How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a big, no-fuss supply of disposable round liners for classic 9-inch cake pans and springform tins, choose Atchake 120Pcs; if you need reusable, custom-molded silicone inserts for a Ninja Crispi Pro AS101CY glass air fryer basket, choose GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer.
• Atchake 120Pcs — biggest strength: 120 pre-cut 9-inch rounds made from heavy-duty silicone-coated wood pulp paper, heat resistant to 446°F, so you place one and bake with zero trimming.
• GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer — biggest strength: A reusable 2-pack (1 large + 1 small) molded specifically for the Ninja Crispi Pro AS101CY 2.5QT and 6QT glass baskets, with raised ridges for airflow and grease drainage, good to 450°F.
• GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: It only fits that specific Ninja model, and it's a basket insert rather than a flat liner, so it's not a universal kitchen tool.
• Who each is for: Atchake for home bakers running round cakes, cheesecakes and tortilla pressing; GreeSuit for Ninja Crispi Pro AS101CY owners who air fry often and hate scrubbing.
Atchake 120Pcs is a straightforward problem-solver: you bake in round pans, and you're tired of greasing, flouring and praying the cake releases. Each sheet is pre-cut to 9 inches round, made from unbleached, food-grade wood pulp paper with a silicone coating on both faces. That coating is what does the work — it gives you a genuinely non-stick surface so cakes, cheesecakes, tarts and deep-dish pizza lift out clean, with no residue left behind on your springform tin. The paper is described as heavy duty and thicker than standard, which matters when you're baking something wet or heavy for a long stretch.
The heat rating is the other number worth knowing: up to 446°F (230°C). That covers essentially every normal home baking temperature, and the sheets are also fine in toaster ovens, microwaves and tortilla presses. The 9-inch cut is the "perfect size" claim in the specs, and for standard 9-inch cake pans and pots it's accurate — no measuring, no scissors, no ragged edges that let batter sneak underneath.
Buy it if you bake regularly in 9-inch round pans and want to skip the grease-and-flour ritual and the soak-and-scrub afterwards. A 120-count pack means you're not rationing sheets or running out mid-project. Skip it if your baking is mostly rectangular — sheet pans, 9x13 brownies, loaf tins — because a 9-inch circle simply won't fit those, and you'd be trimming every single time, which defeats the whole point. Skip it too if you want a reusable product; this is a disposable liner by design, and that's the trade-off you accept for the convenience.
GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer is a very different animal, and it's deliberately narrow. These are reusable silicone basket liners precision-molded to match the Ninja Crispi Pro AS101CY glass baskets — one smaller liner for the 2.5-quart basket and one larger for the 6-quart. That specificity is the entire value proposition. Because they follow the exact contours of the basket, you're not losing usable cooking area to a generic round or square insert that leaves gaps around the edges. GreeSuit does tell you plainly to measure your basket dimensions before buying, and you should take that seriously: these fit that model, not air fryers in general.
The design details are where this product earns its place. The bottom is raised into ridges rather than flat. Those ridges do two jobs. First, they lift food slightly so 360° hot air can circulate underneath, which is what separates crisp results from the soggy-bottom problem people complain about with crowded baskets. Second, the grooves channel rendered fat and oil away from the food instead of letting it pool and re-soak. For anyone air frying chicken thighs, bacon, frozen snacks or weekly meal-prep vegetables, that's a real functional difference, not decoration.
Then there's the protection angle. A glass air fryer basket is the part you look at, and it's the part that shows every baked-on crumb, sauce splatter and melted-cheese stain. These liners sit between the food and the glass, so the basket stays clean and unscratched. In practice that means you rinse a flexible silicone insert instead of scrubbing a glass vessel — hand rinse or top-rack dishwasher both work. The silicone is food-grade and rated to 450°F without warping or melting, and the thickened side tabs give you a cool, secure grip to lift a hot liner straight out.
Buy it if you own the Ninja Crispi Pro AS101CY, cook in it more than occasionally, and want to stop buying disposable liners while keeping the glass basket pristine. Skip it if you don't own that specific model, or if you'd rather not deal with washing anything — for you, paper is the easier answer.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Ninja Crispi Pro AS101CY owners → GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer. Molded to the 2.5QT and 6QT glass baskets specifically.
• Best for high-heat headroom → GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer. 450°F versus Atchake's 446°F — both cover normal cooking; the silicone edges ahead slightly.
• Best for zero washing up → Atchake 120Pcs. Bake, lift out, dispose. Nothing to rinse.
• Best for long-term value and less waste → GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer. Reusable 2-pack replaces disposable liners indefinitely.
• Best for crisping and grease drainage → GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer. Raised ridges lift food for airflow and channel oil away.
• Best for a big, ready supply → Atchake 120Pcs. 120 sheets means you're set for a long run of baking without reordering.
• Best for protecting your appliance → GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer. Shields the glass basket from stains, splatter and scratches.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy GreeSuit Silicone Air Fryer — but only because the two products serve different appliances, and the one I'd reach for most is the one that solves an ongoing chore. A reusable, correctly molded insert that keeps a glass air fryer basket clean, drains grease and improves airflow is a tool I'd use several times a week, and the 2-pack covers both basket sizes. The catch is real: it only makes sense if you own the Ninja Crispi Pro AS101CY. If you don't, Atchake 120Pcs is the better buy — 120 pre-cut 9-inch rounds for round-pan baking is hard to argue with. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever fits your kitchen, since that's the only variable I can't tell you.
FAQ
I don't quote prices here, and the two aren't directly comparable anyway — one is a 120-sheet disposable pack, the other a reusable 2-pack. Compare the current price on Amazon for each against how often you'd actually use it.
Only if it's the Ninja Crispi Pro AS101CY. They're precision-molded for that model's 2.5QT and 6QT glass baskets. GreeSuit advises measuring your basket before buying, and you should.
The sheets are rated to 446°F and safe in toaster ovens and microwaves, but they're cut as 9-inch round pan liners. In an air fryer basket they'd sit loose and can lift into the heating element, so I wouldn't recommend it — use them in your cake pans as intended.
GreeSuit is reusable, so it produces less ongoing waste over time. Atchake is a single-use paper product, though the sheets are unbleached and disposable. If waste reduction matters to you, reusable silicone wins.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Boribim 9 vs Mobestech Silicone Air Fryer, uxcell 18Pcs vs Generic Silicone Air Fryer, GCQFZ Air Fryer Accessories vs Komzon Silicone Air Fryer, AODPWEN 2 vs Onader Air Fryer Basket