Address: University of Liverpool Management School, Chatham St, Liverpool L69 7ZH
Email: balazs.murakozy@liverpool.ac.uk
I am a senior lecturer (associate professor) at the University of Liverpool Management School where I am also the Director of Studies for the PhD in Economics. I am also affiliated with the Centre for Economic and Regional Studies in Budapest, the University of Oslo and I am also an external member of the he Arthur Lewis Lab for Comparative Development. I received my PhD at the Central European University. My research focuses on how firms' decisions on technology, innovation or internationalization are related to outcomes for workers, firms and the the economy in general. Methodologically, I mostly work with large linked microdata.
My CV is here.
Worker skills or firm wage-setting practices? Decomposing wage inequality across 20 OECD countries (with Chiara Criscuolo, Alexander Hijzen, Cyrille Schwellnus, Erling Barth, Antoine Bertheau, Wen-Hao Chen, Richard Fabling, Priscilla Fialho, Jonathan Garita, Andrei Gorshkov, Katarzyna Grabska-Romagosa, Antton Haramboure, Ryo Kambayashi, Michael Koelle, Valerie Lankester, Timo Leidecker, Oskar Nordstr\"om Skans, Satu Nurmi, Vladimir Peciar, Capucine Riom, Duncan Roth, Catalina Sandoval, Balazs Stadler, Richard Upward, Wouter Zwysen), ILR Review, accepted
The Effects of EU-Funded Enterprise Grants on Firms and Workers (with Álmos Telegdy), Journal of Comparative Economics, 2023
High-growth firms’ contribution to aggregate productivity growth (with Marta Bisztray and Francesca de Nicola), Small Business Economics, 2022
Into the Unknown: The Extent and Boldness of Firms’ International Footprint (with Gabor Bekes and Gabriel Benito and Davide Castellani), Global Strategy Journal, 2021
Spillovers from High Growth Firms: Evidence from Hungary (with Francesca de Nicola and Shawn Tan, Small Business Economics, 2019
Centralization of strategic decisions during the Great Recession (with Zoltán Bakonyi). Managerial and Decision Economics 40: (4) 394-413, 2019
Markups of Exporters and Importers: Evidence from Hungary (with Cecília Hornok). Scandinavian Journal of Economics 121:(3) 1303-1333, 2019
The ladder of internationalization modes: Evidence from European firms (with Gábor Békés). Review of World Economics 154:(3) 455-491, 2018
Why do within-firm–product export prices differ across markets?: Evidence from Hungary (with Holger Görg and László Halpern). World Economy, 40: (6) 1233-1246, 2017
Shipment frequency of exporters and demand uncertainty (with Gábor Békés, Lionel Fontagné and Vincent Vicard). Review of World Economics, 153: (4) 779-807, 2017
Political incentives and state subsidy allocation: Evidence from Hungarian municipalities (with Álmos Telegdy) European Economic Review, 89, 324-244, 2016, data and do files
Measuring productivity premia with many modes of internationalization (with Gábor Békés) Economics Letters, 139, 61-64, 2016
Temporary trade and heterogeneous firms (with Gábor Békés), Journal of International Economics 87:(2) 232-246, 2012
Innovation, productivity and exports: the case of Hungary (with László Halpern). Economics of Innovation and New Technology, 21:(2) pp.151- 173., 2012
What makes a successful export?: evidence from firm-product-level data (with Holger Görg and Richard Kneller) Canadian Journal of Economics, 45:(4) pp. 1332-1368, 2012
Firms and products in international trade: evidence from Hungary (with Gábor Békés and Péter Harasztosi) Economic Systems: Journal Of International And Comparative Economics 35:(1) pp. 4-24., 2011
Does distance matter in spillover? (with László Halpern) Economics Of Transition 15:(4) pp. 781-805, 2007
Books and other publications
Productivity differences in Hungary and mechanisms of TFP growth slowdown, Study written by Balázs Muraközy, Márta Bisztray and Balázs Reizer (CERS HAS) for the European Commission, policy presentation
Still standing: how European firms weathered the crisis – The third EFIGE policy report (with Gábor Békés, László Halpern and Miklós Koren), Bruegel Blueprints 15, 22 December 2011
Working papers and drafts
Technological Change and Skill Demand in Non-Competitive Labor Markets (with Attila Lindner, Balázs Reizer and Ragnhild Schreiner) -- Revise and Resubmit at the American Economic Review
We quantify the contribution of firm-level technological change to skill demand and aggregate inequality in the presence of imperfect competition in the labor market. We show that skill-biased technological change increases both the firm-level skill ratio and the skill premium, while other shocks (e.g. firm-specific output demand shocks) cannot explain the increase in both outcomes. We exploit administrative data and a large survey measuring a broad class of firm-level technological changes from Hungary and Norway. We estimate that the aggregate college premium increases by 6.1% in Norway and by 13.8% in Hungary as a result of the skill bias in technological change.
