Sensemaking Workshop
at CHI 2024

Sensemaking: What is it today?


Sunday, May 12, 2024

Room 306A at the Hawai'i Convention Center

Everything you need to know about the "Sensemaking: What is it today?"  Workshop at CHI 2024 in Honolulu, Hawai'i (USA)  

A workshop on how sensemaking is currently operating
How people are making sense of their world.  What are the tools, processes, methods, results.  

Call for Presentations (CfP) - how to participate

This workshop will focus on the most recent work in sensemaking, the activities, technologies and behaviors that people do when making sense of their complex information spaces. 

We are seeking submissions from interested authors who can present their work in sensemaking.  This can be case studies of sensemaking behavior, analyses of tools that people use for sensemaking, or position papers about how sensemaking should be working in an ideal world.  

The workshop will have presentations from accepted papers in the first half, and then a group effort to understand this field and how it's evolving.  

The workshop is  scheduled to be held on Sunday, May 12, and will be an all-day event.

To submit a paper, please contact the workshop coordinator, Daniel M. Russell at dmrussell@gmail.com with your idea for submission.  If you've got a paper that you'd like to submit, please click on this link to formally submit your proposed paper to the workshop.  

We will only accept as many papers as will fit into the program, so we anticipate this to be somewhat competitive.  We also expect to let authors know about acceptance by March 15.  Note that CHI Early Registration closes 2 weeks later on April 1. 

We're especially interested in the ways in which sensemaking practices will be affected by the latest wave of AI methods.  How can generative AI help in sensemaking?  

Paper Proposal Submission Deadline:  (Update--we've extended the deadline by 1 week.)  February 29, 2024.   We will notify authors of acceptances by March 15, 2024.  

Link to CfP details

Please click on this link to formally submit your proposed paper to the workshop


The Workshop will be held on May 12, 2024 in Room 306A at the Hawai'i Convention Center (Link to Map of room location


Plan for the workshop

Master plan: We'll share our work with short presentations to the entire meeting until the first coffee break in the afternoon.  As we've done in earlier workshops, we'll have 3 sessions with papers grouped by topic.  Each hour-long session will have presentations + discussions. We'll then break into subgroups to work on specific sensemaking topics before regrouping to merge and share our insights. (See agenda plan below.) 

Agenda 

          9     Intros (2 minutes per person + inevitable discussion time) 

10     Session 1: AI and XR in sensemaking (9 papers)  

   - 10 min lead paper; 8 others at 3 mins each;

     26 mins discussion 

11     coffee break

11:15     Session 2: People and sensemaking (9 papers) 

    - 10 min lead paper; 8 others at 3 mins each;

      26 mins discussion 

12:15     lunch

13:30     Session 3: Tools (10 papers)

              - 10 min lead paper; 9 others at 3 mins each; 

        23 mins discussion 

14:30 coffee break

15:30     Session 4: Group sensemaking task  

- identify key themes of workshop in 4 subgroups; 

     - merge together at the end  

17:30 wrapup

18         post workshop appetizers / drinks at a place TBD

Participant Papers 

Sesssion #1:  Using AI for Sensemaking 

Using Generative AI to Enhance Sensemaking of Domain Experts: A Case Study in Whole Genome Sequencing Analysis (10)  Angela Mastrianni, et al. 

When Generative AI meets Email: Enhancing Sensemaking and Utilization of Information for Work YINGLONG ZHANG, et al. 

What to Make Sense of in the Era of LLM? A Perspective from the Structure and Efforts in Sensemaking TIANYI LI, et al. 

Making sense of developer productivity with AI Jude Yew, et al. 

How do multiple LLM-powered conversational agents assist sensemaking and decision-making in an unfamiliar domain?  Jeongeon Park, et al  

Sensemaking in large graphs Asiyah Ahmad, et al. 

Responsibility Attribution in Human-AI Decision Making: Reevaluating Sensemaking in the Age of AI Collaboration Joe Brailsford, et al. 

From Incantations to Incarnations: Sensemaking with Gen AI in the Design Process J.D. Zamfirescu-Pereira, et al. 

Making Sense of Generative AI Sensefaking: Critical Task Context Attributes for UX Developers to Consider Bonnie E. John, Victoria Bellotti


Session #2:  People making sense (or not)  

Making Sense of Patient-Generated Data: A Data-Frame Perspective on Clinicians’ Work (10) Shriti Raj

Hypothesis Formalization: A (sensemaking) theory of theory of how analysts translate their conceptual research questions and hypotheses into statistical modeling code E. M. Jun, et al.

Beyond Viral Dances: Crisis and Disaster Sensemaking on TikTok Julie A. Vera

Misleading Ourselves: How Disinformation Manipulates Sensemaking Stephen Prochaska, et al. 

Who are the Dataset Practitioners Behind Large Language Model Development? Crystal Qian, et al. 

Sensemaking in Embodied Remembering Nathalie Overdevest, et al. 

