How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
These two products sit in completely different aisles of the air fryer world. One is a consumable that keeps your existing basket clean. The other is a hard part that replaces what's already inside your oven. Buyers get them confused because both mention "Power XL" and both are accessories. That's where the overlap ends.
• BYKITCHEN 200PCS — biggest strength: 200 disposable 10x10 inch parchment liners that fit 8–12 QT air fryers, including Power XL 8 QT, so cleanup becomes "lift and toss."
• BYKITCHEN 200PCS — biggest trade-off: It's disposable paper. You'll rebuy it, and it must be weighted down at all four corners or it can lift into the heating element.
• Allstare B-AFO-002G-1 — biggest strength: A 304 stainless steel crisper basket plus crumb tray built for PowerXL B-AFO-002 / B-AFO-002G / B-AFO-002G-1 toaster ovens, with an open mesh design that lets air circulate for crisp results.
• Allstare B-AFO-002G-1 — biggest trade-off: It is model-specific. If your oven's model number doesn't match, it isn't the right part, and the listing itself warns against ordering by appearance.
• Who each is for: BYKITCHEN for anyone who hates scrubbing a big basket after every batch of wings or fries. Allstare for someone whose PowerXL tray is rusted, warped, lost, or worn out.
BYKITCHEN solves one problem extremely well: the greasy basket. Each liner is a 10x10 inch square made from natural wood pulp coated on both sides with food-grade silicone oil. That coating is what makes it waterproof, oil-proof, nonstick and tear-resistant, and it's rated heat-safe up to 450°F / 232°C. Practical result: sauce, crumbs and rendered fat stay on the paper, and you lift the whole mess out and throw it away. No soaking. No scouring pad.
The size is the other selling point. At 10 inches square, the liners are aimed squarely at the 8–12 QT class — the sheet lists Chefman 8/10/12 QT, Power XL Air Fryer 8 QT, Instant Pot 10 QT Airfryer Oven and other 8–12 QT units. If you cook in a large single-basket air fryer and you're feeding two to four people, that footprint covers most of the basket floor. The liners are also listed as usable in ovens, microwaves and steamers, so a pack does double duty beyond the air fryer. With 200 sheets in the pack, it's a bulk consumable — the kind of thing you keep in a drawer and stop thinking about for a long while.
Who should buy it: busy home cooks, meal-preppers, and anyone who uses their air fryer several times a week and resents the cleanup more than the cooking. It's also a genuinely practical gift for a household that just got a big air fryer.
Who should skip it: anyone who wants a permanent part rather than a consumable, and anyone whose air fryer basket is much smaller than 8 QT — a 10-inch square will be oversized. Also skip it if you won't follow the manufacturer's own guidance: cover at least two-thirds of the liner with food and weigh down all four corners so the paper doesn't lift into the heating element. That isn't optional advice. It's how the product is designed to be used safely.
The Allstare set is the opposite kind of purchase: a repair, not a routine. You get two pieces — a crisper basket at 12.6"L x 10"W x 1.4"H and a drip tray roughly 12.5 inches long, both in food-grade 304 stainless steel. It's a replacement for PowerXL air fryer toaster oven models B-AFO-002, B-AFO-002G and B-AFO-002G-1.
The material story matters here. 304 stainless is chosen specifically because it resists rust and deformation and handles high heat without melting or bending — the sheet explicitly contrasts it with lesser materials that corrode or warp. For a part that sits inches from a heating element and gets hit with grease and moisture, that's the right call. The basket's open mesh design is functional, not decorative: air moves around the food instead of being blocked, which is what actually produces a crispy exterior. The drip tray underneath catches crumbs and oil that fall during cooking, keeping the food from sitting in rendered fat and making cleanup easier.
Cleaning is straightforward. Regular maintenance is a hot-water and dish soap soak, then a wipe, with a scouring pad for stubborn spots. The care instructions also list it as dishwasher safe, so you have both options.
Who should buy it: owners of a PowerXL B-AFO-002 series toaster oven whose original basket or crumb tray is rusted, bent, stained beyond cleaning, or simply missing. Also anyone who bought a used unit and needs the internals.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for near-zero cleanup → BYKITCHEN 200PCS. Lift the liner, toss it, done.
• Best for replacing a worn or missing part → Allstare B-AFO-002G-1. It's a hard part, not a consumable.
• Best for large 8–12 QT basket air fryers → BYKITCHEN 200PCS. 10x10 inches is sized for that class.
• Best for PowerXL toaster oven owners → Allstare B-AFO-002G-1. Built for B-AFO-002 / B-AFO-002G / B-AFO-002G-1.
• Best for long-term durability → Allstare B-AFO-002G-1. 304 stainless resists rust, heat and warping.
• Best for crispiness from airflow → Allstare B-AFO-002G-1. The open mesh lets hot air circulate around the food.
• Best for bulk convenience → BYKITCHEN 200PCS. 200 sheets means you're not reordering constantly.
• Best for low-maintenance habits → BYKITCHEN 200PCS, with the caveat that you must weigh down all four corners and cover two-thirds of the liner with food.
In my opinion, these aren't competitors — they're answers to two different questions. If your problem is "I hate cleaning my big air fryer," I'd buy the BYKITCHEN 200PCS. It removes the worst part of air frying and 200 sheets go a long way. If your problem is "my PowerXL tray is shot," I'd buy the Allstare B-AFO-002G-1, because no amount of parchment fixes a rusted or missing basket. Buy the one that matches your actual problem, and check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
how to use power xl air fryer
Load food into the basket, set your temperature and time, and let the unit circulate hot air around it. If you're using the Allstare basket, its open mesh design is what allows that airflow to crisp the food. If you're using BYKITCHEN liners, cover at least two-thirds of the liner with food and weigh down all four corners so the paper can't lift into the heating element.
how to clean power xl air fryer
For the BYKITCHEN route, you don't really clean the basket — you lift out the used liner and throw it away, which is the whole point. For the Allstare stainless parts, soak in hot water with dish soap, wipe away loosened residue, and use a scouring pad for tougher marks; the tray is also listed as dishwasher safe. Either way, letting grease cool before handling makes the job easier.
how to preheat power xl air fryer
Run the empty unit at your target temperature for a few minutes before adding food. If you're using BYKITCHEN liners, don't put an empty liner in during preheat — paper needs food weight on it to stay down. Add the liner and food together once preheating is done.
how to start power xl air fryer
Plug in the unit, place your basket or tray inside, add food, then set time and temperature and start the cycle. On the Allstare side, confirm you have the correct model first — the B-AFO-002G-1 fits B-AFO-002, B-AFO-002G and B-AFO-002G-1 ovens, and a mismatched tray won't seat properly.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.