The Marvelfied Mind:Escaping the Trap of Collective Blame
A cold prison cell while you hold a sign. A sign asking for help. But the whole world is against you, and always will be, because your country has become a killing machine. Or at least the world thinks.
For millennia, we have chosen simple thinking, seeing the world as good and evil. Because it's easy. Because it's prettier than reality. But the truth hidden behind the extremist headline will shock you, just like it shocked me. Nearly nineteen thousand Russians were detained for anti-war protests in 2022 alone (OVD-Info). Yet the world flattens a population of 140 million unique individuals into the image of their leader. Russians are denied entry worldwide, fired from global jobs, expelled from schools, punished by both their own country and the rest of the world for the crime of wanting peace, while we pretend they all want war. This reflex is deeply human, wired into us from birth. But being natural does not make it right. And being ingrained does not make it unchangeable. This essay moves through five stages. First, the Russian case as undeniable proof. Second, the psychological engine that drives our blame. Third, the harder test of American democracy. Fourth, the media's amplification of this reflex. Finally, the universal pattern that spans every nation.
When you look at the long list of Russian citizens imprisoned for anti-war protests, you have to keep scrolling just to reach the names starting with B. Russia's freedom score is twelve out of a hundred as of 2026, lower than it was when the war began (Freedom House). The average freedom score across the globe is around sixty, with several dozen countries scoring in the nineties. Looking at those two stats together, you hardly need to explain being a Russian in 2026 is not the dream. Despite the dangers that surround them, since February 2022, over 20,000 Russians have faced fines or sentences for making anti-war statements (The Moscow Times). Controversially, 66% approved of Putin as of June 28 this year. It had been 70% the week earlier (The Moscow Times). But by looking at the full picture we can understand polling Russians isn't always going to provide accurate results. We know what happens when you disapprove of Putin, your name gets lost in the vast seas of the endless list. You know what I think? Russians distrust the safety of distrust. And why wouldn't they, when hundreds are gone? Even if the stats were fully accurate, that would still be a third of the population disagreeing with Putin's decisions. This disapproval spans Russia from Moscow to St Petersburg to Novosibirsk, quietly or loudly the whole country knows the leadership just isn't right. We see the war on the news constantly, but how many times do we hear this side of the story? Because from the news I see, this perspective is painfully underexposed.
One of the reasons is that Russians are silenced. Silenced by the law. The war censorship laws were put in place in March 2022. They punish the spreading of “knowingly false information’ regarding the Russia-Ukraine war. The laws are deliberately vague. That is the whole point. When you don't know what can be punished, you are far less likely to rebel. This may explain why people do not feel safe answering honestly on approval ratings. Who knows what is acceptable and what can send you to a cell?
Turns out, lots can send you to jail. Punishments are escalating drastically. In 2022, two out of fourteen convictions for ‘war-fakes’ resulted in prison time. A year later, it was eight out of twenty-one (The Moscow Times). There is not enough data to determine full percentages for any year, with recent years being the most sparse. But most sources agree numbers are growing rapidly. There is not enough to conclude for this year, but we do know of prison sentences rising up to 25 years. That's a third of the average life for criticizing a dictator. Recent imprisonments seem less about laws and more about manufacturing fear. The case of Ilya Yashin is a prime example.
“I see it as an illegal expulsion against my will,” Yashin said after being expelled from his country in a prisoner exchange on August 1st (Meduza). Ilya Yashin was an opposition politician, human rights activist, and journalist until he was arrested for a YouTube video. Yashin posted footage of hundreds of Ukrainian citizens killed by Russian occupying forces in Bucha. His video was accused of being staged provocation. Yashin was sentenced to eight and a half years behind bars before he was exchanged. “With that hysterical sentence, the authorities want to scare us all, but it effectively shows their weakness,” Yashin said after his sentence (BBC News).
