How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want one handled pan that drops straight into a 5-quart or larger air fryer basket and bakes a full batch of English muffin–style egg bites in one go, choose CAKETIME Silicone Muffin Pan; if you need twelve separate flexible cups you can arrange any way you like for single English muffins, mini pizzas and small portions, choose KOLUTI Nonstick Silicone Muffin.
• CAKETIME's biggest trade-off: it's one fixed footprint. All seven cups bake together whether you want one muffin or seven, and it needs a 5-quart or larger air fryer to fit properly.
• KOLUTI's biggest strength: twelve individual 2.8-inch cups with double anti-slip handles, so you can load exactly as many as you need and stack the rest away — genuinely modular for small portions and variety.
• KOLUTI's biggest trade-off: loose cups mean loose logistics. Twelve separate pieces to place, retrieve and wash, and nothing holds them in a single rigid frame.
• Who CAKETIME is for: the batch baker with a bigger air fryer who wants one sturdy, no-fuss pan with a handle.
• Who KOLUTI is for: the small-portion cook who wants flexibility, multiple colors and the option to use just two cups tonight and ten next weekend.
CAKETIME solves a very specific annoyance: getting a silicone mold into and out of a hot air fryer basket without burning your fingers or spilling batter. The design answer is the anti-slip handle paired with a reinforced back, which keeps the pan steadier when you slide it in. That's the detail that separates it from a generic floppy silicone tray.
The footprint is deliberate. At 8.45 inches in diameter it's aimed at an 8.5-inch basket or larger, and CAKETIME states it fits 5-quart or bigger air fryers. Each cup is 2.5 inches across the top and 1.4 inches deep — a real muffin size, not a thimble. Seven of those in one pan is a proper batch: a week of egg bites, a tray of cornbread muffins, frittatas, mini quiches or cupcakes in a single pass. The material is food-grade silicone rated from -104°F to 446°F, so oven, air fryer, microwave, dishwasher, fridge and freezer are all fair game.
Who should buy it: anyone with a 5-quart-plus air fryer who bakes in batches and wants one object to handle rather than twelve. The handle is the whole point — it turns a fiddly job into a one-hand job.
KOLUTI Nonstick Silicone Muffin: Who It's For
KOLUTI takes the opposite approach: instead of one pan, you get a pack of twelve reusable cups, each 2.8 inches inner diameter by 1.4 inches deep, in three colors. The double anti-slip handles on each cup make them easy to carry and move, which matters more than it sounds when you're pulling a hot cup out of an air fryer.
The flexibility is the selling point. Making one English muffin pizza for a snack? Use one cup. Meal-prepping eight egg bites for the week? Use eight and leave four in the drawer. Because they're separate, they stack on the countertop or in a cabinet without eating much space — a genuine advantage over a rigid 8.45-inch pan if your kitchen is tight. They're BPA-free silicone rated up to 460°F and safe in the air fryer, oven, microwave and freezer, though KOLUTI explicitly notes no open flames.
They're not only baking molds, either. KOLUTI positions them for serving jams, snacks, fruit, dipping sauces, butter and ice cream — so they double as small bowls at the table, which is a nice bit of dual-purpose design. Cleaning is hand-wash or dishwasher, and because they're reusable rather than paper, one set keeps working.
Who should buy it: small-portion cooks, single-person households, anyone who wants to bake two muffins without firing up a seven-cup pan, and people who like the idea of using the same cups for serving. Twelve cups also means you can keep a few dedicated to savory egg bites and a few to sweet baking without cross-flavored results.
Who should skip it: anyone who wants one rigid, handled unit to lift in and out in a single motion. With KOLUTI you're placing and retrieving cups individually, and a cup without a surrounding frame can tip if you knock it while loading a crowded basket. If you bake large batches every time, twelve loose cups is more handling than one pan.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for batch baking in one lift → CAKETIME Silicone Muffin Pan — 7 cups in a single handled, reinforced frame.
• Best for baking one or two items → KOLUTI Nonstick Silicone Muffin — use exactly the cups you need and store the rest.
• Best for small air fryers → KOLUTI — individual 2.8-inch cups fit where an 8.45-inch pan won't.
• Best for space-saving storage → KOLUTI — twelve cups stack compactly; a rigid pan doesn't.
• Best for serving at the table → KOLUTI — the cups work for jams, sauces, fruit and ice cream.
• Best for a steady, non-slip grip during loading → CAKETIME — the anti-slip handle and reinforced back are designed for that exact moment.
• Best for color variety → KOLUTI — three colors across the set; CAKETIME is one Confetti pan.
• Best for temperature ceiling → KOLUTI, marginally — rated to 460°F versus CAKETIME's 446°F, both far above normal baking.
In my opinion, the deciding factor isn't the silicone — both are food-grade, nonstick and heat-resistant well past what an air fryer does. It's how you cook. If your air fryer is 5 quarts or bigger and you think in batches, I'd buy the CAKETIME Silicone Muffin Pan: the handle and reinforced back make loading and unloading a full tray of English muffin egg bites a one-hand job, and seven cups at a time is the efficient path.
If your air fryer is small, or you cook for one or two and want the freedom to make a single English muffin pizza without committing to a whole pan, I'd buy the KOLUTI set instead. Twelve cups you can deploy in any number is genuinely more flexible. Check the current price on Amazon before you decide — the button on this page has it.
FAQ
how to air fry english muffins
how to air fry english muffin pizzas
The cup depth matters here. CAKETIME's cups are 1.4 inches deep and 2.5 inches across the top; KOLUTI's are 1.4 inches deep with a 2.8-inch inner diameter. KOLUTI's slightly wider cup gives a bit more surface for sauce, cheese and toppings. Either way, the nonstick silicone means the finished item presses out from the bottom rather than sticking.
how to make air fryer english muffin pizzas
Think of the mold as the vessel, not the recipe. Portion your base into the cup, add toppings, and bake. CAKETIME is the better fit if you're making seven at once for a crowd; KOLUTI is the better fit if you want two or three and no leftovers. Both are dishwasher-friendly, so cleanup after a saucy bake is straightforward.
how long to air fryer english muffin pizzas
I can't give you a time — that depends on your air fryer, your batter and your toppings, not on the mold. What the data sheets do tell you is that both products tolerate far more heat than any air fryer produces: CAKETIME is rated -104°F to 446°F and KOLUTI up to 460°F. Neither will be the limiting factor in your cook.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Fchil Silicone Muffin Pan vs ROOM127 Air Fryer Liners, Eiyisem Silicone Muffin Pan vs SAWNZC 24Pack: Air Fryer, HONGBAKE Nonstick Muffin Pan vs equlup Air Fryer Grill