The story concerned two Chicago musicians, William Looney and John Kelly, who had been hired to entertain at a parish fair at St. James.
Because the festivities ran late, they slept overnight in a building on the church property.
Looney reportedly awoke to the sound of galloping horses and a carriage on the road, but when he looked outside, nothing was there.
In September 1897, the Chicago Tribune was already reporting supernatural stories from Sag Bridge.
The vague legend says hooded figures have appeared at St. James since the nineteenth century.
In November 1977, a Cook County law-enforcement officer saw approximately eight hooded figures moving from the woods toward the St. James property. Thinking they were trespassers or pranksters, he pursued them; the figures reportedly disappeared as they reached the hill.
There is apparently no record of a community of monks ever living at St. James...
The sighting of these phantom friars long ago earned the church’s social hall the name of “Monk’s Castle” in local lore, though no record exists of monks ever living here.
The priests who have made their home at this sacred site, however, have had their own stories to tell.
An early pastor, Fr. James Bollman, claimed to regularly witness the cemetery ground rising and falling as if the entire landscape were one great body of water-or as if the earth were breathing.
Additionally, the unmistakable sound of Gregorian chant has been heard in the vicinity, and a ghost light has been reported, bobbing among the tombstones.
One of the strangest St. James traditions involves the ground itself.
An early parish priest is said to have seen the cemetery earth rise and fall as though breathing. Later writers preserve that story as part of St. James lore.
For over a century and a half, strange tales have been told of this part of the Chicago Southland-tales including haunted houses, disembodied voices and music, phantom cars, and no less than Chicago’s most famous ghost: the wayfaring spirit known as “Resurrection Mary.”
An Archer Avenue legend is a driverless horse-drawn hearse.
Some versions say the hearse carries an infant's coffin that glows through its viewing window.
Other versions connect the spectral carriage to the 1897 St. James encounters.
Saint Charles Borromeo on Chicago's Near West Side was plagued by supernatural manifestations.
Father Rocco discovered that the building was allegedly haunted by the spirit of Bishop Peter J. Muldoon, a real historical figure and highly influential Chicago prelate who had died decades earlier.
Bishop Muldoon's life had been filled with intense clerical competition, political rivalries, and public scandals. The book explains the haunting as a spiritual echo of these unfinished earthly battles, with Muldoon's ghost bound to the rectory until the truth of his legacy, his missing ring, and the clerical sabotage against him could be brought to light