If you want drop protection, a clip-on keychain and a cleaning pen for your JBL Tune 230NC charging case, choose BOVUGAC TPU Case Compatible; if you need a soft, secure silicone seal that keeps an earbud stable and comfortable when you lie on your side, choose NANLANFAN Replacement Silicone Ear. These two accessories are not really rivals — one guards the case, the other fixes the fit. But they land in the same shopping session often enough that picking the wrong one wastes a purchase.
BOVUGAC TPU Case Compatible vs NANLANFAN Replacement Silicone Ear at a Glance
• BOVUGAC TPU Case Compatible — biggest trade-off: it protects the charging case and nothing else. It is listed as not water resistant, and it will not fit any other earbud model.
• NANLANFAN Replacement Silicone Ear — biggest strength: six pairs of ultra-light silicone tips in small, medium and large that restore grip, comfort and passive noise blocking on JBL Endurance-series buds.
• NANLANFAN Replacement Silicone Ear — biggest trade-off: these are consumable replacement parts, not protection. No case, no keychain, and they only fit the Endurance Peak 3 / Peak II / Peak / Run 2 / Race family.
• Who each pick is for: BOVUGAC suits a Tune 230NC owner who carries the case in a bag or backpack; NANLANFAN suits an Endurance owner whose tips have worn, torn, hardened or gone missing.
This is a single-purpose accessory done properly. The shell is molded for the JBL Tune 230NC TWS specifically — not a universal sleeve that happens to stretch — and the material is thermoplastic polyurethane with a soft, skin-friendly, silky feel in the hand. That softness matters more than it sounds. A hard plastic shell transfers impact straight into whatever it's protecting; a TPU cover absorbs scratches, accidental drops, shocks and bumps while staying slim enough that the case still slides into a jacket pocket.
The bundle is where it earns its place. You get the cover, a carabiner keychain, a lanyard and a cleaning pen. The keychain is the practical bit: clip the case to a handbag strap or a backpack and it stops migrating to the bottom of your bag, which is how earbuds cases usually get lost or crushed. The cleaning pen is the underrated item — earwax and lint in the mesh and in the charging pins are a common reason buds stop seating properly, and having a small tool attached to the case means you actually use it.
Buy it if you own the Tune 230NC TWS and the case lives in a bag, a backpack or a gym tote. Skip it if you own any other model, because it is explicitly built for that one device. Skip it too if you expect weather protection — it is listed as not water resistant, so it is a bump-and-scratch guard, not a rain cover. And if your complaint is that your earbuds feel loose or uncomfortable in your ears, this product will not change that at all. Note that the earbuds themselves are not included; this is the cover and accessories only.
How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
NANLANFAN Replacement Silicone Ear: Who It's For
This is the fix for the part of an earbud that wears out first. Silicone tips harden, stretch, tear at the seam or simply vanish — and a bud with a bad tip sounds thin, feels loose and leaks noise both ways. NANLANFAN's set is high-quality soft silicone with an ultra-light weight, designed to sit securely so the tips don't work their way out mid-session. Lighter tips also mean less weight pulling on the nozzle, which keeps the bud balanced rather than top-heavy.
The sizing is the real feature. You get six pairs across small, medium and large in black, so you can find the size that actually seals your ear canal instead of accepting whatever came in the box. A proper seal is what delivers the noise blocking these are built for — it's passive isolation from the silicone itself, not electronic cancellation, so fit is everything.
Here's the honest trade-off: compatibility is narrow. These fit JBL Endurance Peak 3, Peak II, Peak, Run 2 and Race TWS earbuds — not the Tune 230NC, and not other brands. They are also a wear item, so buying them is routine maintenance rather than an upgrade. Buy them if your Endurance buds feel loose, sound dull, or you've lost a tip and the set is now unusable. Skip them if you're chasing a case, a keychain or any kind of drop protection — there's none of that here. And if you're hunting the best lightweight wireless headphones for side sleepers, understand that a tip change is the cheapest way to test whether your current buds can work in bed before you replace the headphones themselves.
• You own JBL Tune 230NC TWS → BOVUGAC TPU Case Compatible. The NANLANFAN tips are not made for that model.
• You own JBL Endurance Peak 3, Peak II, Peak, Run 2 or Race → NANLANFAN Replacement Silicone Ear. The BOVUGAC cover is sized for a different case entirely.
• Best for side-sleeping comfort → NANLANFAN. A soft tip in the right size is what stops an earbud from pressing, slipping or aching when your ear is against a pillow.
• Best for travel and bag carry → BOVUGAC. The carabiner and lanyard are genuinely useful, and the slim TPU shell keeps the case from getting scuffed.
• Best for passive noise blocking → NANLANFAN. Silicone seals the canal; a case does nothing for sound.
• Best for keeping the kit hygienic → BOVUGAC. The included cleaning pen is the difference between a case you maintain and one you forget about.
• Best fix for a loose, falling-out earbud → NANLANFAN. Grip and seal are exactly what the specs promise.
• If you need water resistance → neither. BOVUGAC is listed as not water resistant, and the NANLANFAN set is ear tips only, so keep both away from soaking conditions.
A quick clarification for anyone who arrived while shopping for the best rechargeable open ear earbuds for side sleepers: both items here are accessories, not headphones. They assume you already own a JBL pair and want to protect it or restore its fit.
In my opinion, if you're shopping with side sleeping in mind, NANLANFAN Replacement Silicone Ear is the one I'd buy. Comfort in bed comes down to the interface between the bud and your ear canal, and a fresh soft silicone tip in the correct size is the only thing in this comparison that changes it. BOVUGAC is the better buy for a different person: someone who already likes how their Tune 230NC fits and just wants the case to survive a backpack. Neither is expensive enough to agonize over, so check the current price on Amazon and match the accessory to the earbuds you actually own — that's the decision that matters, not the branding.
No. BOVUGAC is molded for the JBL Tune 230NC TWS only. NANLANFAN fits the JBL Endurance Peak 3, Peak II, Peak, Run 2 and Race TWS. Check your model before ordering — this is the single most common way to get it wrong.
The cover is listed as not water resistant. It's designed for scratches, drops, shocks and bumps, so treat it as impact protection rather than weather protection and keep the case out of wet bags and puddles.
Yes — six pairs in small, medium and large, in black. Start with the size closest to your current tips, then try one step up if the seal feels weak or one step down if your ear feels pressured.
The tips. A soft, correctly sized silicone tip spreads pressure and holds the bud steady against a pillow, which is what side sleepers struggle with most. A case has no effect on in-ear comfort — it only protects the charging case while it's stored.
• STUPIDYIN Headset V5.4 vs TANGZU Shangguan Wan'er II
• TOPOINT Sleep Mask vs HomeSpot Work Headphones
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.