How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• ANQIA Extra's biggest strength: 12 x 12 inch square sheets sized for XXXL air fryers, 10QT and above, so a single liner covers the whole basket floor instead of leaving gaps around the edges.
• ANQIA Extra's biggest trade-off: it's a non-porous sheet in a brown color, so it's built for lining and protecting rather than for steam to pass through — and you only get 125 sheets per pack.
• MUELODSIC 500pcs' biggest strength: 500 round perforated liners in one package, in a white silicone-oil-paper material, so you're never rationing them — use one per dumpling batch and toss it.
• MUELODSIC 500pcs' biggest trade-off: the round liners are small, roughly 6.5 inches across, so they suit compact baskets, steamer inserts and single portions rather than a wide XXL air fryer floor.
• Who ANQIA Extra is for: owners of very large air fryers and ovens who want full-basket coverage and hate scrubbing.
• Who MUELODSIC 500pcs is for: steamer users and small-air-fryer cooks who want a deep, disposable supply of round liners.
ANQIA Extra is a liner built around size. The sheets are 12 by 12 inches and square, and the brand positions them for XXXL air fryers — think 10QT and above, or "bigger" as the listing puts it. That's the whole point of this product: when your basket is wide, a small round liner leaves a ring of exposed metal around the food, and that ring is exactly where grease and dumpling drips bake on. A 12-inch square covers the floor properly.
The material is food-grade parchment made from food-grade pulp, brown in color, and it's described as non-sticky. The listing also calls it a "non-porous super size" sheet, which is worth understanding before you buy: this is a solid liner, not a perforated one. For dumplings that means it sits under the food as a barrier, keeping the basket clean and helping dumplings and breads hold their shape. You get 125 sheets in the pack, in a single size.
MUELODSIC 500pcs: Who It's For
MUELODSIC 500pcs is the volume play. Five hundred round liners, roughly 6.5 inches across in the main size listed, made from solvent-free silicone oil paper in white. They have holes — the title calls them "Steamer Liners with Holes" — which changes how they behave. Steam and heat move through them, so they suit steamer baskets and dumpling steamers, not just flat baking.
The listing frames them around cleanup first: keep your air fryer or baking pan free from food residue, protect the basket, make cleanup a breeze. It also notes they keep bacon, fried chicken, fries and similar foods in good shape without affecting taste, and that the paper can absorb excess oil — a small but real plus if you're cooking dumplings that were brushed with oil before going in. The material is food-grade and the sheets can be used directly for holding food, so they double as a serving layer.
Two things to plan around. First, the round shape and roughly 6.5-inch diameter mean these fit compact air fryers, steamer inserts, bamboo steamers and single portions — not a wide XXL basket floor. Second, the product data lists a sheet count of 1 and a unit count of 1, while the title and package list say 500 liners. That's a listing inconsistency, not a product mystery: if the count matters to you, it's worth confirming what you're getting before ordering.
Who should buy it: steamer cooks, small-air-fryer owners, and anyone who goes through liners fast and doesn't want to think about it. Who should skip it: people with a 10QT-plus air fryer who need full-basket coverage, and anyone who wants a solid liner rather than a perforated one.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a very large air fryer (10QT and up) → ANQIA Extra. 12 x 12 inch square sheets actually cover the basket floor.
• Best for a compact air fryer or steamer insert → MUELODSIC 500pcs. The round 6.5-inch perforated liners are sized for smaller vessels.
• Best for steamer use → MUELODSIC 500pcs. The holes let steam through, which is the point of a steamer liner.
• Best for full-basket protection and less scrubbing → ANQIA Extra. One solid sheet catches drips across the whole floor.
• Best for a long supply you won't ration → MUELODSIC 500pcs. 500 liners versus 125.
• Best for oven, microwave and general baking → ANQIA Extra. The listing explicitly covers air fryer, microwave, oven, steamer and cooker.
• Best if you dislike trimming liners to fit → ANQIA Extra, provided your basket is actually the large size it's made for.
If I were buying for dumplings in a big air fryer, I'd take ANQIA Extra. The 12 x 12 inch square size is the deciding factor: it covers a large basket in one piece, keeps dumplings and breads from sticking and holding their shape, and does the one job that matters most — keeping the basket clean. I'd choose MUELODSIC 500pcs instead if my setup is a steamer basket or a small air fryer, or if I simply want a huge stack of round perforated liners on hand and don't care about full-basket coverage. Match the liner to the size of the thing you're cooking in, and either one does its job well.
how to air fry dumplings
Put a liner down first so the basket stays clean and the dumplings don't stick, then arrange them in a single layer with a little space between each one. ANQIA Extra's 12 x 12 inch square sheet is the better fit for a large basket; MUELODSIC's round perforated liners suit a compact one. Either way, keep them from touching so they cook evenly.
how to air fry dumplings from frozen
Frozen dumplings go straight in — no thawing needed. Line the basket, place them in a single layer, and leave gaps so heat can move around them. MUELODSIC's perforated liners let air and steam pass through, which helps with the moisture frozen dumplings release, while ANQIA Extra's solid sheet keeps that moisture and any oil off the basket floor.
how to air fry dumplings not frozen
Fresh or thawed dumplings are more delicate, so a liner matters more here. A non-stick sheet keeps them intact and helps them hold their shape, which is exactly what both listings describe. Use one liner per batch, single layer, and don't crowd the basket — the 500-count MUELODSIC pack makes tossing a liner after every batch painless.
how to make air fryer dumplings
Line the basket, arrange the dumplings in one even layer, and cook until the wrappers are crisp and the filling is hot. The liner is doing two jobs: stopping stick and catching drips. ANQIA Extra covers a wide basket in one 12 x 12 inch sheet; MUELODSIC gives you 500 round 6.5-inch perforated liners, so you can use a fresh one every time without thinking about it. For current pricing on either, check the button on this page.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Healifty 200Pcs vs HANWER 100: Air Fryer Dumplings, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Grill vs ANQIA Non-Stick Disposable Air, Hinthetall Peach Blossoms Pressure vs Zephyrovelle Peaches Rice Cooker