Investigate Sensemaking with Information-based Ideation  Andruid Kerne

Information Seeking & Sensemaking in Engineering Education Patricia Verdines

Collective Privacy Sensemaking on Social Media about Period and Fertility Tracking post Roe v. Wade Qiurong Song, et al. 


Session #3:  Tools and XR for sensemaking   

Supporting Orchestration of GenAI in Sensemaking Workflows (10) Srishti Palani, Gonzalo Ramos

Tools and Tasks in Sensemaking: A Visual Accessibility Perspective Yichun Zhao, Miguel A. Nacenta

Hypertext and the Future of Augmented Sensemaking Joel Chan, et al. 

Space to Think as a Common Ground for Human-AI Sensemaking Chris North, et al. 

Making Code Understandable at Scale for Sensemaking in Introductory Programming Education Ashley Zhang, et al. 

Balancing Cognitive Effort and AI Assistance: an AI-assisted Sensemaking Framework for Synchronous Communication Xinyue Chen, Xu Wang

Sensemaking on the Flightdeck: Pilot Monitoring Strategies Dorrit Billman, et al. 

Designing Interaction Approaches for Shared Sensemaking in XR Samir Ghosh, et al. 

KHAIT: K-9 Handler Artificial Intelligence Teaming for Collaborative Sensemaking Matthew Wilchek, et al. 

User Experience Research Play Card in Augmented Reality: A sensemaking case study on designing Visibility Shar Liang, et al. 


Laura Koesten

Koesten is a Postdoc at the University of Vienna (Austria) in the Research Group for Visualization and Data Analysis (Faculty of Computer Science) and an affiliate researcher at King’s College London, UK. Her research explores the characteristics of sensemaking with data in different contexts, such as data discovery, data reuse, and data visualizations. She uses verbal and written summarization techniques to surface sensemaking activities and studies subjective experiences of sensemaking in interactions with datasets and data visualizations. She is PI of the Talking Charts project, which investigates how charts related to climate change and COVID-19 are created and understood by public as well as by scientific audiences.


Daniel M. Russell

I am a traveling scholar. As such I write, lecture, and create materials for teaching.  Sometimes this includes videos, short podcasts, tech reports, sometimes papers for scientific publication, and sometimes books for everyone.  

I'm a practicing scientist.  That means I experiment and I analyze. I do field studies and I try to understand what makes online researchers tick.

Why do they sometimes query Google for [ first ], and then not click on anything? Why do some Google users only ask one query, while others can go on and on? 

This is what drives my work:  How do people make sense of the data they find?  What do people search for?  How do they do it?  How do they understand and use what they've found.  

Aniket Kittur

Niki an Associate Professor and Cooper-Siegel Chair in the Human-Computer Interaction Institute at Carnegie Mellon University. His research explores a future that scales sensemaking beyond the limits of a single individual’s mind by: (1) distributing sensemaking among many people and machines; (2) enabling people to build on the sensemaking that others have already done; and (3) seamlessly integrating human and machine cognition to make sense of large information spaces. He is also a co-founder of DataSquid, a startup that supports sensemaking by bringing the power of intuitive touch and physics to data visualization.

Nitesh Goyal

Nitesh Goyal (Tesh) leads research at the intersection of Safety and AI, in the Responsible AI team of Google Research. His work at Google has led to launch of ML based tools like AI Test Kitchen as a sandbox to upload generative AI applications, MakerSuite as a tool for developers to leverage Google’s generative AI capabilities without coding, Harassment Manager to empower targets of online harassment, and ML based moderation to reduce online toxic content production on platforms like OpenWeb. He also introduced design metaphor of "Sensemaking Translucence" to reduce biased sensemaking in criminal justice while managing interruptions appropriately. His research has been supported by German Govt. Fellowship, National Science Foundation, and MacArthur Genius Grant.

Pengyi Zhang

Dr. Pengyi Zhang is an associate professor at Department of Information Management, Peking University. She holds a Ph.D. and a MLS from College of Information Studies, University of Maryland. Her research expertise include information and knowledge organization, information/data seeking and sensemaking, and user-centered design and evaluation. She is particularly interested in how people seek for and make sense of data and information. Her recent research investigates the how individuals in groups and communities make sense together to negotiate meaning, deal with conflicts, and form consensus. She has received grants from National Science Foundation of China, Chinese Library Association, and OCLC/ALISE Library and Information Science Research Grant.

Michael Xieyang Liu 

Dr. Michael Xieyang Liu is a research scientist at Google in the Pittsburgh office. He recently obtained his PhD from Carnegie-Mellon University with his thesis Tool Support for Knowledge Foraging, Structuring, and Transfer During Online Sensemaking. His work has integrated several different sensemaking tools and systems into a coherent whole, establishing patterns for bridging the gap between rapidly evolving mental models in people’s heads and the externalization of those models. Specifically, he designs and builds interactive systems to reduce the costs and increase the benefits of externalization, thereby capturing more of the cognitive work that users engage in while making sense of information.

Map of the Hawai'i Convention Center  (LINK to overview map)

Room 306A Hawaii Convention Center (Link to Map of room 306A location)   306A is in the lower right of the map.