We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-19 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want replacement ear tips that upgrade comfort, grip and noise isolation on your AirPods Pro, choose AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium; if you need to bring a worn-out Logitech G Pro or G Pro X gaming headset back to life, choose XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads. These two products are not really rivals at all — they serve different ears, different devices and different problems. One is a fit-and-comfort upgrade for Apple's earbuds. The other is a straight swap-in part for a gaming headset whose cushions have flattened out. The rest of this article breaks down exactly which one fits your situation.
• AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium — biggest strength: ISO-9 memory foam with a semi-permeable top layer, an ergonomic tapered shape, and an assorted S/M/L pack that lets you dial in fit, grip and passive noise cancellation on AirPods Pro.
• AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium — biggest trade-off: It is a three-pair kit aimed at one specific ecosystem (AirPods Pro), and the fit depends on picking the right size and variant, so it rewards a little patience.
• XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads — biggest strength: A simple, direct replacement for Logitech G Pro / G Pro X earpads using memory foam, meant to restore a headset that already works.
• XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads — biggest trade-off: One pair per pack, one headset family only, and no sizing options — if your model isn't a G Pro or G Pro X, it isn't for you.
• Who each pick is for: AutoLine Pro for AirPods Pro owners chasing better seal, bass and comfort; XBERSTAR for Logitech G Pro / G Pro X gamers whose pads are worn, lost or damaged.
The AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium is a set of memory foam ear tips — three pairs, in assorted small, medium and large — built for AirPods Pro 1st and 2nd Gen and AirPods Pro 3 (with the correct variant for your model). The headline material is ISO-9 memory foam, which the brand describes as blending comfort with durability, sweat resistance and grip, thanks to a semi-permeable layer sitting on top of the foam. That layer is the interesting part: it's meant to add a skin-friendly surface without killing the conforming feel that makes foam tips worth using in the first place.
What it does best, based on the design, is solve the fit problem. Each tip is tapered at the front for a deeper, more secure seat and slightly widened at the rear to follow the natural groove of the ear. Because foam behaves differently from the silicone tips that ship with AirPods Pro, the assorted pack is the sensible way to buy — you can test all three sizes, adjust how deep the tip sits and rotate the bud to find your sweet spot. In my opinion, that adjustability is the whole point: a better seal usually means more passive noise isolation, a stronger grip during workouts, and the natural bass response the brand claims.
Who should buy it: AirPods Pro owners who find the stock silicone tips slippery, prone to loosening mid-run, or simply uncomfortable after an hour. The ISO-9 sweat-resistant layer and ergonomic shape are clearly aimed at workouts and long listening sessions. The kit also fits inside the AirPods charging case, so there's no need to remove tips before charging.
Who should skip it: anyone who doesn't own AirPods Pro, anyone unwilling to spend a few sessions fine-tuning depth and rotation, and anyone expecting a one-size-fits-all answer. If you want zero fiddling, foam may not be your material. And if you own an AirPods Pro 3, confirm you're buying the correct longer-adapter variant rather than the AirPods Pro 1 & 2 version.
The XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads are exactly what the name says: a single pair of memory foam earpads built to replace the worn-out cushions on Logitech G Pro and G Pro X gaming headphones. The construction is described as football net plus sponge, finished in black, with high elasticity and a soft, comfortable feel. The stated goal is straightforward — swap your flattened, cracked or missing earpads and give the headset a fresh look and a fresh feel.
This is a maintenance part, not an upgrade path. The brand notes that new ear cotton can improve the bass performance of your headphones, which is a reasonable claim: a pad that seals properly against your head generally delivers more low-end than a compressed, disintegrating one. But the core appeal is restoration. If your G Pro or G Pro X still works perfectly and only the cushions have given up, replacing them is far more sensible than retiring the whole headset.
Who should buy it: Logitech G Pro / G Pro X owners with worn, torn or lost earpads who want a like-for-like replacement in black memory foam. It's also a reasonable pick if you simply want a spare pair on hand before the originals fail.
Who should skip it: anyone with a different headset brand or model — compatibility is explicitly limited to the G Pro and G Pro X. Also skip it if you were hoping for a choice of sizes, colors or materials; this is one pair, one color, one spec. And note the warranty is listed as 30 (days), which is short, so check the fit carefully once it arrives.
• Best for AirPods Pro comfort and seal → AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium. Tapered front, widened rear, memory foam that conforms instead of sitting rigid.
• Best for sweaty workouts → AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium. The ISO-9 layer is specifically described as sweat-resistant with strong grip.
• Best for noise isolation and bass on earbuds → AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium. Passive isolation and natural bass response are the stated benefits of the foam seal.
• Best for finding your exact size → AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium. The assorted S/M/L pack exists precisely so you can test all three.
• Best for reviving a Logitech G Pro / G Pro X → XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads. Direct compatibility, memory foam, one pair, done.
• Best for a simple like-for-like swap → XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads. No sizing decisions, no variant confusion — just replace the old cushions.
• Best for a spare set on the shelf → XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads. One pair per pack makes stocking a backup easy.
• Best for long-term value on AirPods Pro → AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium. Three pairs in one kit plus a one-year warranty description gives you more to work with over time.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the AutoLine Pro Foam Masters Ultra-Premium. In my opinion it's the more interesting product: the ISO-9 memory foam, the tapered ergonomic shape and the three-size pack give you real levers to pull on fit, grip and isolation, and the one-year warranty description backs it up. That said, my recommendation only holds if you own AirPods Pro. If your problem is a Logitech G Pro or G Pro X with dead earpads, the XBERSTAR pair is the correct, honest fix — cheaper in effort, narrower in scope, and it does exactly one job. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your device.
They're not comparable products. AutoLine Pro makes memory foam ear tips for AirPods Pro; XBERSTAR makes replacement earpads for Logitech G Pro / G Pro X headsets. "Better" only means "fits your device."
No. Compatibility is limited to Logitech G Pro and G Pro X. If you have a different model, these pads aren't designed for it.
Foam conforms to your ear canal better than silicone, so it typically improves passive isolation. AutoLine Pro states better active noise cancellation (isolation) and natural bass as benefits, and lets you adjust depth and rotation to tune the seal.
Match it to your AirPods Pro generation. The AirPods Pro 1 & 2 version uses a shorter adapter; the AirPods Pro 3 version uses a longer one. Confirm your model before ordering, and start with the assorted S/M/L pack so you can test sizes.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.