How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want accurate, isolating headphones for tracking and mixing, choose Audio Technica ATH-M40x; if you need a complete recording front end with multiple ins and outs, choose Focusrite Scarlett 4i4. These two products answer completely different questions, and that's the whole point of this comparison. One is a monitoring tool you wear; the other is the hub everything plugs into. Here's how to decide which one actually belongs on your desk.
• Audio Technica ATH-M40x — biggest strength: 40 mm drivers tuned flat across a 15–24,000 Hz range, with 90° swiveling earcups and a detachable cable for tracking, mixing and one-ear monitoring. Biggest trade-off: it's wired only, closed-back, and offers no inputs, outputs or software of its own.
• Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 — biggest strength: a 4-in/4-out USB interface with Hi-Z instrument inputs, Air mode, Loopback and four line outputs for two monitor setups. Biggest trade-off: it does nothing on its own — you still need headphones or monitors, plus a computer, to hear anything.
• Pick the ATH-M40x if your job is listening critically, tracking quietly, or DJ monitoring without disturbing the room.
• Pick the Scarlett 4i4 if your job is getting microphones, guitars and synths into a computer with clean conversion and flexible routing.
The ATH-M40x is a closed-back dynamic studio monitor headphone built around 40 mm drivers with rare earth magnets and copper-clad aluminum wire voice coils. Audio-Technica tunes it flat across 15–24,000 Hz, which is the spec that matters most here: this is a headphone meant to tell you the truth about a mix rather than flatter it. Sensitivity is rated at 98 dB and impedance at 35 ohms, so it's easy to drive from a laptop, a phone with an adapter, or a modest interface headphone output. The 6.35 mm jack and included screw-on 1/4" adapter cover both consumer and pro connections.
Who should buy it: producers, engineers and DJs who need one reliable, isolating, wired reference headphone that works with nearly any source and travels well. Who should skip it: anyone who needs to plug in a microphone, a guitar, or multiple monitors — the M40x has no inputs and no outputs beyond its cable.
Focusrite Scarlett 4i4: Who It's For
The Scarlett 4i4 (4th Gen) is a USB audio interface — the box that turns analog sound into something your computer can record. Its headline numbers are a 69 dB gain range and a 120 dB dynamic range, which is the kind of converter performance Focusrite borrows from its high-end studio interfaces. Practically, that means clean, detailed recordings of quiet sources without hiss, and enough headroom to capture loud ones without clipping.
Connectivity is the real story. You get four inputs, including Hi-Z instrument and line inputs, so guitars, synths and groove boxes plug straight in without a DI box. You get four line outputs, which lets you run two separate monitor setups with independent mixes or patch outboard gear and effects back into your DAW. Air mode re-voices the preamps to add high-end presence and harmonic drive to vocals and instruments — a character switch you can leave on for lead tracks. Loopback sends stereo audio from your music apps and other software directly into your DAW, which is genuinely handy for streaming, podcasting or sampling. Dynamic Gain Halos give you a visual cue for setting levels quickly, and Focusrite's Easy Start tool walks you through setup.
The bundle matters too: it includes a pair of TX-100 closed-back studio headphones, two 6-foot instrument cables and two 25-foot XLR microphone cables. That's a working setup in one box — interface, monitoring and cabling. At 1.75 pounds it's a desktop unit, not a portable one, and it needs a computer to function.
Who should buy it: singer-songwriters, podcasters, streamers and small project studios that need to record several sources at once and route them flexibly. Who should skip it: anyone who just wants to listen. Without a computer and headphones or monitors, the 4i4 makes no sound at all.
• Best for critical listening and mixing → Audio Technica ATH-M40x. Flat tuning across 15–24,000 Hz and closed-back isolation are built for judging a mix.
• Best for recording microphones and instruments → Focusrite Scarlett 4i4. Four inputs with Hi-Z and line options plus 69 dB of gain range.
• Best for one-ear tracking and DJ work → Audio Technica ATH-M40x. The 90° swiveling earcups exist for exactly this.
• Best for routing and monitoring flexibility → Focusrite Scarlett 4i4. Four line outputs support two monitor pairs with separate mixes.
• Best for portability → Audio Technica ATH-M40x. It collapses, weighs 240 g, and runs from anything with a headphone jack.
• Best for a complete starter rig → Focusrite Scarlett 4i4. The bundle includes headphones and cables, so you can record the day it arrives.
• Best if you already own an interface → Audio Technica ATH-M40x. It's the missing monitoring link, not a replacement for your recording chain.
• Best if you already own headphones → Focusrite Scarlett 4i4. It's the missing front end, and it even ships with a spare pair.
In my opinion, most people searching this comparison should buy the Focusrite Scarlett 4i4. Here's my reasoning: if you're comparing a headphone against an interface, you're probably trying to start recording, and the 4i4 is the part you can't work around — it's the thing microphones and guitars actually plug into. Buy the ATH-M40x instead only if you already have a way to get sound into your computer and simply need honest, isolating monitoring. Both are excellent at their jobs; the 4i4 is just the harder one to substitute.
FAQ
No. At 35 ohms and 98 dB sensitivity it runs fine from a laptop or phone, and the included 1/4" adapter covers pro gear. An interface only helps if you're recording, not just listening.
No. It's a USB interface, so it needs a computer to convert and route audio. It also has no built-in speakers or included monitoring beyond the bundled TX-100 headphones — plan accordingly.
In my opinion, buy the Scarlett 4i4 first if you have nothing, because you can't record without an interface. Buy the ATH-M40x first if you already have an interface and need better monitoring. If price is the deciding factor, check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.