THE FIRM-LEVEL LINK BETWEEN PRODUCTIVITY DISPERSION AND WAGE INEQUALITY: A SYMPTOM OF LOW JOB MOBILITY? (with Chiara Criscuolo, Alexander Hijzen, Michael Koelle, Cyrille Schwellnus, Erling Barth, Wen-Hao Chen, Richard Fabling, Priscilla Fialho, Alfred Garloff, Katharzyna Grabska, Ryo Kambayashi, Valerie Lankester, Balazs Stadler, Oskar Nordström Skans, Satu Nurmi, Richard Upward and Wouter Zwysen)
Differences in average wages across firms – which account for around one-half of overall wage inequality – are mainly explained by differences in firm wage premia (the part of wages that depends exclusively on characteristics of firms) rather than workforce composition. Using a new cross-country dataset of linked employer-employee data, this paper investigates the role of cross-firm dispersion in productivity in explaining dispersion in firm wage premia, as well as the factors shaping the link between productivity and wages at the firm level. The results suggest that around 15% of cross-firm differences in productivity are passed on to differences in firm wage premia. The degree of pass-through is systematically larger in countries and industries with more limited job mobility, where low-productivity firms can afford to pay lower wage premia relative to high-productivity ones without a substantial fraction of workers quitting their jobs. Stronger product market competition raises pass-through while more centralised bargaining and higher minimum wages constrain firm-level wage setting at any given level of productivity dispersion. From a policy perspective, the results suggest that the key priority should be to promote job mobility, which would reduce wage differences between firms while easing the efficient reallocation of workers across them.
Firms and the Gender Wage Gap: A Comparison of Eleven Countries (with Marco G. Palladino, Antoine Bertheau, Alexander Hijzen, Astrid Kunze, Cesar Barreto, Doğan Gülümser, Marta Lachowska, Anne Sophie Lassen, Salvatore Lattanzio, Benjamin Lochner, Stefano Lombardi, Jordy Meekes and Oskar Nordström Skans)
We quantify the role of gender-specific firm wage premiums in explaining the private-sector gender gap in hourly wages using a harmonized research design across eleven matched employer–employee datasets covering ten European countries and Washington State (USA). Firm wage premiums contribute to the gender wage gap through two channels: women’s concentration in lower-paying firms (sorting) and lower wage premiums for women than for men within the same firm (pay-setting). We find that firm wage premiums account for 10 to 30 percent of the overall gender wage gap, with sorting emerging as the dominant mechanism in most countries. We document three robust cross-country patterns: women’s sorting into lower-paying firms increases with age; women are more concentrated in low-paying firms with a high share of part-time workers; and women receive around 90 percent of the wage premia that men obtain from firm surplus. These findings highlight the importance of firm-level wage-setting and worker allocation in shaping gender wage disparities.
