How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-02 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH — biggest strength: closed-back isolation plus 45 mm drivers and a detachable, highly directional boom mic, all under 230 g.
• Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH — biggest trade-off: no virtual surround, no USB, and it runs on analog 3.5 mm jacks only.
• FIFINE USB Gaming Headset — biggest strength: open-back earcups, 53 mm drivers and 7.1 virtual surround over USB for positional awareness.
• FIFINE USB Gaming Headset — biggest trade-off: open-back design leaks sound both ways, and it has no noise control and no Xbox support.
• Pick Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH if you play on multiple platforms, share a room, or want a mic you can remove.
• Pick FIFINE USB Gaming Headset if you're deskbound on PC, Mac or PS5 and want plug-and-play surround with RGB.
The ATH-GL3WH is built around one idea: keep outside noise out and keep your voice clean. Closed-back earcups give it real passive isolation, so a fan, a keyboard or a noisy room doesn't bleed into what you hear. Inside, 45 mm dynamic drivers cover a claimed 10 Hz to 35,000 Hz range at 45 ohms. That's a wide frequency spread, and it's the kind of tuning that favors detail and clarity over a bass-heavy thump. If you like hearing reverb tails, distant footsteps and the texture of a soundtrack, this is the more analytical listen of the two.
The mic is the standout. It's a flexible boom with highly directional pickup and a windscreen, and it detaches completely when you're not using it — which turns the headset into a plain pair of headphones for music or calls. Volume and mute live on the left earcup, so you're not hunting for a cable control. At 228 g it's genuinely light for a closed-back over-ear, and the earpads and headpad detach for replacement, which is a nice nod toward longevity.
Two cables ship in the box, and that's the real story here. The 3.0 m cable ends in two 3.5 mm plugs for PC — separate headphone and mic jacks — while the 1.2 m cable uses a single 3.5 mm TRRS plug for modern consoles. Swapping cables takes seconds.
Who should buy it: multi-platform players, people in shared or noisy spaces, anyone who wants a removable mic, and buyers who prefer a wired analog connection they can plug into a controller, a phone, a DAC or an audio interface. Who should skip it: people who want virtual surround processing, RGB lighting, or a single-cable USB setup. There's also no software suite here — what you plug into is what you get. And the white plastic finish is a look you either like or you don't. If you're price-sensitive, check the current price on Amazon before deciding; this page doesn't quote figures.
The FIFINE H19BP goes the opposite direction: open-back, spacious, and processed. Its 53 mm dynamic drivers are the largest in this comparison, and they're paired with 7.1 virtual surround delivered over USB. The open-back earcups let air move, which creates a wider, more natural soundstage — the design's whole selling point is that you can tell whether a sound came from the left-front bush or the right-back room. For FPS players who live and die by positional audio, that's the pitch, and the spec sheet backs the intent: open-back cups, big drivers, virtual surround.
Comfort is handled differently too. Instead of padding alone, FIFINE uses breathable mesh fabric and open-back earcups specifically to cut heat and pressure over long sessions. If you've ever peeled off a closed headset after four hours with sweaty ears, you know why that matters. It's listed at 0.7 kg, which is a shipping-weight figure rather than a bare headset weight, so I'd treat the on-head feel as something the breathable mesh is designed to address rather than something the numbers settle.
Then there's the convenience layer. One USB-A cable — 7.55 ft of braided — handles everything, plug-and-play on Windows, Mac, PS5 and PS4 with no extra software. There's an in-line control box with push-button volume, EQ tuning and audio profiles, plus 11 RGB lighting modes you can switch off entirely if you want a clean look. Sensitivity is rated at 108 dB with 32 ohms impedance, and the frequency range is 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz.
The trade-offs are honest and worth stating. Open-back means sound leaks out and in — fine in a private room, less fine next to a sleeping partner or on a mic that picks up your speakers. There's no noise control at all. And the compatibility note is blunt: it does not work with Xbox or with PS controllers, so it's a desk-and-console setup, not a couch-and-controller one. Cable runs are long enough to reach behind a tower or entertainment unit, which suits that use case.
• Best isolation and quiet-room focus → Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH (closed-back earcups, passive sound isolation).
• Best spatial awareness in FPS → FIFINE USB Gaming Headset (open-back design plus 7.1 virtual surround over USB).
• Best for multi-platform use → Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH (3.5 mm TRRS for consoles, dual 3.5 mm plugs for PC, two cables included).
• Best for PC-only plug-and-play → FIFINE USB Gaming Headset (single USB-A connection, no software needed).
• Best for long, hot sessions → FIFINE USB Gaming Headset (breathable mesh fabric and open-back airflow).
• Best for voice clarity and a removable mic → Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH (directional detachable boom mic with windscreen).
• Best for customization → FIFINE USB Gaming Headset (11 RGB modes, EQ tuning, audio profiles).
• Best for shared spaces and streaming → Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH (closed-back keeps sound in; open-back leaks both ways).
• Best for replacement parts and longevity → Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH (detachable earpads and headpad, two-year limited warranty).
In my opinion, the Audio-Technica ATH-GL3WH is the safer buy for most people. It works across PC and consoles, it isolates you from a noisy room, its mic comes off when you don't need it, and its parts are replaceable. That's a lot of flexibility for one headset. I'd only steer you to the FIFINE H19BP if you're committed to a PC, Mac or PS5 desk setup and you specifically want open-back spatial audio with 7.1 surround and RGB. If you play competitive FPS in a quiet room, the FIFINE's soundstage is the more exciting pick. Otherwise, the Audio-Technica is the one I'd take.
FAQ
No. FIFINE states the H19BP is not compatible with Xbox or with PS controllers. It works with Windows, Mac and PS5/PS4 over USB-A, so plan for a desk or console setup rather than a wireless controller.
No. It's described as plug-and-play on PC, Mac and PS5/PS4 with no additional software required. The in-line control box handles volume, EQ tuning and lighting, so setup is essentially plug in and go.
Yes — that's the design. Use the 1.2 m 3.5 mm TRRS cable for modern consoles and the 3.0 m cable with separate 3.5 mm headphone and mic plugs for PC. Both are detachable, so switching takes a moment.
It comes down to what you'd otherwise buy separately. The ATH-GL3WH bundles two cables, a detachable boom mic and replaceable pads; the FIFINE bundles USB surround, RGB and EQ control. Check the current price on Amazon for each and weigh those extras against your setup.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: iClever BTH26 vs Aurotlu Open Ear Headphones, AZLA SednaEarfit MAX vs Xmenha True: TWS Headphones, Matast Earbuds 2026 vs Cillso Earbuds, Onkyo Headphone Amplifier DAC vs Casio CT-S200RD