Yashin is not alone. In March 2022, Russian children as young as seven, along with their mothers, were arrested for bringing flowers and signs to the Ukrainian embassy (NPR). In May 2025, fifteen-year-old Sevastyan Sultanov was sentenced for two pieces of anti-war graffiti (The Moscow Times). These might seem like solitary cases, but 544 minors have been detained over anti-war protests since 2023 (The Moscow Times). If so many Russians are against the war, and they clearly are, then why do we so easily blame civilians for their state's actions?
II. The Psychological Engine
The answer is not logic. It is psychology. Scapegoating is the act of unfairly blaming an individual, group, or organization for a problem they did not cause. According to Rothschild and colleagues, this displacement serves a purpose. It reduces "collective guilt over ingroup harm-doing" by redirecting moral outrage outward (Rothschild et al.). In other words, we judge entire countries for problems our own nations share, just as we judge individuals who remind us of ourselves. This is not new. History is littered with whole communities painted with one brush. Jewish populations blamed for economic collapse. Japanese Americans accused of a foreign empire's attack. Muslim communities criticized for the crimes of a few. We recycle the same dehumanizing logic generation after generation, only swapping the target. It is so much easier to reflect on others' failures than our own. We categorize people like us as good and people like “them” as bad. We hardly notice we are far more similar than different. Scapegoating puts some under a magnifying glass while we throw our own mistakes out the window.
A second reason is that our brains do not always thrive in complexity. We struggle to imagine eight billion people, so we shift to imagine their leaders. We want the world as good guys and bad guys. When we see an extremist post about how all Russians want war, our confirmation bias clicks on. When we see good people from all sides, it clicks off. For us to be the good guys, bad guys must exist. And who wants empathy for the bad guys?
This way of thinking has a name in this essay. I call it Marvelfied thinking.
We are surrounded by stories that divide the world into heroes and villains. The hero has a side, the villain has a side, and the side we pick determines the judgement people have of us. Real life does not work that way. Countries are not characters. Citizens are not armies. Politicians are not their populations. Yet when reality becomes complicated, we reach for the simplest story available. We turn millions of people into one character. We give that character a face, a motive, and a moral label. Then we decide how we feel about everyone else based on it.
So what if we shift direction? Who is the rest of the world scapegoating?
Across 29 countries, only 46% believe the United States will have a positive influence. It ranges from 76% in Peru down to 19% in Canada (Ipsos). Why do less than half trust the impact of one of the most powerful countries of our time? The answer ranges from stereotypes to cultural differences, but the main cause is ultimately politics. Over the years, I have heard endless criticism toward Americans. When researching polls, I expected high percentages labeling them "arrogant" or "rude." What I found was much more interesting. Many polls barely separate rating the United States from rating Americans. Even when they rate Americans, the reasons are often politics-driven. That begs the question. Do the choices of American politicians shape how the world sees American citizens? If so, in a way is Russia and the United States really so different?
You might be thinking, yes, incredibly different. The United States is a democracy. Russia is a dictatorship. Americans choose their leaders.
The distance between a prison cell and a president many don't support is real, and I am not pretending otherwise. What I am comparing is not the punishment but the way an entire population gets held responsible for decisions most of them never made. If Americans truly chose Trump, most would approve of the current leadership, but Trump's approval hovers around 33% (The New York Times). The image you want to reflect your country goes far deeper than the name you check on a ballot. Seventy-five percent of Americans say presidents should seek congressional approval before military decisions, yet with power concentrated on one person's shoulders, it becomes much harder for anyone else to have a say (Responsible Statecraft). Two-party thinking forces people to vote against their greater enemy. The least bad option is rarely a good one, and it leads to the unsettling reality that two-thirds of a population are unhappy with their president. So even in a democracy, a president's decisions should not fall on the people's shoulders.
But what about that 33%? Surely they are accountable.
Not necessarily.
Accepting Trump does not mean endorsing every choice. The system was built long ago for one person to make decisions and keep blood off civilian hands. That makes sense. We would make little progress if we voted on every decision. Yet having every major decision for hundreds of millions rest on one person supported by only a third is absurd. Congress has some say, but it hardly balances Trump's power. With wars, tariffs, and deportations, it is easy to see why not even half of people in those 29 countries believe the United States does more good than harm.
