We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-28 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a two-piece oven air fryer set with a basket, a tray and a stack of liners already in the box, choose Baccooli Air Fryer Basket; if you need a single replacement basket cut to fit a Ninja Foodi or Typhur Sync countertop oven, choose GWYSY Air Fryer Basket.
• Baccooli's biggest strength: two sizes (15"×11" and 12.8"×9.6") plus a matching tray and 100 parchment sheets, so you get a full setup rather than one part.
• Baccooli's biggest trade-off: it's a generic "fits most convection ovens" set — it isn't cut for any specific oven model, so you have to measure your own rack first.
• GWYSY's biggest strength: it's a purpose-built replacement for named machines — Ninja Foodi DT251, DT200, DT201 and the Typhur Sync 12-in-1 27QT — at 14.29"×10.87"×1.18".
• GWYSY's biggest trade-off: it's one basket only, no tray and no liners, so if you want a complete set you're buying more than one item.
• In my opinion, Baccooli is for the cook who wants family-sized batches of fries, wings and veggies and wants cleanup to be mostly "toss the liner."
• In my opinion, GWYSY is for the owner of a Ninja Foodi or Typhur Sync oven whose original basket has warped, stained or gone missing.
Baccooli is selling a system, not a part. The set ships with a 15"×11" basket, a 12.8"×9.6" basket, a tray, and 100 oil-absorbing parchment sheets. That combination is the reason to look at it. The smaller basket handles a weeknight portion for two; the larger one is sized for the four-to-six servings Baccooli claims, which is the difference between air-frying in two rounds and air-frying in one.
The mesh is where the real design thinking shows. Baccooli uses a honeycomb mesh for what it describes as 360° hot air circulation, and the point of that open pattern is that hot air reaches food from below as well as above. In practice, that's the difference between a tray where you flip halfway and a basket where you can often leave things alone. The construction is 18/8 stainless steel with a non-stick coating, and the sheet is explicit that it's free of BPA, PTFE, PFOA, PFOS, lead, cadmium and phthalates — worth knowing if you're the type who reads coating labels. Baccooli also says the steel is 25% thicker than earlier versions of this kind of set, and that the frame is reinforced, which matters because thin mesh baskets are the ones that bow and wobble after a few hot cycles.
Two practical details stand out for everyday use. The set is stackable, which Baccooli puts at 70% less storage space — relevant if your cupboards are already full. And the rounded edges plus the "splatter-proof structure" are the kind of small stuff you notice on day one, not month six. The whole thing is dishwasher safe, and the parchment sheets mean many meals need nothing more than a liner in the bin.
GWYSY Air Fryer Basket: Who It's For
GWYSY takes the opposite approach: one basket, one job, named machines. The listing calls out Ninja Foodi DT251 10-in-1 Smart XL, the DT200 and DT201 convection ovens, and the Typhur Sync Oven 12-in-1 27QT. The basket measures 14.29"×10.87"×1.18", which is the number that actually matters — if you own one of those ovens and your measurements line up, you're done shopping.
The build is food-grade steel with a rust-resistant screen, and GWYSY leans hard on the anti-warp angle: a frame that "won't rattle or bend" and a square shape made to resist warping. That's the failure mode people actually complain about with replacement racks, so it's a sensible thing to design against. The unit weighs 1.23 pounds, which tells you it's a real piece of steel rather than a foil-thin insert.
The second design idea here is the ultra-fine mesh. GWYSY pitches it as a splatter shield: it catches grease, oil and food particles so they don't hit the heating element, which keeps the element cleaner and reduces the smoke that comes with baked-on residue. If you've ever had a countertop oven start smoking mid-bake, that's the problem this is aimed at. The flip side of a fine mesh is airflow — it's a tighter weave than a honeycomb pattern, so it's better at containing mess than at maximizing circulation. That's a fair trade for wings and fries in a Ninja, less ideal if your goal is the crispiest possible roasted vegetables.
Cleaning is straightforward: dishwasher safe, heat-resisting, non-stick. GWYSY does warn against scrubbing with abrasive cloths or metal balls, which is worth heeding on any coated or fine-mesh rack. It's also worth noting this is a single basket — no tray, no liners, no second size. You're buying a replacement part, and you should judge it as one.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for cooking for four to six people at once → Baccooli, since the 15"×11" basket is the larger of the two options here.
• Best for a Ninja Foodi DT251, DT200 or DT201 → GWYSY, which names those models directly.
• Best for a Typhur Sync 12-in-1 27QT → GWYSY, which lists that oven as a target fit.
• Best for maximizing hot air circulation → Baccooli, whose honeycomb mesh is designed for omnidirectional airflow and less flipping.
• Best for containing grease splatter and keeping the heating element clean → GWYSY, thanks to its ultra-fine mesh shield.
• Best for small kitchens → Baccooli, because the stackable design is built around saving storage space.
• Best for replacing one worn-out rack → GWYSY, since you're not paying for accessories you already own.
If I were buying for a household that cooks real volume — fries, wings, roasted vegetables, batch baking — I'd take the Baccooli Air Fryer Basket. In my opinion the two sizes plus the tray and liners do more for a normal week of cooking than any single rack can, and the thicker 18/8 steel and stackable shape are the details I'd want to live with. But if I owned a Ninja Foodi or Typhur Sync and just needed a basket that fits, I'd buy the GWYSY Air Fryer Basket without hesitating — it's the one that names my machine, and fit beats extras every time. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your oven before you decide.
Baccooli says it fits most convection ovens and oven air-fry functions, but it doesn't list specific models. Measure your oven rack and compare it to the 15"×11" and 12.8"×9.6" sizes before ordering.
Yes — GWYSY lists the DT251 10-in-1 Smart XL as a target model, along with the DT200, DT201 and the Typhur Sync 12-in-1 27QT. The basket measures 14.29"×10.87"×1.18", so it's worth confirming against your own oven.
Baccooli's honeycomb mesh is designed for 360° airflow so food heats evenly without flipping. GWYSY's ultra-fine mesh is optimized for splatter control, so more even browning may still mean a mid-cook toss.
Both are dishwasher safe. GWYSY specifically warns against abrasive cloths or metal scrubbers, and the same caution makes sense for Baccooli's non-stick coated steel.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GLOWYE Air Fryer Basket vs MMH Air Fry Mesh, PGMTDEFXJO Air Fryer Cooking vs JKIFKSP Air Fryer Silicone, ZOWVAAM Air Fryer Liners vs Webake 6, MMH 130PCs vs GAROZATION Air Fryer Replacement