How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• BYKITCHEN 9 — biggest strength: true 9 x 13 inch precut sheets that drop straight into a quarter sheet pan, rated to 450°F.
• BYKITCHEN 9 — biggest trade-off: 120 sheets per pack, and the 9 x 13 footprint is oversized for small air fryer baskets.
• SMARTAKE 200 — biggest strength: 200 sheets of 8 x 12 inch paper that lay flat instead of curling, and come in a storage box.
• SMARTAKE 200 — biggest trade-off: the smaller 8 x 12 size leaves gaps on a full quarter sheet pan.
• Pick BYKITCHEN 9 if you bake sourdough, sheet-pan dinners and roasted vegetables on standard pans.
• Pick SMARTAKE 200 if you want sheer quantity for air fryer bread, cookies, pizza and quick weeknight trays.
BYKITCHEN's whole pitch is fit. These sheets are precut to 9 x 13 inches, which is the exact footprint of a quarter sheet pan and a close match for most standard baking pans. That means no measuring, no scissors, no ragged edges. You pull one sheet, drop it in, and you're done. For anyone who bakes often, that small ritual matters more than it sounds — it's the difference between starting a batch of cookies in ten seconds and wrestling with a roll of paper that keeps springing back.
The material story is solid too. It's unbleached, food-grade wood pulp with a silicone coating, so it's non-stick, waterproof and greaseproof. Heat resistance goes up to 450°F, and BYKITCHEN lists compatibility with ovens, microwaves, toaster ovens and air fryers. Cleanup is the real payoff: grease, crumbs and sticky residue stay on the paper, not on your pan. The multi-purpose angle is broader than baking — wrapping sandwiches, separating frozen burger patties, lining a tray for roasted veggies or a sheet-pan dinner.
The pack is 120 sheets of 9 x 13 inch paper in a natural, rectangular format. Here's who should skip it: if your air fryer basket is small, a 9 x 13 sheet is simply too big and you'll be folding and cutting, which defeats the purpose. And if you go through paper fast, 120 sheets won't last as long as a 200-count pack. In my opinion, BYKITCHEN 9 is the pick for the sheet-pan baker who wants the paper to fit the pan on the first try.
SMARTAKE attacks the same problem from the opposite direction: volume and flatness. You get 200 precut sheets at 8 x 12 inches, made from natural wood pulp with a silicone oil coating. The stated goal is to end the curly-roll problem — these sheets lay flat on the tray instead of rolling up on you. That's a genuinely practical detail, because a sheet that curls at the corners is the single most annoying thing about parchment in a hot air fryer or a small toaster oven.
The spec sheet is straightforward. Food grade, non-toxic, withstands up to 450°F, and suitable for baking, grilling, frying and steaming. SMARTAKE names cookies, bread, meat and pizza as the usual suspects. The silicone coating makes the surface smooth and waterproof, so food slides off and keeps its shape, and the whole sheet is disposable — you toss it and the tray stays clean. There's also a rectangular packing box included, which is a small but real plus if you've ever had loose parchment sheets fanning out all over a cabinet shelf.
The trade-off is size. At 8 x 12 inches, these sheets won't cover a full quarter sheet pan edge to edge, so for big batches of cookies or a full sheet-pan dinner you'll either use two sheets or accept bare corners. The sheet count is 200, and the unit count is listed as 1 box, so it's one box of 200 sheets rather than 200 individually packed items. Who should skip it: bakers who want one sheet to fit one standard pan exactly, and anyone who regularly roasts on larger trays. Otherwise, in my opinion, this is the better everyday workhorse for air fryer bread and small-batch cooking.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best fit for a quarter sheet pan → BYKITCHEN 9. 9 x 13 inches is purpose-built for that pan size.
• Best sheet count for the money-conscious bulk buyer → SMARTAKE 200. 200 sheets versus 120.
• Best for small air fryer baskets → SMARTAKE 200. The 8 x 12 size is far easier to fit without folding.
• Best for large-batch baking and roasting → BYKITCHEN 9. The wider sheet covers more of a standard pan.
• Best for flat, curl-free handling → SMARTAKE 200. The sheets are described as laying flat rather than curling.
• Best for organized storage → SMARTAKE 200. It ships with a rectangular packing box.
• Best for freezer and food-wrapping tasks → BYKITCHEN 9. Its feature list includes wrapping sandwiches and freezing burger patties.
• Both share the same heat ceiling → 450°F, so neither has an edge for high-temperature roasting.
I'd buy the SMARTAKE 200. Here's my reasoning: most people reaching for parchment in 2026 are doing small, fast jobs — air fryer bread, a handful of cookies, a quick tray of vegetables — and 200 flat 8 x 12 sheets handle that routine better than 120 larger ones. The storage box is a nice touch and the higher sheet count means fewer reorders. That said, if your kitchen revolves around a quarter sheet pan and you hate trimming paper to fit, I'd go the other way and take the BYKITCHEN 9, because a sheet that fits on the first try is worth more than a bigger stack. Check the current price on Amazon for both before you commit, since that's the one variable I can't weigh in for you.
how to air fryer bread
Line your air fryer basket or tray with a precut sheet — either the SMARTAKE 200 at 8 x 12 inches or a trimmed BYKITCHEN 9 — so crumbs and grease stay off the basket. Both papers are rated to 450°F, which covers typical air fryer bread temperatures. Keep the paper weighted down with the food so it doesn't lift into the heating element.
how to air fryer breaded chicken
Breaded chicken releases fat and loose coating, which is exactly the mess parchment is designed to catch. Use a flat sheet on the tray so the coating doesn't stick, and discard it afterward instead of scrubbing. The silicone coating on both products is there to help food release cleanly and hold its shape.
how to air fryer breaded chicken breast
Because a full breast takes up real space, sheet size matters here. The SMARTAKE 200's 8 x 12 inch sheets suit compact air fryer trays, while the BYKITCHEN 9's 9 x 13 sheets fit larger pans and can be trimmed down. Either way, both are food-grade, waterproof and rated to 450°F.
how to air fryer breaded fish
Breaded fish is delicate, so a non-stick surface keeps fillets intact when you flip them. Both papers use a silicone coating for easy release, and both are disposable, so you can lift the sheet out with the residue instead of washing the tray. Use a sheet sized to your basket — 8 x 12 for small fryers, 9 x 13 trimmed for larger ones.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SMARTAKE 8 vs MiKapana Air Fryer Liners: Air Fryer Cinnamon, Generic Air Fryer Toaster vs SENECESLI Fryer Accessories Set, katbite 200Pcs vs SATONBEYI 1Pcs: Air Fryer Bacon