How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Blaihild Air Fryer Magnetic — biggest strength: two magnetic sheets covering over 100 foods, grouped by category, sized to live right where you cook.
• Blaihild Air Fryer Magnetic — biggest trade-off: it's plastic and it's a reference tool, not a showpiece — nothing about it is meant to be looked at when you're not cooking.
• Generic Made — biggest strength: a 16" x 12" aluminum sign with a scratch-resistant, waterproof, fade/rust/corrosion-resistant coating that's built for long-term indoor and outdoor display.
• Generic Made — biggest trade-off: it's a single fixed-size wall sign with pre-drilled corner holes — you hang it, you don't move it around the kitchen with you.
• Who Blaihild is for: home cooks who want fast temperature and timing lookups within arm's reach of the air fryer.
• Who Generic Made is for: people who want a retro-style air fryer conversion chart as permanent kitchen decor, or as a gift for someone who collects that kind of thing.
This is a reference tool first and a decoration never. You get a 2-pack: a large sheet at roughly 10.6 x 6.7 inches and a small one at roughly 5.1 x 5.1 inches, both with strong magnetic backing. The idea is that one lives on the refrigerator or microwave and the other sits on the fryer hood or right next to your prep area, so a look-up never means walking across the kitchen or pulling out your phone with wet hands.
The content is the point. The sheets list cooking time, temperature and food size guidance for over 100 foods, sorted into groups like vegetables, frozen foods, beef, chicken and seafood. That categorization matters more than it sounds. When you're mid-prep with a basket already loaded, you don't want to scan an alphabetical wall of text — you want to jump to "frozen foods" and find your answer. Large bold text helps you read settings from an angle, which is exactly how you read a magnet stuck to a hood while standing at the counter.
The material is plastic, and the whole thing weighs about 4.7 ounces. That's a deliberate trade: light and cheap to produce, easy to reposition, but not something that will survive being treated like a metal sign. It's also a two-piece set, which is the real reason I'd pick it — one chart near the prep area and one near the fryer covers the two moments you actually need a reference.
Generic Made: Who It's For
This is the opposite product wearing the same label. It's a 16 x 12 inch rectangular metal sign made from aluminum, 0.04 inches thick and weighing about 10.4 ounces, printed with an air fryer conversion chart in a vintage poster style. It's manufactured in the United States and finished with a coating the maker describes as scratch resistant, waterproof and resistant to fading, rust and corrosion — which is what lets it sit indoors or outdoors, all weather, without degrading.
Installation is deliberately simple: four pre-drilled holes at the corners, so it hangs straight on a wall with no extra hardware or fuss. The retro art-deco look is aimed at a specific buyer — someone decorating a kitchen, game room, garage, bar or den, or buying a themed gift for a decorator or collector. The manufacturer also offers personalized customization of the pattern, text and style on request, which is unusual for this category and opens up options like a housewarming or hobby gift with custom wording.
Here's the honest trade-off: it's decor that happens to carry cooking information, not a working reference you carry around. You hang it where you want it and you read it from there. It's also a fixed large size — 16 by 12 inches is a statement piece, not a discreet magnet. Buy it if you want a durable, weatherproof air fryer conversion chart that earns its wall space and stays readable for years. Skip it if you need quick at-a-glance lookups right at the fryer, or if your kitchen has no wall space you're willing to give up.
• Best for on-the-spot lookups while cooking → Blaihild Air Fryer Magnetic. Two magnets mean one chart can sit within arm's reach of the fryer, not across the room.
• Best for durability and long-term display → Generic Made. Aluminum with a scratch-resistant, waterproof, fade/rust/corrosion-resistant coating beats plastic for anything permanent.
• Best for organized, fast reference → Blaihild Air Fryer Magnetic. Over 100 foods sorted into vegetables, frozen foods, beef, chicken, seafood and more.
• Best for indoor and outdoor placement → Generic Made. The coating is explicitly built for all-weather use; plastic magnets are a kitchen-counter item.
• Best for small kitchens or rentals → Blaihild Air Fryer Magnetic. Nothing to drill, nothing to mount, and it repositions in a second.
• Best as a gift or decor piece → Generic Made. The retro poster look, the 16 x 12 inch footprint and the custom personalization option suit gifting far better.
• Best for batch cooking and weeknight meal prep → Blaihild Air Fryer Magnetic. The categorized layout speeds up repeated lookups when you're cooking several things in a row.
• Best for a themed room, garage or bar → Generic Made. Its listed use cases include garages, bars and dens — places a fridge magnet wouldn't fit.
In my opinion, if you're buying this for yourself because you actually cook with an air fryer, get the Blaihild Air Fryer Magnetic set. Two magnets, one at the prep area and one at the fryer, is the setup that solves the real problem — not remembering whether frozen wings want a different temperature than fresh ones. The Generic Made sign is the better-made object by a wide margin, and I'd recommend it without hesitation if the goal is a permanent, weatherproof, good-looking chart on the wall or a gift for someone who decorates with this style. It's just a different job. Check the current price on Amazon before you decide, since that's the one thing that could tip a close call either way.
FAQ
Nothing in the product details claims either. It's described as plastic for everyday kitchen use with a magnetic backing, so keep it on the fridge, microwave or fryer hood and wipe it clean rather than soaking it.
For daily cooking, I'd pick the Blaihild 2-pack, because having a chart physically next to the fryer and another at the prep area is faster than walking to a wall sign. The Generic Made sign is the better choice if you want one durable, permanent chart instead of two movable ones.
The product details say personalized customization is supported for pattern, text and style, arranged through the seller's customer service. If you want specific foods or wording on it, ask before ordering.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: DIRBAK Magnetic Cooking Guide vs Generic Air Fryer Prep, Generic Upgrade Loaf Pan vs VZZNN 300: Air Fryer Banana, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement vs TZARROT Air Fryer Magnetic