The progress America achieves does not matter when you check a box on a survey. Nor does the friendly tourist you met last year. When you say you dislike Americans, you are not thinking of 342,833,447 faces. You are thinking of one.
See the pattern?
It is not Russia. It is not dictatorships. It is not even the United States.
It's our heads.
It is how what we want to see never matches what we do. It is time to examine why we think this way, and how the media has weaponized what psychology started.
IV. The Media's Amplification
The media does not just trigger this hero and villain thinking. It scripts who our heroes and villains are, starting with the movies, books, and shows. Take the most obvious example: Marvel.
Marvel is fiction, obviously. I am not arguing that flawless heroes and inhuman villains make the world worse. That would be a stretch. I am arguing that superhero stories mirror how we already picture reality, and that mirror is shattered.
Everyone thinks they are the hero. Have you ever met someone who admits to being terrible? If you have, they are an exception. 98% of English people consider themselves in the top half of niceness (CBS News). 53% of Americans view their own compatriots as morally bad (Pew Research Center). Different countries, same frightening pattern. We forgive ourselves and convict everyone else.
It is hard to accept that a war has villains on both sides. It is harder to accept that it also has good people on both sides who just want to live. That is where Marvelfied thinking turns dangerous: a government becomes its people, a politician becomes a country, a flag becomes a personality, and millions of strangers collapse into one image.
So who is casting these roles? It starts at home. When your family and friends hate someone, you likely will too. It hardens as we get older. Our phones learn what we already believe and feed it back to us. You've likely heard of echo chambers, but do you know why they persist? Because different is uncomfortable, and we crave comfort.
Maybe echo chambers were never technology's fault.
Maybe they were always bound to happen.
Maybe they were waiting for us.
If Marvelfied thinking is truly wired into us, then its consequences should appear everywhere, not just in the United States or Russia, but in every corner of the world.
Across every continent, people receive collateral blame for governments they never controlled, and each case has its own quiet evidence of that blame being wrong.
Travel to Asia. Indians and Pakistanis have called each other their greatest threats for years. Ninety-one percent of Indians view Pakistanis unfavorably. Pakistan returns the sentiment at 78% (Pew Research Center). And yet in 2016, after nineteen Indian soldiers were killed in Kashmir and calls for war spiked on both sides, a twenty-four-year-old Pakistani woman named Aliya Harir crossed from Islamabad into India anyway, leading a delegation of Pakistani girls to a peace conference. She said every Indian she met on that trip was warm and welcoming despite the surrounding hostility (Al Jazeera).
In Sudan, when fighters stopped a group of men fleeing el-Fasher in 2025, a young man named Alkheir Ismail was recognized by a former university classmate among them, who told the others not to kill him (Al Jazeera). One person, for one second, treated Ismail as someone he actually knew instead of a category he was supposed to belong to, and it was the only thing that made a difference.
This issue spans the globe because our minds are drawn toward simple stories. We want heroes. We want villains. We want to know who is right before we have learned who people are.
Return to the cell we opened with, the cold room, the cardboard sign, a country transformed into one man's caricature. That cell exists because of a decision that happens before any government acts on it: the decision to see a person as a flag instead of a face. Ilya Yashin made that decision reversible for one Russian audience willing to listen. Aliya Harir made it reversible for a busload of Indian strangers. A man in el-Fasher recognized a former classmate through a militia uniform and made it reversible for one more life, for one more second, in the middle of the worst possible circumstances to do it. None of them changed a government. They changed the smallest unit of the problem. So can we.
The next time a leader's decision makes you angry at an entire country, ask which one you are actually angry at, the person who made the decision, or the millions who did not. Do that consistently enough and the cell built out of cardboard signs and collective hatred stops being inevitable. Marvelfied thinking was never wired into the world. It is wired into us, one unexamined assumption at a time. It can be unwired the same way. Let's escape the Marvelfied Mind.
