This paper develops a general equilibrium model of firm and investment dynamics to study the sources of the divergence between a persistently high measured return on capital and a declining risk-free rate in the U.S. since the 1980s. The framework delivers a closed-form decomposition of the gap between the two rates into profits, risk premia, capital gains, taxes, capital wedges, and aggregation, together with an identification strategy applicable to standard data sources. Applying the framework to U.S. firms, we find that capital wedges account for about 70 percent of this divergence, while risk premia and profits explain the rest. The rise in wedges is a within-firm phenomenon, associated with intangible capital and hurdle-rate wedges that slow capital accumulation. These same forces imply that the true return on capital has declined alongside the risk-free rate and are also consistent with slower productivity growth and rising stock market valuations.