From Planning to Markets: Export-Oriented Firms and Firm–Market Heterogeneity in 1990s Hungary (with Fabrice Defever and Alejandro Riaño)
This paper exploits Hungary’s transition from a planned to a market economy as a natural experiment to study how firms’ export behavior evolves during large-scale economic change. We document a sharp increase in the number of export-oriented firms, a defining feature of the modern Hungarian economy. While part of this reflects a gradual reallocation of exports toward Western markets, the main driver is a growing dispersion in firm–market sales, particularly toward Western destinations. This pattern is only partially explained by improved access to global value chains and rising foreign ownership, pointing instead to substantial heterogeneity in how firms respond to new market opportunities. The results highlight the importance of firm-level adjustments and market-specific dynamics in shaping export performance during economic transition.
Import Competition from China, Escape Competition, and the Shift toward Science-Based Innovation (with Sofia Amaral-Garcia, Péter Bauer, Clemens Domnick, Péter Harasztosi and Christoph Weiss)
This paper examines how rising import competition from China affects innovation among manufacturing firms across European countries. Using multiple waves of the Community Innovation Survey (CIS) and a shift–share identification strategy, we study both the extensive margin of technological change—measured by the share of firms introducing new products and processes—and the type of innovation firms undertake. We find that industries more exposed to Chinese import growth exhibit a higher share of innovating firms, consistent with an escape-competition mechanism, and a shift toward more science-based innovation: firms increase R&D engagement, R&D intensity and cooperation with scientific institutions, while organizational and marketing innovation show no comparable response. These results suggest that import competition reshapes not only the level but also the composition of innovation across firms, as stronger competitive pressure raises overall innovation incentives while increasing the relative return to science-based innovation, which is more effective at sustaining profits under close competition.
Which ICTs Promote Global Value Chain Integration? Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Data (with Márta Bisztray)
Technology upgrading has been shown to be both a precondition for and a consequence of integration into global value chains (GVCs), yet the role of specific technologies remains less well understood. This paper focuses on information technologies that enable automated information sharing with business partners (external AIS). Combining Hungarian firm-to-firm transaction data with detailed ICT survey information, we identify suppliers that serve multinational enterprises (MNEs) and other GVC-integrated firms. We develop a simple framework in which suppliers’ technology choices complement those of global firms and are determined endogenously. Empirically, we find that the use of external AIS significantly increases the likelihood of GVC integration: firms adopting these technologies are more likely to be selected by MNEs and to acquire new multinational buyers. At the same time, exposure to multinational firms encourages technology adoption, as suppliers facing a higher share of potential or actual MNE buyers are more likely to introduce AIS. Quantitatively, AIS adoption is associated with a 10 percentage point increase in the probability of supplying an MNE (around one-third of the baseline), while a 10 percentage point increase in the share of MNEs among potential buyers raises AIS adoption by 16–24%. These results highlight complementarities between firm technologies and global production networks, and suggest that policies promoting digital information-sharing technologies can facilitate GVC integration.
The Role of Firms in the Wage Penalty for Chronic Health Conditions (with Márta Bisztray and Rita Pető)
More than one-third of people in the EU report having a chronic health condition (CHC), and their share in the workforce is expected to rise. Using linked employer–employee administrative data from Hungary that combine detailed healthcare utilization with wage records, we identify workers with CHCs and analyze their labor market outcomes with a focus on the role of firms. We find that men and women with CHCs are 7 and 14 percentage points less likely to be employed, respectively, and among the employed face wage penalties of 5.8% and 13.9%. Differences in firm-specific pay premiums account for 12% of the penalty for men and 23% for women. Event-study estimates with worker fixed effects show persistent wage losses following CHC onset—4% for men and 1.5% for women—only a small share of which is explained by transitions to lower-paying firms, with the remainder likely reflecting missed promotions and slower wage growth. Examining firm ownership, we find that foreign-owned firms account for around 20% of the overall penalty, driven primarily by worker sorting and, to a lesser extent, by smaller wage premia for CHC workers within these firms. These results imply that wage declines between ages 40 and 60 would be 10–20% smaller in the absence of CHC-related penalties, with about one-fifth of this effect attributable to the role of foreign-owned firms.
