Interaction of Education and Innovation Policies in Space (Job market paper)
Abstract: Governments invest heavily in regional development through provision of public goods or place-based policies, yet the agencies that design these investments rarely coordinate. The lack of coordination can lead to spatial misallocation where subsidies flow to regions that lack the skilled workers to be employed in incentivized activities, or universities produce graduates in places with few high-skill jobs. I investigate how much this coordination failure matters for aggregate production and income inequality in Turkey. First, I evaluate two government policies that are closely related but implemented by two separate government agencies: (i) university expansion reform that increased access to higher education (new university locations were advised by the Higher Education Council), and (ii) the R&D support given to Turkish firms that reduced the cost of hiring high-skill workers (implemented by the Ministry of Industry). Results show that both government policies achieve their separate goals but there is significant spatial mismatch. I also find that the effect of each policy is larger when the other is present, suggesting a strong complementarity. I examine the interaction of these policies in the presence of productivity spillovers with a spatial equilibrium model with migration for education and work. I find that coordinated policy scenarios result in an increase of 0.5-5% gain in aggregate output, or a decline of 4-8% in regional inequality compared to the current allocation, depending on the policy objective.
R&D Centers, Innovation and Productivity
Abstract: I investigate the effects of an R&D support law using rich administrative data on patenting, tax returns and balance sheets from Turkey. Leveraging subsequent changes to eligibility requirements in 2016 in fuzzy regression discontinuity, difference-in-discontinuities and difference-in-differences designs, I estimate the causal effect of R&D subsidies on patenting and firm performance. I examine spatial distribution of subsidized firms and discuss regional spillovers of the R&D support using geographical variation in the pre-policy change eligibility intensity. This study yields several significant insights on firm level R&D and innovation in Turkey: (i) relaxing eligibility requirements increase R&D support take-up significantly; (ii) for the full firm size distribution, R&D tax relief has positive and statistically significant effects on innovation and R&D expenditures; (iii) the effects are more pronounced for larger R&D operations; (iv) spatial analysis reveals that R&D support recipients are geographically concentrated, forming multiple innovation clusters in Turkey, and (v) there is suggestive evidence on regional knowledge spillovers in districts with high intensity of treated firms.
Within and Between Firm Responses to R&D IncentivesÂ
Abstract: How firms and workers adjust to public policy and other shocks is a question that interests multiple branches of economics. Firms' response can be in terms of reallocation of capital or labor in intensive and extensive margins. First, I investigate whether Turkish firms respond to R&D support through new establishment openings and reallocating high-skill labor across establishments to become eligible for R&D tax rebates. I exploit a policy shock that decreased the minimum employment requirement from 50 to 15 R&D workers, which increased the number of firms eligible for government support. I use this identifying variation to measure the changes in the composition of establishments within a firm using administrative micro data. This within-firm response can be more salient in settings with R&D, as firms enjoy knowledge spillovers from being geographically close to other innovative firms and may choose to locate their R&D-intensive activities in innovation clusters. In the second part of the paper, I examine spillovers in the supplier-buyer network of subsidized firms using firm-to-firm transaction data available for more than 3 million Turkish firms.