How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter — biggest strength: An ultra-fine stainless steel mesh that catches grease splatter before it reaches the heater, keeping the element clean and reducing smoke. Comes as a 2-pack.
• BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter — biggest trade-off: It's a protective shield, not a cooking surface. It won't give you grill marks or replace a worn-out grate.
• GLOWYE Grill Grate — biggest strength: A heavy-duty cast iron cooking surface with a non-stick ceramic coating that produces real grill marks and even heat across a large area.
• GLOWYE Grill Grate — biggest trade-off: It's a single, heavy cast iron piece that needs seasoning and careful handling, and it's a replacement part rather than a protective accessory.
• Who each pick is for: Buy BBQ-PLUS if your priority is keeping the inside of your Foodi clean and smoke-free. Buy GLOWYE if your priority is the food itself — steaks, chicken, veggies with proper sear.
The BBQ-PLUS splatter shield is a purpose-built replacement part for the Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill line — specifically the FG551, FG550, BG500A and DG551, plus a broader compatibility list that includes the IG600, IG601, IG651 and the AG300-series air fryers. Each shield measures 7.6" x 7.6", and you get two in the pack, so you have a spare on hand the moment one is in the wash.
What it actually does is simple and useful: the ultra-fine mesh sits over the heater and traps the grease that flies off fatty foods. That keeps the heating element cleaner, which in turn means less smoke billowing out of the unit and a longer working life for the heater itself. If you've ever finished a batch of burgers and dreaded the scrub-down afterward, this is the accessory that quietly spares you that job.
Who should buy it: Anyone cooking greasy food in a compatible Ninja Foodi who's tired of scrubbing the heater and dealing with smoke. Who should skip it: Anyone whose existing grate is damaged or who wants a better searing surface — this shield won't fix either of those problems.
GLOWYE Grill Grate: Who It's For
The GLOWYE Grill Grate is a different animal entirely. It's a cast iron replacement grate and griddle pan for the Ninja Foodi Smart XL Indoor 6-in-1 (FG550, FG551, DG551), measuring 13.36" x 9.1" x 2.63". That's a substantial cooking footprint — enough to lay out several steaks, a batch of chicken, or a full tray of vegetables at once instead of cooking in cramped rounds.
The core of it is heavy-duty cast iron with a ceramic non-stick coating. Cast iron is the reason this thing can hold heat and distribute it evenly, which is what gives you proper grill marks on a steak and avoids the hot spots that leave one piece of chicken charred while its neighbor is still pink. The ceramic coating on top handles the release, so food lifts away cleanly rather than tearing. There's also a handle built in for pulling the grate out of the basket without tongs gymnastics.
The trade-off is that cast iron asks something of you. GLOWYE's own guidance is to heat the grate first, add plenty of oil, wait for it to smoke, and season the plate before use so food doesn't stick. That's normal cast iron behavior, not a flaw, but it means this isn't a wipe-and-go accessory. It's also a single unit — one grate, one count — and it's heavy, so you'll want to handle it with two hands when it's hot.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for reducing smoke and grease buildup → BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter. The fine mesh catches splatter before it hits the heater.
• Best for actual grilling results → GLOWYE Grill Grate. Cast iron plus a ceramic coating equals real grill marks and even heat.
• Best for protecting your appliance long-term → BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter. Keeping the heater clean is the whole point of its design.
• Best for cooking larger batches at once → GLOWYE Grill Grate. Its 13.36" x 9.1" surface gives you room to spread food out.
• Best for easy cleanup → BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter. Soapy water or the dishwasher, and you're done.
• Best if you don't want maintenance → BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter. No seasoning, no oil ritual, no special handling.
• Best for steak, chicken and vegetables specifically → GLOWYE Grill Grate. It's built for foods that benefit from a sear.
• Best if you want a spare on hand → BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter. It ships as a 2-pack; the GLOWYE grate is a single unit.
My Verdict
In my opinion, these aren't really competitors — they're two halves of a better grilling setup. If I had to pick one, I'd buy the GLOWYE Grill Grate, because it changes what you can cook rather than just how much you have to clean. A cast iron surface with even heat and proper grill marks is the upgrade you taste. That said, if your Foodi is smoking and your heater is caked in grease, the BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter is the fix you actually need first. Buy the one that matches your problem.
Yes — it's specifically designed for the FG551, FG550, BG500A and DG551, and also fits several IG600-series and AG300-series models. Check your exact model against the compatibility list before ordering.
It's made for the FG550, FG551 and DG551. The 13.36" x 9.1" size is designed for a seamless fit in that basket, so it isn't a universal part.
They do different jobs. The splatter shield protects the heater and reduces smoke; the grill grate gives you a cooking surface. Plenty of owners use both together.
I don't quote prices here — check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page, then compare against how often you'll actually use each accessory.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Collections Etc Stainless Steel Chicken vs Baker's Signature 9, Deskbloom Stainless Steel Rotisserie vs NEIQIUWING 25.6cm, GORILLA GRIP Stainless Steel Kitchen vs SIUDANGKA 4