How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-17 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Callez Ear Cushions — biggest strength: a 10-pack of 58mm foam cushions plus 5 free mic windscreen covers, backed by a 45-day replacement and 12-month warranty, aimed at a long list of named Plantronics, Jabra, Yealink and similar office headsets.
• Callez Ear Cushions — biggest trade-off: compatibility is narrow and model-specific, so if your headset isn't on the list, these are the wrong buy.
• SHUAIGUO Replacement Ear Cushions — biggest strength: a 2-piece set made from protein leather over memory foam, with a comfort and noise-isolation focus and a 90-day manufacturer warranty.
• SHUAIGUO Replacement Ear Cushions — biggest trade-off: it's a single pair with no windscreen covers and no published dimensions, so you get less in the box and must confirm the fit yourself.
• Who each pick is for: Callez for anyone maintaining a fleet of listed office headsets who wants spares on hand; SHUAIGUO for one person refreshing a single pair of headphones who cares most about plush feel.
The Callez set is built around one job: keeping a working office headset alive. You get ten earpads in a single pack, each measuring 58mm (2.28in) across, with a 34mm (1.34in) inner hole, a 21mm (0.83in) outer hole and 14mm (0.55in) of thickness. The material is memory foam. Those numbers matter more than any marketing line here, because a cushion either matches your headset's ear loop or it doesn't. If you measure first, you'll know in seconds whether this is your part.
Compatibility is where this pack earns its keep — and where it demands attention. Callez lists specific models from Plantronics (Supra Plus Encore HW251N, HW261N, HW510, HW520, Blackwire C225, C310, C320, 3210, 3220, 3310, 3320, 3315, 3325), Jabra (PRO 920, 930, 935, 9450, 9460, 9465, 9470, BIZ 620, 1100, 1500, 1900, 2400II, GN 1900, 2000, 2100, 2025, 9120, 9125, UC Voice 550, 750MS, 550A), plus Yealink YHS33, Sennheiser SC 60 USB ML and SC 75, Leitner LH270 and LH275, VXi Blue Parrott B250-XTS, TruVoice HD-500, Cyber Acoustics AC-104 and AC-204, and headsets from AGPTEK, Arama, MAIRDI, Wantek, Callez and VoiceJoy. The brand is explicit that the pads are not for Jabra Evolve 20, 30, 40, 65, 75 or the Evolve2 line.
So who should buy it? Anyone who owns one of those listed headsets and treats cushions as a consumable — call centers, home offices, IT closets, a small team that keeps chewing through foam. Ten pads plus five mic windscreen covers means you can refresh a headset several times over or split the pack across desks. Installation needs no tools: peel the old pad off, push the larger loop of the new one in, then stretch it around the ear loop edge. The 45-day free replacement and 12-month warranty round out the practical side. Who should skip it? Owners of unlisted headsets, especially Evolve-series users, and anyone who only needs one pair and would rather not store nine spares.
The SHUAIGUO set takes the opposite approach. It's a single pair — two pads — built from protein leather wrapped over memory foam, and the entire pitch is about how they feel and how they sound once fitted. Protein leather is the smooth, skin-friendly surface material here, and memory foam underneath is what lets the cushion cradle the ear instead of pressing on it. For someone who wears headphones for hours at a stretch, that combination is the whole point: the pads are designed so long listening sessions stay comfortable rather than turning into a pressure headache.
The second thing SHUAIGUO emphasizes is sound isolation. That's a genuine, physical consequence of replacing worn pads — collapsed, flattened foam lets outside noise in and lets your audio leak out, so a fresh, fuller cushion improves both. The brand also frames the pads as durable and resistant to daily wear, which is the reasonable expectation for protein leather and memory foam used indoors. Installation is the same tool-free routine: remove the originals, fit the new ones, done.
Who should buy it? One person with one headset who wants a plusher, more enclosed feel and a cleaner look, and who doesn't need a stockpile of spares. Who should skip it? Anyone maintaining several headsets — two pads won't cover a team — and anyone who wants mic windscreen covers included, since this set is pads only. It's also worth noting the box is minimal: two ear pads, nothing else, backed by a 90-day manufacturer warranty.
• Best for a fleet or multiple headsets → Callez Ear Cushions. Ten pads in one pack versus two.
• Best for a single headset refresh → SHUAIGUO Replacement Ear Cushions. One pair, no leftover spares to store.
• Best for surface feel and plush comfort → SHUAIGUO. Protein leather over memory foam is the comfort-focused build.
• Best for noise isolation focus → SHUAIGUO. The design is aimed at sealing in sound and keeping external noise out.
• Best for verified fit on a listed office headset → Callez. Published 58mm dimensions and a long, named compatibility list mean you can check before you buy.
• Best for fitting confidence when your model isn't listed → neither, without measuring. Callez warns against buying if your headset isn't on the list; SHUAIGUO publishes no dimensions, so measure your old pads first.
• Best for extras in the box → Callez. Five free mic windscreen covers come along with the pads.
• Best for longer warranty coverage → Callez. 12 months versus SHUAIGUO's 90 days.
• Best for a Plantronics or Jabra office headset → Callez. That's precisely the lineup this pack is built around.
In my opinion, the deciding factor here isn't comfort language — it's whether your headset is on Callez's compatibility list. If it is, I'd buy Callez Ear Cushions: ten pads, five windscreen covers, a 12-month warranty and dimensions you can verify against your headset make it the more practical, lower-risk purchase, especially if you own more than one headset. If your headphones aren't on that list and you simply want one pair of protein-leather memory foam pads for a single set, I'd go with SHUAIGUO Replacement Ear Cushions instead. Measure your old pads first either way — that's the step that prevents a return.
Not necessarily. Callez publishes a specific compatibility list and states it does not fit Jabra Evolve or Evolve2 models. SHUAIGUO doesn't publish a model list or dimensions at all, so you'll need to measure your existing pads and compare.
Callez includes 10 earpads plus 5 free mic windscreen covers. SHUAIGUO includes 2 replacement ear pads and nothing else.
SHUAIGUO is the more comfort-oriented choice on paper, thanks to protein leather over memory foam and a design focused on noise isolation. Callez also uses memory foam and is described as soft and breathable, so it's a solid everyday option too.
I don't list prices here because they change often. Use the "Check latest price on Amazon" button on this page to see the current price for each before you decide.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.