Supplier Choice and Market Frictions: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Data (with Attila Lindner and Adam Szeidl)
This project develops and estimates a structural model of supplier choice in which firms select trading partners under information frictions and costly search. The model incorporates a two-stage decision process, where firms first form a consideration set and then choose a supplier based on prices, wages as a proxy for quality, and distance-related costs. Using firm-to-firm transaction data, we estimate the model and quantify the importance of frictions in shaping supplier networks. Preliminary results suggest that limited information and search costs substantially restrict firms’ choice sets, with implications for market efficiency and the propagation of shocks through production networks.
Targeting government aid during COVID-19:The issue of fixed costs (with Yannick Bormans and Jozef Konings)
Many governments implement policies to support generally healthy firms to survive the COVID-19 crisis in a targeted way. Efficient design requires information on howmargins andprofitability change during the crisis, however, earlier research produced ambiguous resultsabout this relationship. This paper argues that the ambiguitymainly results from the fact that the two components of price-cost margins, the part needed to cover fixed costsand the excess profits, both as a fraction of operating revenue, move indifferent directions during aneconomic crisis. We build on a novel methodology (Abraham, Bormans, Konings & Roeger, 2020) whichestimates price-cost margins in the presence of fixed costs, and apply it to microdata from Belgium, Hungary and the UK. We show that, indeed,the fixed cost share is countercyclical while excess profitability isprocyclical.According to our estimates, the COVID-19crisis will lead to an increase of 16.0percentage pointsin the fixed cost ratio and a decrease of 3.8percentage points in excess profit rates.Finally, we identify sectors which are more vulnerable to inefficient exit of healthy firmsbased on three criteria: high operating revenue losses, large increases infixed cost shares and low pre-crisis profitability.
The nature of buyer-supplier relationships: Lessons from the Central European Supplier Survey (with Gábor Békés, Miklós Koren and Álmos Telegdy) Presentation
The increasing importance of global value chains has created both scientific and policy interest in supplier-buyer relationships. Data availability is often a key constraint for such research. The few firm-to-firm datasets that exist contain little information on how relationships form and operate. This study introduces the Central European Supplier Survey, a new data source, which merges survey information with financial statements for a large sample of manufacturing firms from Hungary, Romania and Slovakia. The first part of the paper describes the data collection process and the different issues and dilemmas it brought about, while the second part highlights key features of firm connections. These results show that (i) buyer/supplier portfolios are correlated with productivity, (ii) key relationships are as often initiated by the buyer as the supplier and (iii) many of these relationships start with both product and process innovation.These patterns indicate that many key relationships are of long-term and relational.Such patterns can be of key interest for policymakers aiming at supporting firms in creating high-value relationships.
Competition with multinational firms (with Katehryn N. Russ)
Do multinational firms wield more market power than their domestic counterparts? Using Hungarian firm-level data between 1993 and 2007, we find that markups are 19 percent higher for foreign-owned firms than for domestically owned firms. Moreover, markups for domestically owned firms are significantly lower in industries where multinationals have a greater technological edge, suggesting that Ricardian differences in technology and endogenous markups constitute important dimensions for models of foreign direct investment. We innovate within a canonical Ricardian model of endogenous markups and heterogeneous firms to provide analytical distributions of market shares and markups when goods are imperfect substitutes to provide structure for our empirical analysis. Our model explains about half of the multinational markup premium identified in the empirical analysis.
In Hungarian
A magyar vállalati adózás heterogenitása [Heterogeneity of corporate taxation in Hungary] (with Balázs Reizer), Közgazdasági Szemle, 64:(12) pp. 1233-1264., 2017.
