How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
These two products share almost nothing except a kitchen setting. One is a stainless steel grill accessory built around a single job. The other is a 220-count box of unbleached wood-pulp liners built around convenience and repeat use. Comparing them is really about comparing two different problems: holding food in place over a flame, versus keeping a basket free of mess. If you are torn, the deciding question is simple — do you cook chicken legs on a grill, or do you steam and air-fry in a round basket?
• Collections Etc's biggest strength: a dedicated stainless steel rack that holds chicken legs in position for even cooking on a backyard grill, sized at 15 1/2"L x 6 1/4"W x 6 1/4"H.
• Collections Etc's biggest trade-off: it does one narrow job. It is not a liner, not a steamer accessory, and not a general-purpose cooking tool.
• Baker's Signature 9's biggest strength: 220 round, perforated, curl-resistant liners that prevent sticking and cut cleanup time in air fryers and steamer baskets.
• Baker's Signature 9's biggest trade-off: it is a consumable. Once the 220 sheets are gone, you buy again — and it only fits round baskets around 9 inches.
• Pick Collections Etc if your goal is grilling drumsticks evenly and you want a durable metal tool.
• Pick Baker's Signature 9 if your goal is faster cleanup and you cook in a round air fryer or bamboo steamer.
This is a single-purpose tool, and that is its whole appeal. The rack measures 15 1/2 inches long, 6 1/4 inches wide and 6 1/4 inches high, so it sits across a grill grate and holds chicken legs upright instead of letting them roll around. The stainless steel construction points to a rack you can keep in rotation season after season rather than replace. It weighs 1.7 pounds, which is substantial enough to feel planted on the grate but light enough to move with one hand.
Who should buy it: anyone who grills chicken legs regularly and is tired of chasing drumsticks around the grate. Holding them in place is exactly what produces more even cooking, because the meat is not resting directly on one spot and scorching while the rest stays underdone. It also suits someone hosting a barbecue who wants to load up a batch of legs at once and manage them without tongs gymnastics. The rack's footprint is long and relatively narrow, so it works best on a standard rectangular grill where you can lay it across the bars.
Who should skip it: if you mostly steam, bake in a basket, or air-fry, this rack does nothing for you. It is also not the pick if you want disposable convenience or zero cleanup — metal racks need scrubbing after a greasy cook. And if you cook for one or two people and rarely make more than a couple of legs at a time, the 15 1/2-inch length may be more rack than you need. It is a grill tool, plain and simple.
This is a cleanup product first and a cooking product second, and it is honest about that. You get 220 round liners, each 9 inches across, made from unbleached wood pulp in a natural brown finish. The perforations matter: the holes let steam and heat move through so food cooks evenly instead of sitting in trapped moisture, and the double-sided silicone coating lets baked goods slide off without extra prep. The liners are described as curl-resistant, which is the detail that separates a usable liner from a frustrating one — a sheet that stays flat does its job; one that rolls up at the edges does not.
Who should buy it: air fryer owners with a round basket, and anyone using a bamboo steamer who is tired of dumplings and buns welding themselves to the wood. The 220-count box is the real story here. That is a long runway of cooks before you think about restocking, and it means you can line a basket, cook, and toss without a second thought. It also suits people who care about what touches their food — the liner is described as non-toxic, unbleached, and free of the bleaching-related chemicals found in white sheets, which matters if you are lining baskets for vegetables, fish, and dumplings often.
Who should skip it: if you use a square or unusually sized air fryer basket, a 9-inch round liner will not seat properly. If you are looking for a reusable tool, this is the opposite — it is designed to be used once and discarded. And if you grill rather than steam or air-fry, these liners have no role in your cooking at all.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer cleanup → Baker's Signature 9. Round, perforated liners catch the mess so the basket does not.
• Best for steaming dumplings and buns → Baker's Signature 9. It is built as a bamboo steamer liner alternative and fits 9-inch round baskets.
• Best for a durable, reusable tool → Collections Etc Stainless Steel Chicken. Stainless steel, 1.7 pounds, made to be kept and reused.
• Best for low-effort, cook-and-toss convenience → Baker's Signature 9. 220 liners means you line, cook, and discard without washing anything.
• Best for feeding a crowd at a barbecue → Collections Etc Stainless Steel Chicken. The 15 1/2-inch rack loads multiple legs in one pass.
• Best for food that sticks → Baker's Signature 9. The silicone coating and non-stick liner design address sticking directly.
• Best if you want both → buy both. They solve different problems and do not overlap at all.
If I had to pick one, I would pick based on how you actually cook, because these products never compete for the same job. For grilling drumsticks evenly and owning a tool that lasts, I would buy the Collections Etc Stainless Steel Chicken Leg Cooker Rack — in my opinion it earns its place because it solves a real, specific grilling problem with durable stainless steel. But if cleanup is your pain point, I would buy Baker's Signature 9 instead: 220 curl-resistant liners in one box is a lot of hassle-free cooking. Honestly, if you grill legs and air-fry, buying both makes more sense than choosing. Check the current price on Amazon for each before you decide, since that is the one variable this comparison cannot settle for you.
See also: Whole Foods Market vs DOITOOL Stainless Steel Air, Deedro Stainless Steel Baking vs Reynolds Kitchens Air Fryer, PRIJESSE Air Fryer Dual vs Bella Pro Stainless Steel 9-qt, TOSSPER Reusable Non Stick vs HINMAY Stainless Steel Scissor
It depends on your grate size. The rack is 15 1/2 inches long and 6 1/4 inches wide, so it needs a reasonably long cooking surface to sit across. On a compact grill it may take up most of the grate, leaving little room for anything else. On a standard rectangular grill, it fits comfortably.
Each pack contains 220 round liners, each 9 inches across. That is a large supply meant to last through many cooking sessions. They are single-use, so plan to restock once the box runs out.
No. Collections Etc is a stainless steel rack that holds chicken legs in place for even grilling. Baker's Signature 9 is a set of perforated parchment-style liners for air fryers and steamer baskets. One is a reusable tool, the other a disposable liner — they do not substitute for each other.
Only if your basket is round and close to 9 inches. A 9-inch round liner will not seat properly in a square or significantly larger or smaller basket. Measure your basket's diameter before buying.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.