How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want serious active noise cancellation and wireless freedom for commuting, flights or deep-focus work, choose Bose QuietComfort 35; if you need a lightweight, foldable wired headset for a kid, a teen or a school bag, choose ELECDER i45. These two look like they belong in the same conversation because both are headphones — but that's where the overlap ends. One is a premium over-ear wireless model with active noise cancellation and app-based controls. The other is a compact on-ear wired headset built for everyday listening on a budget-friendly scale. Here's how I'd split them.
• Bose QuietComfort 35 — biggest strength: Active Noise Cancellation with three adjustable levels, plus wireless Bluetooth/NFC pairing and a 20-hour battery. It's built to erase the world around you.
• Bose QuietComfort 35 — biggest trade-off: It's a Certified Refurbished unit, so it ships with a 90-day limited warranty and may arrive in a generic box. You're buying renewed, not new.
• ELECDER i45 — biggest strength: A foldable, lightweight on-ear wired design with a 1.5M cord and a 40mm driver — plug-and-play on almost anything with a 3.5mm jack, no charging required.
• ELECDER i45 — biggest trade-off: No Bluetooth, no active noise cancellation, and no inline volume control. You adjust volume on the device, and it's aimed at kids and teens.
• Pick Bose QuietComfort 35 if you fly, commute or work in noisy spaces and want wireless freedom.
• Pick ELECDER i45 if you want a simple, durable wired pair for a child, a student or a spare set that never needs charging.
The QuietComfort 35 is the one you reach for when noise is the problem. Bose's active noise cancellation is the headline feature, and it's adjustable across three settings via the Action button or the Bose Connect app — so you can dial it down when you still need to hear a gate announcement and crank it up when you want pure quiet. The plush ear cushions use synthetic protein leather, and the earcups are over-ear and rounded, which is the design that tends to feel least intrusive over long stretches.
Who should buy it: frequent flyers, commuters, open-plan-office workers, and anyone who wants wireless listening plus real noise cancellation. Who should skip it: someone who wants a brand-new sealed product — this is a Certified Refurbished Series I unit with a 90-day limited warranty, so if that matters to you, look elsewhere. And if you mostly need a cheap wired set for a kid, this is overkill.
ELECDER i45: Who It's For
The ELECDER i45 is a different animal entirely, and it's honest about it. This is a wired on-ear headset with a fixed 1.5M cord and a 3.5mm jack — no pairing, no charging, no app. You plug it in and it works. Inside is a 40mm dynamic driver covering the same 20Hz–20,000Hz range, tuned for moderate bass and a crisp midrange with some passive sound isolation to soften background noise. It's not going to challenge a noise-cancelling flagship, but that's not the brief.
The design is all about portability and fit. The ear cushions and headband are padded and ultra-soft, the size slider adjusts to different head sizes, and the whole thing folds down to roughly 6 x 4.53 x 2.87 inches — small enough to drop in a backpack or a carry-on. ELECDER positions it for kids and teens around 7–8 years and up, though the adjustable headband means adults can wear it too. There's a push-button media control, but note that volume is handled on your device, not on the cord. It works with smartphones, Chromebooks, laptops, PCs, Kindle, MP3 players, tablets and airplane seat jacks.
Who should buy it: parents buying for a school-age kid or teen, students who want a cheap knockaround pair, and anyone who wants a wired backup that never runs out of battery. Who should skip it: anyone who needs wireless, active noise cancellation, or inline volume buttons. Also, if you're on an iPhone 7 or newer iPad, you'll need a Lightning-to-3.5mm adapter that isn't included.
• Best for noise cancellation → Bose QuietComfort 35. It's the only one of the two with Active Noise Cancellation, and it's adjustable across three levels.
• Best for wireless freedom → Bose QuietComfort 35. Bluetooth and NFC pairing, 10-meter range, 20-hour battery.
• Best for long-haul travel → Bose QuietComfort 35. Over-ear cushions, a hard-shell case and an airline adapter are all in the box.
• Best for kids and teens → ELECDER i45. Lightweight, foldable, wired, and sized for younger heads.
• Best for "never think about charging" → ELECDER i45. It's wired, so battery life is simply not a factor.
• Best for school and classroom use → ELECDER i45. A 3.5mm jack works with Chromebooks, laptops and tablets without pairing headaches.
• Best for multi-device desk setups → ELECDER i45. Plug into a PC, tablet or Kindle and go; no Bluetooth juggling.
• Best for a premium listening experience → Bose QuietComfort 35. Volume-optimized EQ and Bose's cancellation tech put it in a different class.
• Best for a no-fuss spare pair → ELECDER i45. Foldable, cheap to replace, and always ready.
If I had to pick one for myself, I'd take the Bose QuietComfort 35. In my opinion, active noise cancellation plus wireless freedom plus a 20-hour battery is the combination that actually changes how you use headphones day to day — on a plane, on a train, in a loud office. The catch is that it's a Certified Refurbished unit with a 90-day warranty, so I'd only go this route if renewed gear doesn't bother you. If it does, or if the buyer is a kid who just needs something wired and durable, the ELECDER i45 is the smarter call — it's simple, foldable and never needs charging. Different tools, different jobs.
For noise cancellation and wireless use, yes — the Bose has Active Noise Cancellation, Bluetooth/NFC and a 20-hour battery. For a simple wired pair for a kid, the ELECDER i45 is the more sensible pick. It depends entirely on your use case, not on which is "better" in the abstract.
No. It relies on passive sound isolation from the padded on-ear cushions, which reduces some background noise but is not active noise cancellation. If you need real ANC, the Bose QuietComfort 35 is the one to look at.
Adults can wear it — the headband is adjustable for different head sizes. ELECDER recommends it for kids over 8, but the fit isn't child-exclusive. Just remember volume is adjusted on your device, since there are no inline volume buttons.
I don't publish prices here since they change often — check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page. In my opinion, "value" depends on what you need: the Bose earns its keep through noise cancellation and wireless convenience, while the ELECDER i45 is the budget-friendly choice for wired, kid-friendly listening.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: EKSA USB Gaming Headset vs Nacon RIG 600, Skullcandy Hesh ANC vs Godyse Earbuds: Wireless Noise, Audio-Technica ATH-S120C-LV vs Wisoqu Earbuds 3.5mm, FZONE P4 vs KLIM Journey