Beszállítói termékek a magyar feldolgozóiparban [Intermediate inputs in Hungarian manufacturing] (with Gábor Békés), Közgazdasági Szemle, 63(10), 1046-1073., 2016
Magyar vállalatok haszonkulcsai [Markups of Hungarian Firms] (with Cecília Hornok), Közgazdasági Szemle 62:(10) pp. 1048—1069., 2015
Külkereskedelem és a vállalatok közötti különbségek. [Trade and firm heterogeneity] (with Gábor Békés and László Halpern) Közgazdasági Szemle 60:(1) pp. 1-24., 2013
Magyar gazellák: a gyors növekedésű vállalatok jellemzői [Hungarian gazelles: which firms grow quickly?] (with Gábor Békés) Közgazdasági Szemle 59:(3) pp. 233-262., 2012
A teremtő rombolás szerepe a vállalati termelékenység alakulásában Magyarországon [The role of creative destruction in productivity in Hungary] (with Gábor Békés and László Halpern) Közgazdasági Szemle 58:(2) pp. 111-132., 2011
Innováció́ és vállalati teljesítmény Magyarországon [Innovation and firm performance in Hungary] (with László Halpern) Közgazdasági Szemle 57:(4) pp. 293-317., 2010
Policy-related research and analysis
Firm growth and Investment in Pakistan for the World Bank (2021-22)
Innovation Country Report 2019: High growth enterprises, innovation and productivity challenges Hungary for the European Commision (2019)
TFP growth slowdown in Hungary for DG Growth of the European Commission (2017-2018), presentation
My team conducted on in-depth analysis of the causes and consequences of productivity slowdown in Hungary, including differences in within-firm growth and reallocation to inform policy advice of the European Commission.
High growth firms in Hungary (2017-2018)
A detailed country report on High Growth firms in Hungary prepared for the World Banks flagship report on HGFs.
Consulting for the OECD on its Innovation Review of Kazakhstan (2016-2017)
I have been one of the external experts in the preparation of the Innovation Review for Kazakhstan.
Blog posts
The ladder of Internationalization Modes, VoxEU, March 28, 2018
Why hit-and-run exporting can be optimal, VoxEU, September 20, 2012
Shipping out the best beer: Why export prices increase with distance, VoxEU, March 14, 2010
Research grants
H2020 MICRODROD (2019-2023)
The main aim of the MICROPROD will be to investigate the reasons for the productivity slowdown observable in developed countries in the recent period both in terms of theory and measurement. The team, which consists of CERS HAS as well as Aarhus, Bocconi, Bruegel, CERS HAS, Paris School of Economics, Vrjie University, will set out to evaluate if productivity is measured correctly and if its underlying mechanisms are sufficiently well understood. We will also aim to study the effect of globalization and technological change on new production methods, and if the current policy environment is conducive to the new productivity environment. According to plan, I will lead the Hungarian team and the workpackage on Globalization.
Employment of the low-skilled in Hungary NKFIH Grant (2017-2020)
The falling relative wage and declining employment of low-skilled workers has led to an important debate about the role of different factors in this trend. In the last decade three potential key explanations have emerged: skill-biased technological change (Acemolglu, 2002), globalization and outsourcing (Feenstra and Hanson, 2001; Acemoglu and Autor, 2011; David et al. 2013) and changes in economic policy (e. g. declining minimum wages; Dinardo et al. 1999). The goal of this research is to provide new evidence on a number of key demand factors affecting low-skilled employment and wages. It examines both the role of economic factors such as globalization and innovation as well as the role of some prominent public policies such as trade liberalization, minimum wages and public work programs.
Firms, Strategy and Performance Momentum Grant (2013-2018)
The Momentum ("Lendület") grant of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences is for establishing new research groups to conduct outstanding research. Its design is based on that of the ERC both in terms of its evaluation method and size. I have won this research grant in 2013 to set up the research group aimed at analyzing microdata on firms. After the 5-year period, we received an evaluation with an "excellent" degree, and the Academy decided that the group will become permanent.
Political determinants of Enterprise subsidies Global Development Network grant (2012-2014)
This grant was for studying how the affiliation of local politicians is related to the amount of grants they receive from the EU structural funds. This research was published as 'Political incentives and state subsidy allocation: Evidence from Hungarian municipalities' in the European Economic Review.