Works Cited
ACLED. Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project, www.acleddata.com/. Accessed 11 Sept. 2026.
"America's Reputation Drops Across the World." Ipsos, 2025, www.ipsos.com/en-us/americas-reputation-drops-across-the-world.
"Donald Trump Approval Rating Polls." The New York Times, 2025, www.nytimes.com/interactive/polls/donald-trump-approval-rating-polls.html.
"Freedom in the World 2024: Country Scores." Freedom House, 2024, freedomhouse.org/country/scores.
"Ilya Yashin: Russian Opposition Politician Sentenced." BBC News, 2022, www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-63915301.
"'I See It as an Illegal Expulsion Against My Will.'" Meduza, 2 Aug. 2024, meduza.io/en/feature/2024/08/02/i-see-it-as-an-illegal-expulsion-against-my-will.
"In 25-Country Survey, Americans Especially Likely to View Fellow Citizens as Morally Bad." Pew Research Center, 5 Mar. 2026, www.pewresearch.org/religion/2026/03/05/in-25-country-survey-americans-especially-likely-to-view-fellow-citizens-as-morally-bad/.
"India and Pakistan: Rivals with Divergent Views of the Global Order." Pew Research Center, 13 Aug. 2026, www.pewresearch.org/global/2026/08/13/india-pakistan-rivals-with-divergent-views-of-the-global-order/.
OVD-Info. "Anti-War Protests Detention Statistics." Repression.info, 2022, repression.info/en/locations/imprisoned.
"Poll: Americans Want Biden to Push for Ceasefire in Gaza and Ukraine." Responsible Statecraft, 2024, responsiblestatecraft.org/poll-ukraine-israel/. Accessed 11 Sept. 2026.
"Putin's Job Approval Rating Sees Sharpest Weekly Drop Since Ukraine Invasion." The Moscow Times, 3 July 2026, www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/07/03/putins-job-approval-rating-sees-sharpest-weekly-drop-since-ukraine-invasion-vtsiom-a93161.
Rothschild, Zachary K., et al. "A Dual-Motive Model of Scapegoating: Displacing Blame to Reduce Guilt or Increase Control." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 102, no. 6, 2012, pp. 1148–63. PubMed, pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22545745/. Accessed 11 Sept. 2026.
"Russia Handing Out More Jail Sentences Under War Censorship Laws in 2023." The Moscow Times, 23 Oct. 2023, www.themoscowtimes.com/2023/10/23/russia-handing-out-more-jail-sentences-under-war-censorship-laws-in-2023-kommersant-a82860.
"Russian Police Jail Kids Who Took Flowers and 'No to War' Signs to Ukraine's Embassy." NPR, 2 Mar. 2022, www.npr.org/2022/03/02/1083911717/russian-police-jail-kids-who-took-flowers-and-no-to-war-signs-to-ukraines-embass.
"Silence or Jail: Teens Targeted in Russia's Wartime Political Crackdown." The Moscow Times, 2 May 2025, www.themoscowtimes.com/2025/05/02/silence-or-jail-teens-targeted-in-russias-wartime-political-crackdown-a88944.
"Study: People Think They're Nicer Than They Actually Are." CBS News, 2023, www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/study-people-think-theyre-nicer-than-they-actually-are/.
"Thousands Missing, New Horrors Emerge After RSF Taking of Sudan's El-Fasher." Al Jazeera, 1 Nov. 2025, www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/11/1/thousands-missing-new-horrors-emerge-after-rsf-taking-of-sudan-el-fasher.
"The Voices of Peace Opposing War in India and Pakistan." Al Jazeera, 19 Oct. 2016, www.aljazeera.com/news/2016/10/voices-peace-opposing-war-india-pakistan-161019053544807.html.
Freedom House. “Russia: Freedom in the World 2026 Country Report.” Freedom House, 2026, freedomhouse.org/country/russia/freedom-world/2026.