a soft damp sponge, and use a liquid cleanser if stains start building up.
The main trade-off is fitment risk. The brand is unusually blunt about it — don't order by appearance, compare the size and model against your own original part. Two Ninja trays can look nearly identical in a photo and differ by a fraction of an inch that decides whether they slide freely. There's also a 30-day manufacturer warranty, which is a reasonable cushion, but the better protection is checking your model number against that list before you buy. In my opinion this is a sensible, no-drama fix rather than an upgrade — you're restoring what the oven came with, in a material that should outlast the original.
Here's a different kind of accessory: a single reusable silicone mold built for air fryer and toaster oven baking. Non-stick surface, easy release, dishwasher safe, and the brand pitches it for eggs, cupcakes and small snacks. The listing is the pink version, described as 3pcs Pink in the color field, and the set also includes a rolling pin and a pastry board.
The case for silicone over paper here is repeat use. A paper liner is one cook and gone; a silicone mold you rinse or dishwash and use again next morning. If you like egg bites, single-serve muffins, or small baked custards in a toaster oven, a mold gives you shape — which parchment can't do. It also expands what the appliance can make, which is the whole point of buying accessories for a toaster oven air fryer in the first place.
The rolling pin and pastry board push this toward dough work: flattening pie crust, shaping cookie dough, prepping bread on a smooth surface instead of your countertop. That's a nice bonus if you bake, and fairly useless if you don't.
Generic 1PC
This is the same concept in a different colorway: one reusable silicone egg and cupcake mold for air fryers and toaster ovens, non-stick, dishwasher safe, listed here in grey. The included-components field again names a cover, and the set brings a rolling pin and pastry board along with the mold.
Functionally, I'd expect it to behave like any silicone baking mold — flexible, easy to release food from, and happy in a dishwasher. The stated uses are the same: eggs, cupcakes, pastries and desserts in various shapes, plus dough prep on the pastry board. For a small household that bakes occasionally, or someone who wants egg bites without buying a dedicated appliance, that covers a lot of ground for one small item.
Because the two silicone listings come from near-identical brand names and share a model number, my honest read is that they're variants of the same item, and the meaningful difference for a buyer is the color and whatever the listing's own contents line says. That makes this a straightforward choice: pick grey if it suits your kitchen, pick pink if you'd rather have the brighter one. Don't expect them to be different products.
The trade-offs are the same as above. Confirm the package contents, support the mold on a tray when it's full of liquid batter, and don't count on silicone for browning. Also worth saying: neither silicone listing is a rack, tray or liner, so if your goal is protecting the oven floor or crisping food on a rack, this isn't that product. It's a baking-shape tool. In my opinion it's the right add-on for someone who already has their cleanup sorted and now wants to cook more types of food.
How We Picked
I compared the published specs and features of each accessory — dimensions, materials, stated compatibility lists and included components — and weighed how each one behaves in normal toaster oven and air fryer use. The ranking is my independent editorial opinion, based on those specs rather than any hands-on testing. No brand paid for placement or had any input into the order.
The INFRAOVENS liners are 12 x 13 inches, which the brand lists as fitting many Cuisinart, Breville, Black and Decker, Hamilton Beach, Cosori and Ninja models. Measure your rack before buying — an oversized liner curls up the sides.
No. The brand specifically warns against running or preheating the appliance with liners alone, because they can lift and hit the heating element. Always place food on top to hold them down.
Check your model number against the list: DT200, DT201, DT201B2NP, DT201C, DT201NP, DT202BK, DT251, DT251B1, DT255CO, DZ201C, DT255A. The brand advises comparing size and model against your original part rather than judging by appearance.
The listings describe them as reusable, non-stick and dishwasher safe, and intended for air fryer and toaster oven baking. Set the mold on a tray or rack before filling it so it stays level going in.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: digital air fryer toaster oven, air fryer oven accessories, toaster oven air fryer combo