Teaching
University of Liverpool Management School, Theory of the firm & International Economic Relations, undergraduate, 2019
Currently I am teaching these undergraduate courses at ULMS.
Rajk László College for Advanced Studies, Microecomics, Economics of Innovation, Applied Econometrics, Graduate, 2008-2019
I have been teaching in this college since 2006. Rajk László College provides advanced extra-curricular courses for a special group of students who live together in a democratic community. Throughout the years, I have taught different courses there, including a one-year course in Applied Econometrics in recent years, mainly for MA students. Teaching in the small-group environment of the College is very challenging and motivating. Fortunately, many students apply for my course and the feedback tends to be quite positive. In earlier years, I also taught Microeconomics and Economics of Innovation. I have also been a resident fellow of the College between 2006-2008, becoming even more closely involved in all the issues of this institution.
ELTE University, Organizational Economics, Undergraduate, 2009-2012
ELTE has started its innovative Economics BA program in 2008, and I joined as an external lecturer for 3 years. I have been responsible for developing and teaching a core course on the Economics of the firm (Organizational Economics), focusing on applied micro and asymmetric information.
Magyar Nemzeti Bank (Central Bank of Hungary), Applied Econometrics, on-the-job training, 2011
Central European University, Econometrics, Graduate, 2009
Data I work with
Linked Hungarian microdata
Linked Hungarian microdata is available on site in the research room operated together by CERS and the Central Statistical Office of Hungary. I have worked extensively with firm balance sheets, trade data, the Structure of Earnings employee-level data and the Community Innovation Survey. Some of these data has been acquired and cleaned extensively by my research group, funded from the different research grants. For example, the recent paper 'Skill-biased innovation activities' builds on linked innovation-balance sheet-Structure of Earnings data to show how different types of innovation are related to the college premium.
Administrative firm-to-firm data
Recently, we had to opportunity to extend these linked microdata with firm-to-firm transaction data, which is collected as part of the VAT declarations of firms. Now we are working mainly on clearing these data, and comparing it to other datasources. Such firm-to-firm data is available in few countries, and enables one to investigate such questions as how the set of suppliers or buyers is related to a firm's performance, what happens to firms which start to supply multinationals within the country, or how shocks propagate via this network.
EFIGE/AMADEUS
The EFIGE survey was created within the Framework 7 project "European Firms in the Global Economy", in which our institute participated. The database, for the first time in Europe, combines measures of firms’ international activities (e.g. exports, outsourcing, FDI, import) with quantitative and qualitative information on around 150 items including R&D and innovation, labour organisation, financing and organisational activities and pricing behaviour. The data consists of a representative sample (at the country level for the manufacturing industry) of almost 15,000 surveyed firms (above 10 employees) in seven European economies (Germany, France, Italy, Spain, United Kingdom, Austria, and Hungary). The data was collected in 2010, thus covering the years from 2007 to 2009. Importantly, it can be linked to AMADEUS for firm-level financial information. Many of my recent publications use these data. For example, in "The ladder of internationalization modes" we use the rich data on EFIGE to investigate how a rich set of internationalization activities (as identified from EFIGE) are linked to productivity (as identified from the AMADEUS).
CEE Supplier Survey
Together with Gábor Békés, Miklós Koren and Álmos Telegdy and the GfK market research firm, we conducted a survey on buyer-supplier relationships of 1,800 firms in Hungary, Slovakia and Romania. The survey asked a number of questions both about the firm and their buyers and suppliers. Importantly the respondents can be linked to balance sheet data, while we are currently working on linking their partners to AMADEUS. Some preliminary patterns can be seen here.
Who supplies whom
This is a global database on automotive supply chains. It includes detailed information on the supplier of each part built into a car, produced in a specific plant. These data enables one to investigate how such relationships form, how supplier choice is related to the knowledge content or the specificity of each of the part or how input quality is related to output quality. Together with Gábor Békés, we have worked on linking these data to data on car manufacturers (to see firm performance), on car models (to measure the quality of the car), and on the type of car parts (to use patent data to measure knowledge content and technological relatedness).